Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2024.
World J Gastroenterol. Apr 7, 2024; 30(13): 1887-1898
Published online Apr 7, 2024. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v30.i13.1887
Table 1 Preoperative data of all patients (n = 193): Baseline information and obesity-related comorbidities, n (%)
Baseline
Total, n = 193
Sex (Females)129 (66.8)
Age (yr, mean ± SD)31.5 ± 8.2
Height (cm, mean ± SD)169.3 ± 8.0
Weight (kg, mean ± SD)119.6 ± 27.7
Body mass index (kg/m2, mean ± SD)41.3 ± 7.0
Waistline (cm, mean ± SD)123.2 ± 17.2
Hipline (cm, mean ± SD)129.4 ± 15.7
1FAO113 (58.5)
2FAO58 (30.0)
Obesity-related comorbidities
Metabolic syndrome88 (45.6)
Hypertension67 (34.7)
Cardiovascular disease10 (5.2)
Type 2 diabetes mellitus94 (48.7)
Impaired glucose tolerance78 (40.4)
Hyperlipoidemia81 (42.0)
Obstructive sleep apnea128 (66.3)
Polycystic ovarian syndrome (n = 129)31 (24.0)
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease163 (84.5)
Gout10 (5.2)
Hyperuricemia114 (59.1)
Table 2 Preoperative baseline information
1SO, n = 751FAO, n = 75P value
2SO, n = 542FAO, n = 54P value
Sex [female, n (%)]50 (66.7)48 (64.0)0.73136 (66.7)32 (59.3)0.425
Age (yr)29.5 ± 6.831.8 ± 9.10.23431.7 ± 8.630.7 ± 8.60.548
Height (cm)170.3 ± 7.9170.1 ± 7.70.884169.9 ± 7.2170.4 ± 8.30.711
Body Weight (kg)123.5 ± 30.4122.2 ± 29.90.840120.9 ± 28.6124.2 ± 31.30.562
BMI (kg/m2)42.2 ± 8.141.8 ± 7.50.79541.5 ± 7.442.3 ± 7.90.591
Waistline (cm)126.0 ± 18.3124.1 ± 19.90.731124.8 ± 19.8124.3 ± 19.40.916
Hipline (cm)128.3 ± 12.3129.8 ± 16.50.744128.0 ± 13.3130.7 ± 17.40.459
Table 3 Preoperative obesity-related comorbidities, n (%)

n
1SO, n = 80
1FAO, n = 80
χ2
P value
n
2SO, n = 58
2FAO, n = 58
χ2
P value
MS Without8943 (53.8)46 (57.5)0.2280.6336734 (58.6)33 (56.9)0.0350.851
With7137 (46.3)34 (42.5)4924 (41.4)25 (43.1)
HTN Without10554 (67.5)51 (63.8)0.2490.6187533 (56.9)42 (72.4)3.0560.080
With5526 (32.5)29 (36.3)4125 (43.1)16 (27.6)
T2DM Without8643 (53.8)43 (53.8)> 0.9995931 (53.4)28 (48.3)0.3100.577
With7437 (46.3)37 (46.3)5727 (46.6)30 (51.7)
IGT Without8945 (56.3)44 (55.0)0.0250.8747133 (56.9)38 (65.5)0.9080.341
With7135 (43.8)36 (45.0)4525 (43.1)20 (34.5)
HLP Without9651 (63.8)45 (56.3)0.9380.3336839 (67.2)29 (50.0)3.5540.059
With6429 (36.3)35 (43.8)4819 (32.8)29 (50.0)
PCOS Without8741 (74.5)46 (80.7)0.6120.4345227 (77.1)25 (73.5)0.1570.924
With2514 (25.5)11 (19.3)178 (22.9)9 (26.5)
NAFLD Without2616 (20.0)10 (12.5)1.6530.199198 (13.8)11 (19.0)0.5660.452
With13464 (80.0)70 (87.5)9750 (86.2)47 (81.0)
OSA Without5327 (33.8)26 (32.5)0.0280.8673714 (24.1)23 (39.7)3.2150.073
With10753 (66.3)54 (67.5)7944 (75.9)35 (60.3)
HUA Without6837 (46.3)31 (38.8)0.9210.3374218 (31.0)24 (41.4)1.3440.246
With9243 (53.8)49 (61.3)7440 (69.0)34 (58.6)
Table 4 Postoperative body mass index, total weight loss percentage, excess weight loss percentage

1SO, n = 73
1FAO, n = 73
P value
2SO, n = 53
2FAO, n = 53
P value
BaselineSex [female, n (%)]49 (67.1)49 (67.1)> 0.99936 (67.9)33 (62.3)0.541
Age (yr)30.5 ± 7.731.0 ± 8.50.70631.6 ± 8.730.6 ± 8.30.537
Height (cm)169.2 ± 8.4169.9 ± 8.10.617169.8 ± 7.5170.2 ± 8.50.817
Body weight (kg)118.8 ± 26.7120.7 ± 27.40.660123.2 ± 27.3123.2 ± 31.30.995
BMI (kg/m2)41.2 ± 6.941.5 ± 6.80.80242.4 ± 6.942.1 ± 7.90.842
Waistline (cm)123.0 ± 16.0123.4 ± 17.30.892124.9 ± 18.4123.4 ± 19.30.725
Hipline (cm)128.8 ± 16.3131.0 ± 14.40.439131.0 ± 18.1129.8 ± 17.10.771
BMIPre-op (kg/m2)41.2 ± 6.941.5 ± 6.80.80242.4 ± 6.942.1 ± 7.90.842
1 month (kg/m2)35.5 ± 5.936.2 ± 6.30.46536.9 ± 5.736.9 ± 7.60.974
3 months (kg/m2)31.5 ± 5.432.4 ± 5.60.36432.9 ± 5.333.0 ± 6.60.950
6 months (kg/m2)28.4 ± 4.929.3 ± 5.00.24629.6 ± 4.929.9 ± 5.90.784
12 months (kg/m2)26.9 ± 4.827.1 ± 3.90.83027.2 ± 4.428.6 ± 5.50.213
24 months (kg/m2)26.3 ± 5.128.2 ± 4.20.20126.9 ± 4.231.3 ± 5.70.003
36 months (kg/m2)26.9 ± 5.129.3 ± 5.30.42827.5 ± 4.032.2 ± 6.20.061
%TWL1 month13.8 ± 4.412.8 ± 3.20.11612.7 ± 3.512.6 ± 3.90.896
3 months23.2 ± 5.321.8 ± 5.30.11222.2 ± 4.221.6 ± 6.20.571
6 months30.9 ± 5.829.0 ± 6.80.07229.9 ± 5.228.7 ± 7.20.323
12 months36.1 ± 7.532.7 ± 8.30.06335.6 ± 6.832.0 ± 9.80.081
24 months37.4 ± 7.830.0 ± 12.60.02536.6 ± 7.426.7 ± 12.50.006
36 months41.3 ± 11.727.4 ± 10.50.04437.0 ± 11.626.4 ± 13.30.079
%EWL1 month33.2 ± 12.132.2 ± 16.90.67529.1 ± 9.232.5 ± 19.90.262
3 months56.5 ± 16.554.4 ± 25.50.56151.8 ± 12.854.5 ± 30.00.541
6 months74.9 ± 18.971.5 ± 28.90.39969.8 ± 17.471.2 ± 32.50.771
12 months84.9 ± 24.879.8 ± 20.80.32282.7 ± 22.475.2 ± 25.00.162
24 months89.1 ± 24.870.9 ± 27.00.02583.9 ± 20.859.2 ± 25.2< 0.001
36 months83.9 ± 25.166.7 ± 20.60.20277.8 ± 22.856.9 ± 25.30.084
Table 5 Factors affecting percentage total weight loss

1 month
3 months
6 months
12 months
24 months
%TWL1FAO-1.036-1.352-1.838-1.542-5.123
Sex-0.361-1.054-1.798-1.229-1.227
BMI0.02800.0960.250b0.444a0.672a
MS0.091-0.962-1.006-3.8080.829
HTN0.8760.8640.082-0.844-5.728
T2DM-0.370-0.283-0.087-0.376-3.427
HLP0.9801.030-0.817-1.203-4.127
NAFLD-0.517-0.410-1.5680.065-0.958
OSA-0.3710.9391.0332.7523.023
HUA0.5060.028-0.0392.1152.590
%TWL2FAO-0.272-0.671-1.385-3.164-9.486b
Sex1.0460.4611.0132.6932.206
BMI-0.0390.0540.1560.2850.618a
MS-0.891-0.860-1.852-1.634-4.611
HTN0.3060.810-0.088-2.749-3.853
T2DM-0.338-1.478-1.5480.198-1.050
HLP1.3181.8670.690-2.605-0.980
NAFLD-0.113-0.3030.4820.3382.968
OSA-0.4830.7470.2882.5580.332
HUA-0.367-1.384-1.2980.120-0.298
Table 6 Factors affecting percentage of excess weight loss

1 month
3 months
6 months
12 months
24 months
%EWL1FAO-0.698-1.238-2.329-4.439-14.637
Sex3.5314.4862.864-4.092-1.340
BMI-1.100 c-1.751 c-1.903 c-1.397 b-0.757
MS-1.272-4.902-6.480-10.9832.548
HTN4.3885.4354.3881.123-13.696
T2DM2.4643.3184.4450.240-11.171
HLP0.8071.271-2.716-4.837-11.703
NAFLD-5.720-8.292-11.392 a0.9871.587
OSA-2.937-0.133-0.5335.9916.384
HUA0.940-0.329-1.2692.5652.079
%EWL2FAO2.0671.089-0.691-7.224-23.513 c
Sex6.912 a8.73010.8805.4877.279
BMI-1.145 c-1.806 c-2.054 c-1.539 c-0.666
MS-7.068-8.342-12.334-6.298-5.596
HTN5.5699.4848.283-2.062-8.179
T2DM3.2910.9250.717-0.222-10.684
HLP2.7844.2191.786-7.448-5.069
NAFLD-3.588-6.218-5.1071.5987.874
OSA-5.186-3.097-5.1482.368-2.031
HUA-2.054-5.344-5.365-2.837-5.233
Table 7 Obesity-related comorbidities at 6 months postoperatively, n (%)

n
1SO, n = 731FAO, n = 73χ2
P value
n2SO, n = 532FAO, n = 53χ2
P value
MSWithout13365 (89)68 (93.2)0.7600.38310052 (98.1)48 (90.6)0.205
With138 (11.0)5 (6.8)61 (1.9)5 (9.4)
HTNWithout13266 (90.4)66 (90.4)> 0.9999950 (94.3)49 (92.5)> 0.999
With147 (9.6)7 (9.6)73 (5.7)4 (7.5)
T2DM Without13166 (90.4)65 (89.0)0.0740.7859752 (98.1)45 (84.9)0.031
With157 (9.6)8 (11.0)91 (1.9)8 (15.1)
HLP Without11860 (82.2)58 (79.5)0.1770.6749150 (94.3)41 (77.4)6.2900.012
With2813 (17.8)15 (20.5)153 (5.7)12 (22.6)
NAFLD Without9655 (75.3)41 (56.2)5.9620.0156540 (75.5)25 (47.2)8.9490.003
With5018 (24.7)32 (43.8)4113 (24.5)28 (52.8)
HUA Without9846 (63.0)52 (71.2)> 0.9997841 (77.4)37 (69.8)1.6030.205
With4827 (37.0)21 (28.8)2812 (22.6)16 (30.2)