Case Control Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2024.
World J Gastrointest Oncol. Jul 15, 2024; 16(7): 2925-2940
Published online Jul 15, 2024. doi: 10.4251/wjgo.v16.i7.2925
Table 1 Characteristics of colorectal cancer patients with and without disabilities, n (%)
People without disabilitiesPeople with disabilityBy disability grade
By disability type
Grades 1-3
Grades 4-6
Physical
Communication
Brain
Mental
Cardiopulmonary
Others
All subject, n81069196646517131471072752672013463386808
Age, yr
Mean (SD)68.6 (10.4)68.4 (10.5)67.8 (10.8)68.8 (10.3)67.3 (10.2)71.6 (10.4)70.4 (9.3)58.1 (11.5)69.2 (8.2)64.5 (10.7)
19-40700 (0.9)163 (0.8)80 (1.2)83 (0.6)81 (0.8)19 (0.4)7 (0.3)36 (7.8)0 (0)20 (2.5)
40-6527937 (34.5)6992 (35.6)2452 (37.6)4540 (34.5)4274 (39.8)1375 (26.1)533 (26.5)303 (65.4)120 (31.1)387 (47.9)
65-7531156 (38.4)7411 (37.7)2396 (36.8)5015 (38.1)4078 (38.0)1903 (36.1)872 (43.3)101 (21.8)188 (48.7)269 (33.3)
75-21276 (26.2)5098 (25.9)1589 (24.4)3509 (26.7)2294 (21.4)1970 (37.4)601 (29.9)23 (5.0)78 (20.2)132 (16.3)
Female sex27371 (33.8)6460 (32.9)1928 (29.6)4532 (34.5)3717 (34.7)1612 (30.6)604 (30.0)180 (38.9)57 (14.8)290 (35.9)
Charlson comorbidity Score
Mean (SD)2.1 (1.1)2.4 (1.2)2.6 (1.2)2.3 (1.2)2.3 (1.2)2.3 (1.2)2.8 (1.2)2.1 (1.1)2.5 (1.2)3.3 (1.0)
031441 (38.8)5390 (27.4)1597 (24.5)3793 (28.9)3255 (30.3)1601 (30.4)228 (11.3)203 (43.8)33 (8.5)70 (8.7)
120410 (25.2)4501 (22.9)1304 (20.0)3197 (24.3)2571 (24.0)1281 (24.3)395 (19.6)114 (24.6)87 (22.5)53 (6.6)
212609 (15.6)3288 (16.7)1099 (16.9)2189 (16.7)1785 (16.6)900 (17.1)331 (16.4)64 (13.8)93 (24.1)115 (14.2)
37370 (9.1)2378 (12.1)779 (12.0)1599 (12.2)1240 (11.6)596 (11.3)317 (15.7)36 (7.8)71 (18.4)118 (14.6)
≥ 49239 (11.4)4107 (20.9)1738 (26.7)2369 (18.0)1876 (17.5)889 (16.9)742 (36.9)46 (9.9)102 (26.4)452 (55.9)
Comorbidity
Hypertension38225 (47.2)10902 (55.4)3798 (58.3)7104 (54.0)5550 (51.7)2832 (53.8)1580 (78.5)131 (28.3)241 (62.4)568 (70.3)
Diabetes mellitus19632 (24.2)6039 (30.7)2169 (33.3)3870 (29.4)3109 (29.0)1531 (29.1)776 (38.5)82 (17.7)148 (38.3)393 (48.6)
Coronary heart disease9014 (11.1)2737 (13.9)1046 (16.1)1691 (12.9)1343 (12.5)697 (13.2)300 (14.9)25 (5.4)143 (37.0)229 (28.3)
Stroke4240 (5.2)2377 (12.1)1130 (17.3)1247 (9.5)789 (7.4)466 (8.8)998 (49.6)24 (5.2)28 (7.3)72 (8.9)
COPD19331 (23.8)5691 (28.9)1879 (28.8)3812 (29.0)3002 (28.0)1585 (30.1)522 (25.9)89 (19.2)267 (69.2)226 (28.0)
Income
Medical aid3816 (4.7)2536 (12.9)1329 (20.4)1207 (9.2)1155 (10.8)636 (12.1)287 (14.3)254 (54.9)59 (15.3)145 (17.9)
1st quartile (lowest)13784 (17.0)3430 (17.4)955 (14.7)2475 (18.8)2019 (18.8)929 (17.6)255 (12.7)51 (11.0)51 (13.2)125 (15.5)
2nd quartile13123 (16.2)3067 (15.6)946 (14.5)2121 (16.1)1759 (16.4)807 (15.3)272 (13.5)46 (9.9)63 (16.3)120 (14.9)
3rd quartile18562 (22.9)4177 (21.2)1288 (19.8)2889 (22.0)2352 (21.9)1081 (20.5)455 (22.6)55 (11.9)90 (23.3)144 (17.8)
4th quartile (highest)31784 (39.2)6454 (32.8)1999 (30.7)4455 (33.9)3442 (32.1)1814 (34.4)744 (37.0)57 (12.3)123 (31.9)274 (33.9)
Place of residence
Metropolitan46929 (57.9)10620 (54.0)3585 (55.0)7035 (53.5)5646 (52.6)2825 (53.6)1198 (59.5)221 (47.7)210 (54.4)520 (64.4)
City22329 (27.5)6009 (30.6)1983 (30.4)4026 (30.6)3341 (31.1)1633 (31.0)549 (27.3)147 (31.7)120 (31.1)219 (27.1)
Rural11811 (14.6)3035 (15.4)949 (14.6)2086 (15.9)1740 (16.2)809 (15.4)266 (13.2)95 (20.5)56 (14.5)69 (8.5)
Type of cancer
Colon44269 (54.6)10985 (55.9)3711 (56.9)7274 (55.3)5876 (54.8)2949 (56.0)1182 (58.7)278 (60.0)224 (58)476 (58.9)
Rectosigmoid6123 (7.6)1591 (8.1)530 (8.1)1061 (8.1)860 (8.0)449 (8.5)164 (8.1)46 (9.9)24 (6.2)48 (5.9)
Rectum30677 (37.8)7088 (36.0)2276 (34.9)4812 (36.6)3991 (37.2)1869 (35.5)667 (33.1)139 (30.0)138 (35.8)284 (35.1)
Clinical disease status
Localized29934 (36.9)7322 (37.2)2283 (35.0)5039 (38.3)4201 (39.2)1829 (34.7)664 (33.0)123 (26.6)150 (38.9)355 (43.9)
Locoregional34636 (42.7)7985 (40.6)2617 (40.2)5368 (40.8)4319 (40.3)2243 (42.6)832 (41.3)193 (41.7)142 (36.8)256 (31.7)
Metastatic9387 (11.6)2484 (12.6)889 (13.6)1595 (12.1)1279 (11.9)681 (12.9)298 (14.8)88 (19.0)50 (13.0)88 (10.9)
Unknown7112 (8.8)1873 (9.5)728 (11.2)1145 (8.7)928 (8.7)514 (9.8)219 (10.9)59 (12.7)44 (11.4)109 (13.5)
Treatment within 6 months of diagnosis
Polypectomy, EMR, or ESD11527 (14.2)2849 (14.5)877 (13.5)1972 (15.0)1683 (15.7)677 (12.9)223 (11.1)43 (9.3)63 (16.3)160 (19.8)
Surgery only31118 (38.4)7611 (38.7)2492 (38.2)5119 (38.9)4052 (37.8)2132 (40.5)801 (39.8)162 (35.0)147 (38.1)317 (39.2)
Surgery + RT2959 (3.6)587 (3.0)170 (2.6)417 (3.2)347 (3.2)149 (2.8)50 (2.5)11 (2.4)15 (3.9)15 (1.9)
Surgery + Chemo19409 (23.9)4140 (21.1)1233 (18.9)2907 (22.1)2467 (23.0)1058 (20.1)329 (16.3)113 (24.4)68 (17.6)105 (13.0)
Surgery + CCRT 5339 (6.6)1034 (5.3)310 (4.8)724 (5.5)617 (5.8)284 (5.4)79 (3.9)17 (3.7)20 (5.2)17 (2.1)
CCRT691 (0.9)171 (0.9)68 (1.0)103 (0.8)82 (0.8)50 (0.9)15 (0.7)4 (0.9)11 (2.8)9 (1.1)
Chemo only2023 (2.5)558 (2.8)201 (3.1)357 (2.7)300 (2.8)134 (2.5)65 (3.2)23 (5.0)12 (3.1)24 (3.0)
RT only557 (0.7)155 (0.8)58 (0.9)97 (0.7)82 (0.8)44 (0.8)11 (0.5)4 (0.9)5 (1.3)9 (1.1)
No treatment7446 (9.2)2559 (13.0)1108 (17.0)1451 (11.0)1097 (10.2)739 (14.0)440 (21.9)86 (18.6)45 (11.7)152 (18.8)
Screening subset, n187603866856301024471072216275351
Smoking
Current5935 (31.6)1161 (30.0)267 (31.2)894 (29.7)754 (30.8)319 (29.8)58 (26.9)9 (33.3)7 (13.2)14 (27.5)
Past5146 (27.4)1054 (27.3)223 (26.1)831 (27.6)664 (27.1)290 (27.1)64 (29.6)6 (22.2)21 (39.6)9 (17.6)
Non7679 (40.9)1651 (42.7)366 (42.8)1285 (42.7)1029 (42.1)463 (43.2)94 (43.5)12 (44.4)25 (47.2)28 (54.9)
Alcohol intake
Non-drinker2082 (11.1)596 (15.4)151 (17.6)445 (14.8)353 (14.4)149 (13.9)47 (21.8)11 (40.7)19 (35.8)17 (33.3)
Social amount16096 (85.8)3128 (80.9)681 (79.6)2447 (81.3)2007 (82.0)873 (81.4)168 (77.8)15 (55.6)33 (62.3)32 (62.7)
Heavy drinker582 (3.1)142 (3.7)24 (2.8)118 (3.9)87 (3.6)50 (4.7)1 (0.5)1 (3.7)1 (1.9)2 (3.9)
BMI, kg/m2
< 18.5484 (2.6)100 (2.6)39 (4.6)61 (2)52 (2.1)34 (3.2)6 (2.8)2 (7.4)6 (11.3)0 (0)
18.5-23.06105 (32.5)1260 (32.6)314 (36.7)946 (31.4)760 (31.1)367 (34.2)77 (35.6)11 (40.7)24 (45.3)21 (41.2)
23.0-25.05227 (27.9)1009 (26.1)201 (23.5)808 (26.8)650 (26.6)281 (26.2)49 (22.7)8 (29.6)10 (18.9)11 (21.6)
25.0-30.06438 (34.3)1347 (34.8)270 (31.5)1077 (35.8)878 (35.9)358 (33.4)77 (35.6)6 (22.2)12 (22.6)16 (31.4)
≥ 30.0506 (2.7)150 (3.9)32 (3.7)118 (3.9)107 (4.4)32 (3.0)7 (3.2)0 (0)1 (1.9)3 (5.9)
Table 2 Distribution of cancer stage by disability, n (%)
AllBy cancer stage
P value
Localized
Locoregional
Distant
Unknown
No. of patients10073337256 (37.0)42621 (42.3)11871 (11.8)8985 (8.9)
People without disabilities8106929934 (36.9)34636 (42.7)9387 (11.6)7112 (8.8)< 0.0001
People with disability196647322 (37.2)7985 (40.6)2484 (12.6)1873 (9.5)
By disability grades
Severe (Grades 1-3)65172283 (35.0)2617 (40.2)889 (13.6)728 (11.2)< 0.0001
Mild (Grades 4-6)131475039 (38.3)5368 (40.8)1595 (12.1)1145 (8.7)< 0.0001
Grade 1986309 (31.3)365 (37.0)170 (17.2)142 (14.4)
Grade 22402872 (36.3)953 (39.7)299 (12.4)278 (11.6)
Grade 331291102 (35.2)1299 (41.5)420 (13.4)308 (9.8)
Grade 435311276 (36.1)1447 (41.0)470 (13.3)338 (9.6)
Grade 546951812 (38.6)1888 (40.2)573 (12.2)422 (9.0)
Grade 649211951 (39.6)2033 (41.3)552 (11.2)385 (7.8)
By disability types
Physical
Grades 1-32306853 (37.0)937 (40.6)293 (12.7)223 (9.7)
Grades 4-684213348 (39.8)3382 (40.2)986 (11.7)705 (8.4)
Communication
Grades 1-31423464 (32.6)596 (41.9)192 (13.5)171 (12.0)
Grades 4-638441365 (35.5)1647 (42.8)489 (12.7)343 (8.9)
Brain
Grades 1-31400438 (31.3)572 (40.9)219 (15.6)171 (12.2)
Grades 4-6613226 (36.9)260 (42.4)79 (12.9)48 (7.8)
Mental
Grades 1-3463123 (26.6)193 (41.7)88 (19.0)59 (12.7)
Grades 4-6----
Cardiopulmonary
Grades 1-3385149 (38.7)142 (36.9)50 (13.0)44 (11.4)
Grades 4-611 (100.0)0 (0.0)0 (0.0)
Others
Grades 1-3540256 (47.4)177 (32.8)47 (8.7)60 (11.1)
Grades 4-626899 (36.9)79 (29.5)41 (15.3)49 (18.3)
Table 3 Odds ratio for polypectomy, surgery, chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and no treatment
Overall mortality
Total No.
Polypectomy, EMR, ESD
Surgery+
CT+
RT+
No treatment
No
Yes
Model 1
Model 2
No
Yes
Model 1
Model 2
No
Yes
Model 1
Model 2
No
Yes
Model 1
Model 2
No
Yes
Model 1
Model 2
Disability
Non-disabled patients810696954211527REFREF2224458825REFREF5360727462REFREF715239546REFREF736237446REFREF
Disabled patients196641681528491.022 (0.978-1.069)0.998 (0.951-1.048)6292133720.804 (0.777-0.831)0.848 (0.817-0.88)1376159030.837 (0.81-0.866)0.837 (0.805-0.87)1771719470.823 (0.782-0.867)0.895 (0.844-0.950)1710525591.479 (1.410-1.552)1.389 (1.318-1.464)
By disability severity
Grades 1-3651756408770.938 (0.871-1.010)0.909 (0.839-0.986)231242050.688 (0.652-0.725)0.743 (0.700-0.789)470518120.752 (0.711-0.795)0.703 (0.660-0.749)59116060.768 (0.705-0.837)0.866 (0.784-0.956)540911082.025 (1.891-2.170)1.884 (1.744-2.034)
Grades 4-6131471117519721.065 (1.011-1.121)1.041 (0.984-1.101)398091670.871 (0.837-0.907)0.904 (0.865-0.945)905640910.882 (0.848-0.918)0.908 (0.868-0.949)1180613410.851 (0.801-0.904)0.909 (0.849-0.974)1169614511.227 (1.156-1.302)1.166 (1.093-1.243)
Grade 19868791070.735 (0.601-0.899)0.741 (0.598-0.918)4155710.520 (0.458-0.591)0.592 (0.513-0.684)7562300.594 (0.512-0.689)0.508 (0.431-0.598)910760.626 (0.495-0.792)0.772 (0.594-1.004)7312553.452 (2.987-3.988)2.913 (2.476-3.428)
Grade 2240220613410.998 (0.889-1.121)0.941 (0.829-1.068)87715250.657 (0.604-0.715)0.718 (0.653-0.789)17866160.673 (0.614-0.739)0.655 (0.591-0.727)22091930.655 (0.564-0.760)0.811 (0.686-0.959)19824202.095 (1.881-2.334)1.917 (1.701-2.160)
Grade 3312927004290.959 (0.864-1.063)0.937 (0.838-1.049)102021090.782 (0.724-0.844)0.821 (0.755-0.894)21639660.872 (0.807-0.942)0.811 (0.743-0.884)27923370.904 (0.806-1.015)0.927 (0.813-1.058)26964331.588 (1.431-1.762)1.555 (1.388-1.742)
Grade 4353130384930.979 (0.888-1.079)1.040 (0.936-1.155)109724340.839 (0.780-0.902)0.891 (0.823-0.966)247810530.830 (0.771-0.893)0.871 (0.802-0.946)31933380.793 (0.708-0.889)0.893 (0.784-1.016)30754561.466 (1.325-1.622)1.242 (1.113-1.385)
Grade 5469540076881.036 (0.953-1.126)1.018 (0.931-1.114)146032350.838 (0.786-0.893)0.889 (0.829-0.953)329813970.827 (0.775-0.882)0.896 (0.833-0.963)42404550.804 (0.728-0.888)0.882 (0.788-0.986)41365591.336 (1.220-1.464)1.190 (1.078-1.314)
Grade 6492141307911.155 (1.068-1.250)1.062 (0.975-1.157)142334980.930 (0.872-0.991)0.928 (0.866-0.994)328016410.977 (0.919-1.038)0.944 (0.881-1.011)43735480.939 (0.857-1.029)0.944 (0.851-1.048)44854360.961 (0.869-1.064)1.076 (0.966-1.198)
By disability type
Physical
Grades 1-3230619683381.036 (0.922-1.165)0.966 (0.851-1.097)76315430.765 (0.700-0.835)0.791 (0.717-0.871)15737330.910 (0.832-0.994)0.806 (0.729-0.891)20582480.903 (0.790-1.032)0.894 (0.768-1.041)19973091.530 (1.354-1.729)1.636 (1.431-1.870)
Grades 4-68421707613451.147 (1.078-1.220)1.100 (1.028-1.176)248159400.905 (0.862-0.951)0.925 (0.877-0.977)568827330.938 (0.894-0.984)0.937 (0.887-0.989)75418800.874 (0.813-0.941)0.895 (0.824-0.973)76337881.021 (0.945-1.103)1.028 (0.946-1.116)
Communication
Grades 1-3142312551680.808 (0.687-0.950)0.883 (0.743-1.050)4609630.792 (0.708-0.886)0.888 (0.784-1.005)10124110.793 (0.706-0.890)0.855 (0.751-0.973)12911320.766 (0.640-0.917)0.907 (0.74-1.112)11932301.906 (1.652-2.200)1.429 (1.221-1.671)
Grades 4-6384433355090.921 (0.837-1.013)0.967 (0.872-1.072)118426600.850 (0.792-0.911)0.899 (0.832-0.971)272911150.798 (0.743-0.856)0.883 (0.816-0.957)34493950.858 (0.772-0.954)1.008 (0.893-1.138)33355091.509 (1.371-1.662)1.266 (1.141-1.406)
Brain
Grades 1-3140012601400.670 (0.562-0.799)0.684 (0.568-0.824)5608400.567 (0.509-0.632)0.606 (0.537-0.685)10893110.557 (0.491-0.633)0.537 (0.467-0.617)12951050.607 (0.497-0.742)0.758 (0.606-0.948)10463543.346 (2.959-3.784)2.935 (2.557-3.370)
Grades 4-6613530830.945 (0.749-1.192)0.898 (0.699-1.153)1944190.817 (0.688-0.969)0.838 (0.695-1.012)4361770.792 (0.665-0.944)0.808 (0.664-0.982)563500.665 (0.498-0.889)0.792 (0.573-1.093)527861.614 (1.283-2.029)1.651 (1.287-2.119)
Mental
Grades 1-3463420430.618 (0.451-0.846)0.696 (0.498-0.973)1603030.716 (0.591-0.868)0.773 (0.622-0.960)3061571.002 (0.826-1.215)0.588 (0.475-0.728)427360.632 (0.449-0.888)0.627 (0.428-0.919)377862.256 (1.782-2.854)2.366 (1.827-3.064)
Grades 4-6
Cardiopulmonary
Grades 1-3385323621.158 (0.882-1.521)0.970 (0.724-1.301)1352500.700 (0.568-0.864)0.780 (0.620-0.981)2741110.791 (0.634-0.986)0.828 (0.648-1.059)334511.144 (0.851-1.537)1.471 (1.039-2.081)340451.309 (0.958-1.788)1.304 (0.934-1.822)
Grades 4-6101--10--10--10--10--
Other
Grades 1-35404141261.836 (1.503-2.244)1.387 (1.111-1.731)2343060.494 (0.417-0.587)0.573 (0.474-0.693)451890.385 (0.307-0.484)0.406 (0.317-0.520)506340.503 (0.356-0.713)0.691 (0.469-1.018)456841.821 (1.441-2.301)1.858 (1.441-2.396)
Grades 4-6268234340.877 (0.611-1.257)0.659 (0.451-0.962)1201480.466 (0.366-0.594)0.579 (0.444-0.756)202660.638 (0.483-0.842)0.579 (0.426-0.787)252160.476 (0.287-0.789)0.412 (0.241-0.706)200683.362 (2.551-4.431)3.286 (2.415-4.472)
Table 4 Overall and colorectal cancer-specific mortality by disability
Overall mortalityOverall mortality
Cancer-specific mortality
Total No.
No. of death
Incidence rate (per 1000 PY)
Adjusted HR (95%CI)
Total No.
No. of death
Incidence rate (per 1000 PY)
Adjusted HR (95%CI)
Disability
Non-disabled patients810692690851.3REF810691901136.3REF
Disabled patients19664780870.91.244 (1.213-1.277)19664535448.61.192 (1.156-1.229)
By disability severity
Grades 1-36517318194.81.569 (1.512-1.630)6517209162.31.430 (1.366-1.498)
Grades 4-613147462760.51.095 (1.061-1.130)13147326342.71.081 (1.042-1.123)
Grade 1986553124.41.853 (1.702-2.017)98640891.81.831 (1.659-2.022)
Grade 224021260105.01.731 (1.634-1.833)240277564.61.502 (1.397-1.616)
Grade 33129136879.91.372 (1.299-1.449)312990853.01.259 (1.177-1.346)
Grade 43531141572.11.202 (1.139-1.269)3531100451.21.194 (1.120-1.272)
Grade 54695170463.81.097 (1.044-1.152)4695121345.41.092 (1.030-1.157)
Grade 64921150850.01.011 (0.960-1.065)4921104634.70.984 (0.924-1.047)
By disability type
Physical
Grades 1-3230691268.31.311 (1.227-1.401)230664948.61.290 (1.192-1.396)
Grades 4-68421267553.01.044 (1.003-1.087)8421191437.91.042 (0.994-1.093)
Communication
Grades 1-3142365985.91.245 (1.152-1.346)142344658.11.170 (1.065-1.286)
Grades 4-63844156273.01.136 (1.080-1.196)3844109151.01.115 (1.048-1.185)
Brain
Grades 1-31400853144.71.947 (1.817-2.086)1400601101.91.897 (1.747-2.060)
Grades 4-661327588.41.490 (1.322-1.678)61317857.31.369 (1.181-1.588)
Mental
Grades 1-3463219102.12.230 (1.948-2.553)46317380.62.074 (1.781-2.417)
Grades 4-6--------
Cardiopulmonary
Grades 1-3385212110.11.754 (1.532-2.008)38510755.61.257 (1.039-1.520)
Grades 4-611740.919.971 (2.836-140.612)11740.940.45 (5.691-287.489)
Others
Grades 1-3540326126.22.434 (2.179-2.719)54011544.51.318 (1.096-1.586)
Grades 4-626811474.01.191 (0.990-1.432)2687951.31.167 (0.935-1.456)
Table 5 Overall and colorectal cancer-specific mortality with local and locoregional who underwent surgery by disability
Overall mortality
Overall mortality
Cancer-specific mortality
Total No.
No. of death
Incidence rate (per 1000 PY)
Adjusted HR (95%CI)
Total No.
No. of death
Incidence rate (per 1000 PY)
Adjusted HR (95%CI)
Disability
Non-disabled patients595671384232.7REF59567802419.0REF
Disabled patients13532366942.51.234 (1.189-1.280)13532202123.41.171 (1.114-1.23)
By disability severity
Grades 1-34045140056.31.624 (1.535-1.717)404573329.51.453 (1.345-1.569)
Grades 4-69487226936.91.086 (1.038-1.135)9487128820.91.059 (0.998-1.123)
Grade 153919159.01.677 (1.452-1.936)53911635.81.698 (1.411-2.042)
Grade 2152262470.61.993 (1.837-2.162)152229533.41.638 (1.456-1.842)
Grade 3198458545.81.349 (1.242-1.467)198432225.21.260 (1.127-1.410)
Grade 4245967143.11.182 (1.094-1.278)245939225.21.181 (1.067-1.308)
Grade 5334282738.71.118 (1.042-1.200)334247622.31.104 (1.006-1.212)
Grade 6368677131.30.988 (0.918-1.062)368642017.10.927 (0.840-1.023)
By disability type
Physical
Grades 1-3160142940.81.310 (1.189-1.443)160125123.91.303 (1.148-1.479)
Grades 4-66204130031.81.009 (0.953-1.069)620475618.50.995 (0.923-1.072)
Communication
Grades 1-394029949.11.270 (1.132-1.425)94016627.31.211 (1.038-1.413)
Grades 4-6269778045.61.145 (1.065-1.231)269743425.41.113 (1.010-1.226)
Brain
Grades 1-384437681.12.014 (1.816-2.233)84421045.31.938 (1.688-2.226)
Grades 4-643814456.71.555 (1.319-1.834)4387529.51.420 (1.131-1.784)
Mental
Grades 1-32818653.52.016 (1.626-2.499)2815634.81.811 (1.387-2.365)
Grades 4-6
Others
Grades 1-3379210104.63.224 (2.807-3.704)3795024.91.459 (1.102-1.931)
Grades 4-61484546.31.974 (1.473-2.647)1482323.71.775 (1.178-2.674)