Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastroenterol. May 14, 2015; 21(18): 5513-5523
Published online May 14, 2015. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v21.i18.5513
Table 1 Model inputs
ParametersBaseRangeRef.
Costs (I$: equivalent to 2012 USD)
Cost of cancer (annual)I$3376[26-29] (conversion-ratio)
Cost of screening (endoscopy + mucosal iodine staining + biopsy)I$64I$58.5-63.6[13]
Cost of EGDI$35.8[30]
Cost of biopsyI$28.2[30]
Cost of HRMEI$35.8
Cost of EMRI$1292I$1292-1620[13]
Cost of EMR-related strictureI$1111[31] (conversion-ratio)
Cost of EMR-related perforationI$1786[31] (conversion-ratio)
Cost of esophagectomyI$1768I$1485-2171[13]
Cost of post surgery state (annual)I$136[19,27,28] (conversion-ratio)
Discount rate, %0.03
Transition probabilities
Non-neoplasia to mild dysplasiaCalibrated to overall annual ESCC incidence rate by age group-CI5[10]Overall cumulative incidence in follow-up study[11]
Mild to moderate dysplasia
Moderate to severe dysplasia
Severe dysplasia to IMC
IMC to operable cancer
Screening test characteristics (per patient)
Lugol’s iodine testing
Sensitivity0.99[8]
Specificity0.15[8]
HRME testing
Sensitivity0.99[8]
Specificity0.82[8]
Efficacy of EMR
Complete long-term remission0.62[32]
Adherence rate (compliance of screening)
After positive biopsy0.70[13]
Procedure characteristics
Operative candidate, cancer0.86[33]
Surgical resectability rate
Surveillance0.76[33]
No surveillance0.33[14,15]
Complications of therapy
Post-EMR stricture rate0.05[34]
Post-EMR perforation rate0.02[34]
Post-RFA structure rate0.14[25]
Complication rate from EGD< 0.01[14,35,36]
Mortality from EGD complication< 0.01[14,35,36]
Table 2 Esophageal squamous cell carcinoma incidence in China by age
Age (yr)Incidence (per 100000)
5017.32
5526.61
6036.35
6556.58
7077.50
75117.48
80143.29
85143.17
Table 3 Base case results
StrategyCost (I$)QALYsICER (I$)Unadjusted LYs
Average-risk population
No screening5015.6725-22.1245
Lugol’s iodine screening66515.7158Weakly dominated22.1989
HRME screening69615.71841180822.2032
High-risk population
No screening129713.6188-18.8274
Lugol’s iodine screening244914.7408102720.6889
HRME screening291114.7973817320.7764