Observational Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Clin Cases. Dec 6, 2021; 9(34): 10576-10584
Published online Dec 6, 2021. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v9.i34.10576
Table 1 Comparison of baseline data between the two groups, n (%)
Parameter
Control group (n = 60)
Observation group (n = 60)
χ2/t
P value
Gender0.5430.461
Male36 (75.00)32 (53.33)
Female24 (35.00)28 (46.67)
Age (yr)58.69 ± 10.1359.41 ± 11.050.3720.711
Course (yr)6.36 ± 1.246.24 ± 1.570.4650.643
History of smoking1.2340.267
Yes22 (36.67)28 (46.67)
No38 (63.33)32 (53.33)
NYHA classification0.5340.465
31 (51.67)27 (45.00)
29 (48.33)33 (55.00)
Heart-based diseases 2.3940.495
Dilated cardiomyopathy5 (8.33)9 (15.00)
Rheumatic heart disease10 (16.67)12 (20.00)
Coronary heart disease18 (30.00)19 (31.67)
High blood pressure27 (45.00)20 (33.33)
Combined diseases
Hyperlipidemia15 (25.00)21 (35.00)1.4290.232
Hypertension30 (50.00)33 (55.00)0.3010.583
Diabetes19 (31.67)15 (25.00)0.6570.418
Education1.2950.523
Junior high school and below12 (20.00)9 (15.00)
Secondary and tertiary24 (40.00)21 (35.00)
Undergraduate and above24 (40.00)30 (50.00)
Table 2 Comparison of heart function between the two groups (mean ± SD)
Group
Number of cases
LVEF (%)
SV (mL)
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Control6034.23 ± 4.2648.23 ± 4.63a91.02 ± 5.87103.22 ± 6.32a
Observation6033.97 ± 4.5160.44 ± 4.58a89.63 ± 6.87112.02 ± 5.78a
t0.32514.5221.1917.959
P value0.7460.0000.2360.000
Table 3 Comparison of 6-min walking distance, high-sensitivity cardiac troponin, N-terminal pro B-type natriuretic peptide between the two groups
Group
Number of cases
6MWD (m)
hs-cTnT (µg/L)
NT-proBNP (µg/L)
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Control60352.69 ± 57.89468.22 ± 67.41a0.70 ± 0.220.48 ± 0.15a3.85 ± 0.242.78 ± 0.16a
Observation60346.85 ± 62.08519.36 ± 57.23a0.72 ± 0.210.37 ± 0.12a3.87 ± 0.251.95 ± 0.14a
t0.5334.4800.5094.4360.44730.240
P value0.5950.0000.6110.0000.6560.000
Table 4 Comparison of Self-Care Ability Scale scores between the two groups (mean ± SD, subdivision)
Group
Number of cases
Self-care responsibility
Self-concept
Self-care skills
Self-care health knowledge
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Control6019.16 ± 2.9421.13 ± 2.32a19.85 ± 3.5622.34 ± 3.69a27.84 ± 3.6531.17 ± 4.69a18.69 ± 3.8523.12 ± 3.55a
Observation6018.97 ± 3.0222.78 ± 3.17a19.74 ± 3.6224.87 ± 4.05a28.01 ± 3.9435.23 ± 4.47a18.75 ± 4.0525.78 ± 4.18a
t0.3493.2540.1683.5770.2454.8540.0833.757
P value0.7280.0010.8670.0010.8070.0000.9340.000
Table 5 Comparison of Minnesota heart failure quality of life scores between the two groups (mean ± SD, subdivision)
Group
Number of cases
Physical limitations
Symptoms of illness
Psychological mood
Social relations
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Control6019.24 ± 2.4615.63 ± 2.01a13.56 ± 2.1211.36 ± 1.75a13.23 ± 1.8511.47 ± 1.38a8.78 ± 1.347.24 ± 1.03a
Observation6019.15 ± 2.7311.67 ± 1.45a13.61 ± 2.0810.02 ± 1.51a13.30 ± 1.769.58 ± 1.05a8.83 ± 1.295.48 ± 0.87a
t0.19012.3760.1304.4910.2128.4430.20810.111
P value0.8500.0000.8960.0000.8320.0000.8350.000
Table 6 Comparison of compliance scores between the two groups (mean ± SD, subdivision)
Group
Number of cases
Reasonable diet
Regular drug use
Health behaviour
Review on time
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Pre-intervention
After intervention
Control605.78 ± 1.327.23 ± 1.45a6.23 ± 0.858.24 ± 0.63a5.41 ± 0.967.58 ± 0.78a5.32 ± 1.147.41 ± 0.82a
Observation605.82 ± 1.078.69 ± 1.12a6.21 ± 0.769.23 ± 0.57a5.32 ± 1.058.75 ± 0.63a5.37 ± 1.038.68 ± 0.67a
t0.1826.1720.1369.0260.4909.0390.2529.290
P value0.8560.0000.8920.0000.6250.0000.8010.000
Table 7 Comparison of adverse cardiovascular events between the two groups
Group
Number of cases
Increased heart failure
Acute myocardial infarction
Severe arrhythmia
Cardiogenic rehospitalization
Hospitalization rate
Hospitalization time
Control605 (8.33)8 (13.33)6 (10.00)17 (28.33)16.25 ± 4.23
Observation 602 (3.33)2 (3.33)3 (5.00)7 (11.67)14.36 ± 3.12
χ2/t1.3653.9271.0815.2082.785
P value0.2430.0480.2980.0220.006