Review
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Clin Cases. Dec 16, 2014; 2(12): 742-756
Published online Dec 16, 2014. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v2.i12.742
Table 1 Comparisons of conventional categories of nebulizers
JetUltrasonicVibrating mesh
Features
Power sourceCompressed gas or electrical mainsElectrical mainsBatteries or electrical mains
PortabilityRestrictedRestrictedPortable
Treatment timeLongIntermediateShort
Output rateLowHigherHighest
Residual volume0.8-2.0 mLVariable but low< 0.2 mL
Environmental contamination
Continuous useHighHighHigh
Breath-activatedLowLowLow
Performance variabilityHighIntermediateLow
Formulation characteristics
TemperatureDecreasesIncreasesMinimum change
ConcentrationIncreasesVariablesMinimum change
SuspensionsLow efficiencyPoor efficiencyVariable efficiency
DenaturationPossibleProbablePossible
CleaningRequired, after single useRequired, after multiple useRequired, after single use
CostVery lowHighHigh
Table 2 Advantages and disadvantages of different nebulizer products
Product nameTypeProsCons
PARI Vios®Jet nebulizerLow operational cost, robust in structure, effective in nebulizing suspensionsRelatively bigger in size and heavier in weight; more noisy
Omron MicroAir®Electronic nebulizerDoes not heat the medicine, quiet and fast drug deliveryComparatively expensive;
Omron NE-U17®, Beurer Nebulizer IH30®Ultrasonic nebulizerSilent and portablereplaced much more frequently
Omron NE-U22V®,Vibrating mesh nebulizerHigher output efficiency, minimal residual volume, and High percentage of particles in the emission, small in sizeLess efficient in nebulizing aerosols
Pari E-Flow®
Pari LCD®Breathe-enhanced nebulizersHigher output efficiency avoiding apparatus loss and exhaled lossN/A
AeroEclipse®Dosimetric nebulizerHigher output efficiency avoiding apparatus loss and exhaled lossN/A