Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2022.
World J Clin Cases. May 6, 2022; 10(13): 4064-4071
Published online May 6, 2022. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v10.i13.4064
Table 1 Comparison of baseline data between the two groups, n (%)
Group
Cases
Male
Age (yr)
Body mass index (kg/m2)
ASA
Fracture type
I
II
Femoral neck
Tibiofibula
Intertrochanteric femoral
Observation group6036 (60.00)57.64 ± 11.3522.7 ± 3.1140 (66.67)20 (33.33)20 (33.33)24 (40.00)16 (26.67)
Control group6042 (70.00)58.80 ± 12.2023.0 ± 2.9538 (63.33)22 (36.67)18 (30.00)26 (43.33)16 (26.67)
t/χ2 value1.319-0.539 -0.470 0.1470.185
P value0.2510.591 0.639 0.7020.912
Table 2 Comparison of mean arterial pressure, heart rate and blood oxygen saturation in different time periods between the two groups
Index
Cases
T0
T1
T2
T3
T4
MAP (mmHg)
Observation group6092.54 ± 8.1194.40 ± 7.1090.84 ± 7.2191.03 ± 6.8490.42 ± 7.12
Control group6093.01 ± 7.8086.45 ± 6.5882.30 ± 7.1583.39 ± 6.8490.05 ± 6.10
t value-0.3246.3616.5156.1180.306
P value0.7470.0000.0000.0000.760
HR (times/min)
Observation group6082.21 ± 3.8276.60 ± 7.5275.40 ± 8.0376.64 ± 7.1181.21 ± 6.64
Control group6082.05 ± 3.9588.15 ± 6.9471.03 ± 7.2270.45 ± 6.2083.35 ± 7.10
t value0.226-8.7433.1355.083-1.705
P value0.8220.0000.0020.0000.091
SpO2 (%)
Observation group6097.78 ± 1.2297.87 ± 1.1297.68 ± 1.2098.00 ± 1.1298.11 ± 1.14
Control group6097.03 ± 1.3597.70 ± 1.1097.79 ± 1.2397.76 ± 1.2298.03 ± 1.18
t value3.1930.839-0.4961.1230.378
P value0.0020.4030.6210.2640.706
Table 3 Comparison of visual analog score between the two groups
Groups
Cases
VAS scores (points)
2 h after surgery
6 h after surgery
12 h after surgery
24 h after surgery
Observation group603.55 ± 0.872.84 ± 0.652.05 ± 0.401.87 ± 0.33
Control group605.84 ± 1.003.40 ± 0.702.66 ± 0.382.00 ± 0.41
t value-13.383-4.541-8.564-1.913
P value0.0000.0000.0000.058
Table 4 Comparison of adrenaline and Noradrenaline before and after operation between the two groups
Groups
Cases
Adrenaline (pg/ml)
Noradrenaline (pg/ml)
Preoperative
6 h after anesthesia
Preoperative
6 h after anesthesia
Observation group60104.43 ± 32.2181.10 ± 21.19a630.12 ± 102.23510.20 ± 98.27a
Control group60108.29 ± 30.1192.11 ± 15.53a634.49 ± 101.12572.21 ± 91.54a
t value-0.678-3.246-0.235-3.577
P value0.4990.0020.8140.001
Table 5 Comparison of operation time and postoperative recovery time between the two groups
Groups
Cases
Operation time (min)
Postoperative recovery time (min)
Observation group60134.15 ± 32.4515.51 ± 4.21
Control group60138.84 ± 38.8019.46 ± 3.80
t value-0.718-5.395
P value0.4740.000
Table 6 Comparison of mini mental state examination score between preoperative and postoperative
Groups
Cases
Preoperative
Postoperative 1 d
Observation group6028.10 ± 2.0125.51 ± 1.15a
Control group6028.03 ± 1.8224.12 ± 1.04a
t value0.2006.944
P value0.8420.000
Table 7 Comparison of complications between the two groups, n (%)
Groups
Cases
Nausea and vomiting
Sleepiness
Respiratory depression
Bradycardia
Observation group603 (5.00)4 (6.67)2 (3.33)3 (5.00)
Control group602 (3.33)5 (8.33)1 (1.67)2 (3.33)
χ20.0000.0000.0000.000
P value1.0001.0001.0001.000