Closed loop ileus caused by a defect in the broad ligament: A case report

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Closed loop ileus caused by entrapment of bowel in a defect of the broad ligament is a rarity. Only a few cases have been reported in the literature.

CASE SUMMARY

We present the case of a 44-year-old, healthy patient with no prior history of abdominal surgery who developed a closed loop ileus due to an internal hernia secondary to a defect in the right broad ligament. She first presented to the emergency department with diarrhea and vomiting. As she had had no previous abdominal surgery, she was diagnosed with probable gastroenteritis and discharged. The patient subsequently returned to the emergency department due to a lack of improvement in her symptoms. Blood tests showed an elevated white blood cell count and a closed loop ileus was diagnosed on an abdominal computer tomography scan. Diagnostic laparoscopy revealed an internal hernia entrapped in a 2 cm large defect in the right broad ligament. The hernia was reduced and the ligament defect was closed using a running, barbed suture.

CONCLUSION

Bowel incarceration through an internal hernia may present with misleading symptoms and laparoscopy may reveal unexpected findings.

Key Words: Broad ligament; Ileus; Internal hernia; Laparoscopy; Case report

Core Tip: In young patients with negative history of abdominal surgery presenting at the emergency department with nausea and vomiting, the initial differential diagnosis should include ileus. If an ileus is suspected, computer tomography and laparoscopy are the diagnostic tools of choice. Internal hernias are rare, especially those through the broad ligament, but they should be considered to avoid complications such as bowel necrosis. Because of the rarity of the conditions, there are no studies or long-term data on the best treatment option, but most authors describe a direct defect closure.

INTRODUCTION

Internal hernias are responsible for up to 4% of bowel obstruction in the emergency setting[1,2]. Herniation of the bowel through the broad ligament has been reported to underlie 4%–7% of these cases[2-5]. A computer tomography (CT) scan is the diagnostic tool of choice, however, the cause of bowel obstruction is usually not identified. In this regard, diagnostic laparoscopy plays a crucial role. Not only the area of bowel entrapment can be identified, but the hernia can be reduced, and the defect surgically closed.

The initial clinical presentation may be misleading and non-specific, as affected women have typically not had previous abdominal surgery[5]. Here we present a case of a 44-year-old woman with closed loop ileus caused by a defect in the right broad ligament. The case was reported in accordance with the SCARE 2020 guidelines[6].

CASE PRESENTATION

Chief complaints

A 44-year-old female patient with sudden onset of abdominal pain was assigned to the surgical emergency department by the gynecological ward after exclusion of a gynecological pathology.

History of present illness

The pain was mainly localized in both lower abdominal quadrants and accompanied by nausea without vomiting.

History of past illness

History of past illness was negative.

Personal and family history

She was otherwise healthy, had two children via vaginal delivery, and had no history of abdominal operations.

Physical examination

On clinical examination, pain was found on palpation of the right lower abdominal quadrant without signs of peritonism.

Laboratory examinations

The blood tests showed an elevated white blood cell count (26 g/L) and normal C-reactive protein (CRP).

Imaging examinations

An ultrasound scan could not identify the appendix. However, distended bowel without peristalsis was seen in the right lower quadrant, possibly indicating a segmental obstruction. Because of a lack of previous abdominal operations, an ileus seemed unlikely and the patient was diagnosed with enteritis. She was scheduled for a control the next morning.

Further diagnostic work-up

Within 12 h, the patient was brought back to the emergency department by ambulance and had developed additional vomiting and diarrhea. A diffuse pain on palpation of the lower abdominal quadrants was elicited and stool samples were collected for microbiological analysis. The white blood cell count had fallen to 14 g/L, and the CRP had risen to 20 mg/L. Again, the patient was discharged with the diagnosis of enteritis. On the next day, the patient came to the emergency department again with constant vomiting and new bloody diarrhea. A CT of the abdomen was performed, and a closed loop obstruction was postulated. Moreover, ascites was observed. The CT findings are shown in Figure 1. The patient was scheduled for an emergency laparoscopy which detected herniation of the ileum into a 2 cm defect in the right broad ligament.

Figure 1 computer tomography scan of the abdomen. A: Small bowel distension is observed; B: The dilated small bowel indicates an obstruction; C: The site of change of intestinal caliber is located in the right lower quadrant; D: The cause of obstruction cannot be identified.

FINAL DIAGNOSIS

An internal hernia through the right broad ligament.

TREATMENT

The bowel was successfully reduced and presented no signs of bowel ischemia. Two strangulation marks were identified but appeared to be without transmural necrosis. The defect in the right broad ligament was closed by using a barbed running suture. The intraoperative findings and defect closure are shown in Figure 2. The nasogastric tube could be removed the day after surgery. Food was well tolerated, and the patient was discharged on the third postoperative day.

Figure 2 Intraoperative findings. A: Internal hernia is identified: small bowel incarceration through a defect in the right broad ligament of the uterus (arrow); B: Overview on the anatomy: The defect is caudal to the salpinx and round ligament of the uterus. According to the classification by Cilley et al[13], this classifies as a type I hernia; C: Strangulation marks are indicated by arrows and between which hyperemic bowel can be observed; D: Defect closure with a running suture.

OUTCOME AND FOLLOW-UP

After discharge, no further clinical follow-up was planned in the surgical outpatient clinic and the patient did not present again to the emergency department.

DISCUSSION

Bowel obstruction caused by herniation through the broad ligament is very rare and may occur in healthy patients with no prior history of abdominal surgery. Symptoms including nausea, vomiting and paradoxical diarrhea may therefore be attributed to enteritis, as happened in our case. In a case reported by Agrawal et al[7], a ruptured ovarian cyst was suspected before the exploratory laparotomy was performed and an internal hernia through the broad ligament was detected[7]. Such hernias usually manifest as closed loop obstruction on a CT scan[8,9], but the etiology is hard to detect. Thus, reaching the correct diagnosis may be delayed.

In the literature, only a few similar cases have been described. We were able to perform a laparoscopic hernia reduction and closure of the defect without complications. In other reported cases, the hernia had to be reduced via laparotomy[7-11]. Although the bowel was hyperemic, there were no signs of bowel ischemia, so no bowel resection had to be performed. In contrast, in other reported cases, strangulated bowel had to be resected[10]. In the case reported by Takahashi et al[9], the fallopian tube had to be removed due to necrosis[9]. Hashimoto et al[8] described recurrence of a broad ligament hernia in a 53-year-old woman 10 years after primary repair[8]. In a case reported by Rodrigues et al[12], asymptomatic, internal broad ligament hernia was an incidental finding in an exploratory laparoscopy to recover a lost intrauterine device[12].

According to Cilley et al's classification[13], we report a type I hernia as the defect was located caudal to the round ligament in the broad ligament. A type II hernia would have been located in the mesovarium and mesosalpinx above the round ligament, and a type III hernia has been described as a defect through the meso-ligamentum teres uteri[13]. Broad ligament defects and consecutive hernias can be congenital or acquired[14]. Congenital defects arise from spontaneous rupture of congenital cysts in the broad ligament and are usually bilateral, whereas acquired defects may be secondary to delivery trauma, pregnancy, surgery, or inflammatory disease[9,14]. Inspection of the contralateral broad ligament is important to avoid re-operation, however, guidelines on the optimal defect closure and long-term outcomes are missing.

CONCLUSION

A closed loop ileus due to an internal hernia in patients with a negative history of abdominal surgery may present with misleading symptoms. A CT scan is the diagnostic tool of choice to identify closed loop obstruction, but only laparoscopy can provide the correct diagnosis and treatment. Due to the rarity of broad ligament internal hernias, there is no consensus on the best surgical treatment. Observation of long-term outcomes of the reported cases with regards to hernia recurrence is needed.