Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Gastroenterol. Oct 14, 2014; 20(38): 14018-14032
Published online Oct 14, 2014. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i38.14018
Table 1 Summary of study design, treatment indications and treatment protocols for studies included in systematic review process n (%)
Ref.Time framenStudy design (evidence level)IndicationExtent of CPMTreatment summaryTechniqueIntraperitoneal chemotherapeutic regimen
Portilla et al[33]1985-199618Case series (3)rCPM1PCI < 12, 10/18 (60)CRS + EPICClosed techniquePOD 1: MMC in 1 L 1.5% dextrose peritoneal dialysis solution (10-12.5 mg/m2)
PCI > 12, 8/18 (38)POD 2-6: 5-FU in 1 L 1.5% dextrose peritoneal dialysis solution + 50 mEq sodium bicarbonate
Witkamp et al[34]1995-199729Case series (3)CPM2-CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueMMC 35 mg/m2 in 3-4 L of isotonic dialysis fluid at a temperature of 40 °C-41 °C for 90 min
Pilati et al[35]1995-200134Case series (3)CPM2-CRS + HIPEC10/34 closed techniqueMMC (3.3 mg/m2 per liter) + cisplatin (25 mg/m2 per liter) for 90 min at temperature of 41 °C-42 °C
14/34 open technique
Verwaal et al[36]1995-2003106Case series (3)rCPM2-CRS + HIPECClosed abdomen techniqueMMC 35 mg/m2 in 3-4 L of isotonic dialysis fluid at a temperature of 40 °C-41 °C for 90 min
Glehen et al[37]1989-200253Multicentre case series (3)CPM2Stage2 I 13/53 (25)CRS + HIPECClosed abdomen techniqueMMC 40-60 mg in 4-6 L of perfusate at a temperature of 46 °C-48 °C for 90 min
Stage II 8/53 (15)
Stage III 7/53 (13)
Stage IV 25/53 (47)
Mahteme et al[53]1991-199936 (18 vs 18)Case-control (2-)CPM2-Treatment arm: CRS + EPIC (n = 18)Closed abdomen techniqueEPIC protocol: 5-FU 550 mg/m2 in 500 mL normal saline administered intraperitoneally from POD 1. IV infusion of leucovorin (60 mg/m2) commenced at 60 min after initiation of PIC. Regimen offered 1-8 courses as tolerated with 4-6 wk interval between cycles.
Control arm: Systemic CT onlySystemic CT protocol: Chemotherapeutic regimen not specified
Glehen et al[38]1987-2002506Multinational case series (3)CPM3Limited 171/506(n = 18)CRS + HIPEC and/or EPICOpen or closed techniqueHIPEC protocol: Various (MMC alone 274/506; MMC + cisplatin 48/506; oxaliplatin 32/506; other 29/506)
Extended 329/506EPIC protocol: Various (MMC alone 2/506; MMC + 5-FU 113/506; 5-FU alone 95/506; other 7/506)
Shen et al[39]1991-200277Case series (3)CPM3-CRS + HIPEC40 mg MMC introduced into dialysis fluid for 120 min at ≥ 38.5 °C
Cavaliere et al[40]1996-2005120Multicentre case series (3)CPM1-CRS + HIPECClosed abdomen technique Open 56.7%109/120: MMC (3.3 mg/m2 per liter) and cisplatin (25 mg/m2 per liter) at 41.5 °C-43 °C for 60-90 min
Closed 43.3%11/120: oxaliplatin (460 mg/m2) for 30 min after IV 5-FU and leucovorin
Kianmanesh et al[41]1996-200643Case series (3)CPM3Stage2 I/II 10/43 (23)CRS + HIPECOpen techniqueMMC 120 mg + cisplatin 200 mg/m2 at 41 °C-43 °C for 90 to 120 min
Stage III 6/43 (14)
Stage IV 27/43 (63)
Gusani et al[42]2002-200528Case series (3)CPM2-CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueMMC 30-40 mg in 3 L saline solution at temperature of 40 °C for 100 min
Verwaal et al[26]1998-2001105 (54 vs 51)Randomized trial (1-)CPM2-Treatment arm: CRS + HIPEC (n = 54)Open coliseum techniqueHIPEC protocol: MMC 17.5 mg/m2 at 40 °C for 90 min
Control arm: Systemic CT only (n = 51)Systemic CT protocol: 5-FU (400 mg/m2) + leucovorin (80 mg/m2) weekly for 26 wk
Yan et al[62]1997-200750Case series (3)CPM3PCI < 10 20/50CRS + HIPECOpen coliseum techniqueMMC 10-12.5 mg/m2 in 3 L of 1.5% dextrose peritoneal dialysis solution for 90 min at 42 °C
PCI 10-20 23/50
PCI > 20 7/50
Elias et al[54]1998-200396 (48 vs 48)Case-control (2-)CPM3Treatment arm: Limited 27/48 Extended 21/48Treatment arm: CRS + HIPEC (n = 48)-HIPEC protocol: Oxaliplatin 460 mg/m2 in 2 L/m2 at 43 °C for 30 min. Before HIPEC (during CRS) patients received IV 5-FU 400 mg/m2 + leucovorin 20 mg/m2
Control arm:Control arm:Systemic CT protocol:
Limited 26/48 Extended 17/48Not recorded 5/48Systemic CT only (n = 48)Various regimens (5-FU based 46/48; Capecitabine based 1/48; Camptothecin 1/48)
Varban et al[43]1991-2007142Case series (3)CPM3-CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueMMC 40 mg at 40.5 °C-42.5 °C for 120 min
Vaira et al[44]1997-200840Case series (3)CPM2PCI > 16 11/40CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueCisplatin (100 mg/m2) + MMC (16 mg/m2) at 41.5 °C for 30 min
PCI < 16 29/40OR
Oxaliplatin (460 mg/m2) + IV 5-FU at 42 °C for 30 min
OR
MMC (35 mg/m2) at 40.5 °C for 60 min
Glehen et al[45]1989-2007523Multi-centre case series (3)CPM3-CRS + HIPEC and/or EPICVarious techniquesHIPEC protocol: MMC (30-50 mg/m2) with or without cisplatin (50-100 mg/m2) delivered over 60-120 min at 41 °C-42.5 °C
OR
Oxaliplatin (360-460 mg/m2) +/- irinotecan (100-200 mg/m2) +/- IV 5-FU and leucovorin delivered over 30 min at 43 °C
EPIC protocol: Abdominal cavity filled at the end of surgery with 1 L/m2 Ringer lactate. EPIC lasted 5 d (POD 1-5); POD 1: MMC (10 mg/m2); POD 2-5: 5FU (600 mg/m2)
Franko et al[55]2001-2007105 (67 vs 38)Case-control (2-)CPM2-Treatment arm: CRS+ HIPEC (n = 67)Closed abdomen techniqueHIPEC protocol: MMC 40 mg for 100 min
Control arm: Systemic CT only (n = 38)Systemic CT protocol: Chemotherapeutic regimen(s) not clearly described
Quenet et al[46]1998-2007146Case series (3)CPM3PCI < 10 69/146CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueIV 5-FU (400 mg/m2) + leucovorin (20 mg/m2) followed by: ip oxaliplatin (460 mg/m2) in 2 L/m2 dextrose
PCI 11-19 57/146OR
PCI >20 20/146ip oxaliplatin (300 mg/m2) + ip irinotecan (200 mg/m2) in 2 L/m2 dextrose
Cashin et al[57]1993-200832 (16 vs 16)Case-control (2-)CPM2HIPEC group: Mean PCI 14.4CRS + HIPEC (n = 16)HIPEC:Open coliseum techniqueEPIC: Closed techniqueHIPEC protocol: Oxaliplatin 460 mg/m2 for 30 min at 41 °C-42 °C combined with IV 5-FU (450-500 mg/m2) + leucovorin (25-30 mg/m2)
EPIC group: Mean PCI 13.2CRS + EPIC (n = 16)EPIC protocol: 5-FU (500-600 mg/m2) + IV leucovorin (20-30 mg/m2) once daily for 86-d cycles
Passot et al[47]1991-2010120Case series (3)CPM3Stage2 I-II 41/120CRS + HIPECClosed techniqueMMC + irinotecan or oxaliplatin
Stage III-IV 79/120Exact dosing protocol not described
Mean PCI 8.2
Hompes et al[48]2004-200848Case series (3)CPM2Median PCI 11 (1-22)CRS + HIPECOpen coliseum techniqueIV folinic acid (20 mg/m2) + 5-FU (400 mg/m2) followed by ip oxaliplatin (460 mg/m2) in 2 L/m2 5% glucose solution at 41 °C-42 °C for 30 min
Cashin et al[56]1996-2010151 (69 vs 57)Case control (2-)CPM3PCI 1-10 49/151CRS+ HIPEC (n = 69)HIPEC: Open coliseum techniqueHIPEC protocol: MMC ip (30 mg/m2) for 90 min at 41 °C-42 °C OR oxaliplatin (460 mg/m2) ip for 30 min at 41 °C-42 °C + IV 5-FU (400 mg/m2) and calcium folinate (60 mg/m2) OR oxaliplatin (360 mg/m2) ip + irinotecan (360 mg/m2) for 30 min at 41 °C-42 °C + IV 5-FU (450-500 mg/m2) and calcium folinate (60 mg/m2)
PCI 11-20 45/151CRS + EPIC (n = 57)EPIC: Closed techniqueEPIC protocol: 5-FU (500-600 mg/m2) ip + IV leucovorin (60 mg/m2) once daily for 8 6-d cycles
PCI 21-39 56/151
Klaver et al[49]1996-201024Case series (3)CPM14-CRS+ HIPEC (12/24)Open coliseum techniqueHIPEC protocol: ip chemotherapy (MMC or oxaliplatin; dosing not stated) at 42 °C for 90 min
CRS + EPIC (6/24)EPIC protocol: 5-FU (650-800 mg/m2 per day) in 1 L 1.5% dextrose for 23 h on POD 1-5
CRS + HIPEC + EPIC (6/24)
Turrini et al[50]2004-201026Case series (3)CPM1-CRS + HIPECOpen coliseum techniqueOxaliplatin ip (460 mg/m2) in 2 L/m2 dextrose solution at 43 °C for 30 min after 1 h infusion of IV 5-FU (400 mg/m2) + leucovorin (20 mg/m2)
Haslinger et al[51]2003-201138Case series (3)CPM2-CRS+ HIPECClosed techniqueMMC 40 mg at temperature of 41 °C for 60-120 min
Yonemura et al[52]2004-2012142Case series (3)CPM3-CRS + HIPEC-MMC 20 mg/m2 + cisplatin 100 mg/m2 in $L saline at 42 °C-43 °C for 60 min
Table 2 Oncological outcome data n (%)
Ref.Median FU (mth)Pre-op CTPost-op CTExtent of cytoreduction/disease CCRS21-yr survival2-yr survival3-yr survival4-yr survival5-yr survivalMedian survival (mo)Local/distant recurrence
Portilla et al[33]36.2122% (regimen not stated)100% (regimen not stated)CC0-CC1 (14/18; 64)CC0-CC1 (91%)CC0-CC1 (64%)---Overall-
CC2-CC3 (4/18; 36)CC2-CC3 (43%)CC2-CC3 (14%)20
PCI < 12 (10/18; 56)PC1 < 12 (N/A)PCI < 12 (64%)
PCI > 12 (8/18; 44)PCI > 12 (N/A)PCI > 12 (14%)
Witkamp et al[34]38 (26-52)-72% (5-FU+ leucovorin)-82%45%23%---LR 28%
DR 17%
LR + DR 28%
Pilati et al[35]14.5 (6-34)0%-CC0-1 34/3468%31%---18LR 59%
DR 12%
LR + DR 18%
Verwaal et al[36]47.5 (1.3-88.3)-15% (leucovorin)R1 (54/106; 51)-----R1 11.1Unspecified recurrence 65%
R2a (37/106; 35)R2a 5.9
R2b (15/106; 14)R2b 3.7
Glehen et al[37]59.5-68% (5-FU + irinotecan leucovorin)CC0 (23/53; 43)CC0 85%CC0 54%--CC0 22%CC0 32.9Unspecified recurrence 19%
CC1 (11/53; 21)CC1 46%CC1 36%CC1 9%CC1 12.5
CC2 (19/53; 36)CC2 24%CC2 0%CC2 8.1
Mahteme et al[53]---CC0 (11/18; 61)-CRS + EPIC 60%--CRS + EPIC 28%CRS + EPIC overall 32; CC0 34.5 CC1-2 10-
CC1-2 (7/18; 39)Control arm 10%Control arm 5%Control arm: 14
Glehen et al[38]5354%40%CC0 (271/506; 54)CC0 87%-CC0 47%-CC0 31%MalesUnspecified recurrence 73%
CC1 (106/506; 21)CC1 79%CC1 29%CC1 15%16.8
CC2 (129/506; 25)CC2 38%CC2 6%CC2 0%Females
21.6
Shen et al[39]15 (3-85)75%-R0 (13/77; 17)--R0 69%-R0 55%R0 N/RUnspecified recurrence 68%
R1 (24/77; 31)R1 19%R1 19%R1 17.8
R2a (11/77; 14)R2a 28%R2a 14%R2a 12.7
R2b (9/77; 12)R2b 0%R2b 0%R2b 4.1
R2c (20/77; 26)R2c 6%R2c 0%R2c 5.0
Cavaliere et al[40]1672%-CC0 (102/120; 85)--Overall--19-
CC1 (9/120; 7)25.8%
CC2-3 (9/120; 7)CC0
33.5%
Kianmanesh et al[41]-70%75%--72%-44%38.4-
Gusani et al[42]35.9 (19-57.7)---78%37%37%--15.2-
Verwaal et al[26]96 (72-115)--R1 (22/54; 41)R1 95%R1 80%R1 58%R1 52%R1 45%CRS + HIPEC-
R2a (23/54; 43)R2a 65%R2a 20%R2a 10%R2a 10%R2a 10%22.2
R2b (9/54; 17)R2b 22%R2b 12%R2b 0%R2c 0%R2c 0%Systemic CT
12.6
Yan[17]14 (1-56)--CC0 (41/50; 82)CC0 85%-CC0 62%--CC0 37Unspecified recurrence 34%
CC1-3 (9/50; 8)CC1-3 51%CC1-3 0%CC1-3 14
Elias et al[54]95.7----CRS + HIPEC--CRS + HIPECCRS + HIPEC-
81%51%62.7
Systemic CTSystemic CTSystemic CT
65%13%23.9
Varban et al[43]14.6----HM 43.3%-HM 14.4%-HM 23-
No HM 36.8%No HM 17.4%No HM 15.8
Vaira et al[44]-55%-CC0 (29/40; 73)CC0 88%----Overall: 43-
CC2 (11/40; 27)CC2 42%CC0: 24
CC2: 9.7
Glehen et al[45]----81%58%39%34%28%--
Franko et al[55]-100--CRS + HIPECCRS + HIPECCRS + HIPECCRS + HIPECCRS + HIPECCRS + HIPEC-
90%65%50%42%25%34.7
Systemic CTSystemic CTSystemic CTSystemic CTSystemic CTSystemic CT
55%35%12%10%7%16.8
Quenet et al[46]48.5100%-CC0 (132/146; 90)OverallOverallOverallOverall-OverallUnspecified recurrence 70%
CC1 (12/146; 8)92%72%55%50%41
CC2 (2/146; 2)
Cashin et al[56]HIPECHIPECHIPEC-HIPECHIPEC groupHIPEC groupHIPEC group-HIPEC group-
3881%38%100%78%60%48%36.5
EPICEPICEPICEPICEPIC groupEPIC groupEPIC groupEPIC group
6644%38%80%48%25%17%23.9
Passot et al[47]58.5 (1-183)75%64.30%CC0 (93/120; 78)OverallOverall--OverallOverall-
CC1 (11/120; 9)77%51%33%36.2
CC2 (16/120; 13)
Hompes et al[48]22.7 (3.2-55.7)-62.50%CC0 (48/48; 100)OS 98%OS 89%-----
DFS 66%DFS 46%
Cashin et al[57]49 (0.5-100)31%18%CC0 (97/151; 64)HIPECHIPECHIPECHIPEC-HIPEC-
CC1-3 (54/151; 36)80%50%27%18%34
EPICEPICEPICEPICEPIC
5%---25
Klaver et al[49]10.5 (1-52)--CC0 (22/24; 92)Overall----OverallUnspecified recurrence 54%
CC1 (2/24; 8)83%35
Turrini et al[50]----100%-51%-37%--
Haslinger et al[51]--------OS 38%--
PFS15%
Yonemura et al[52]-77%-CC0 (108/142; 76)----OverallOverall-
CC1 34/142 (24)23.4%24.4
CC0 20%CC0 25.9
CC1 9.9%CC1 8
Table 3 Reported treatment-associated morbidity and mortality following multi-modality therapy for colorectal peritoneal metastase
Ref.nMortality (%)Overall morbidity (%)No of bowel anastomosesIntra-abdominal complications (%)Extra-abdominal complications (%)
Portilla et al[33]180No treatment-associated morbidity data provided
Witkamp et al[34]293382 (0-5)Postoperative bleeding (3)Grade I-II leucopenia (21)
Bowel perforation (3)Grade III leucopenia (31)
Bladder perforation (3)Peripheral neuropathy (10)
Return to theatre (17)Subclavian vein thrombosis (3)
Hydronephrosis requiring nephrostomy (7)
Wound dehiscence (3)
Prolonged chyle leak (3)
Pilati et al[35]34035-Non-specified complications: Ozols’grade I (53), grade II (9), grade III (1), grade IV (1)Haematological toxicity (12)
Pneumonia (12)
Verwaal et al[36]106-No treatment-associated morbidity data provided
Glehen et al[37]534230.4 (0-4)Return to theatre (4)-
Gastrointestinal fistula (8)
Mahteme et al[53]18061-Severe nausea and vomiting (12)Transient neutropaenia (6)
Leak from drain (6)
Catheter-related problems (39)
Glehen et al[38]5064%22.9-Re-operation (10.7)Haematological toxicity (2.4)
Fistula (8.3)Systemic sepsis (2)
Intra-abdominal abscess (1.8)Cardiorespiratory complications (3.5)
Urinary fistula (1)
Shen et al[39]771230-Bowel perforation (3)Haematological toxicity (19)
Cavaliere et al[40]1203.322.5-Perforation (5)
Anastomotic leak (3.3)
Infection (3.3)
Kianmanesh et al[41]432.339-Deep abscess (14)Pleural effusion (12)
Intestinal fistula (9)Renal failure (7)
Delayed gastric emptying (9)Superficial wound infection (12)
Re-operation (4)
Gusani et al[42]28056.5-Re-operation (8)Systemic sepsis (4)
Anastomotic leak (8)
Intra-abdomoninal abscess (4)
Wound dehiscence (4)
Enterocutaneous fistula (2)
Verwaal et al[26]54-No treatment-associated morbidity data provided
Yan[17]50046-Small bowel obstruction (12)Pleural effusion (34)
Fistula (10)Pneumonia (4)
Intra-abdominal abscess (10)
Perforation (4)
Elias et al[54]48-No treatment-associated morbidity data provided
Varban et al[43]142CPM with HMCPM with HM-CPM with HMCPM with HM
7.1%57.1%Bowel leak (11)Pneumonia (7)
CPM with no HMCPM with no HMWound infection (11)Neutropaenia (7)
7.7%40.1%Pancreatic fistula (11)DVT (7)
Ileus (11)CPM with no HM
CPM with no HMPneumonia (6)
Bowel leak (5)Neutropaenia (8)
Wound infection (5)AF (3)
Ileus (5)Thrombocytopaenia (2)
Enterocutaneous fistula (1)
Vaira et al[44]402.5550 (17.5)Fistula (10)Haematological toxicity (12.5)
1(55)Abdominal abscess (7.5)Pleural effusion (22.5)
2 (27.5)Superficial wound infection (12.5)
Glehen et al[45]523-Not specifically provided for patients undergoing procedures for CPM
Franko et al[55]105-No treatment-associated morbidity data provided
Quenet et al[46]1464.147.2-GI fistula (4.8)-
Urinary fistula (1.4)
Abdominal abscess (2.7)
Reoperation (11.6)
Cashin et al[57]32HIPEC group;HIPEC group;-HIPEC group;HIPEC group;
6%37%Reoperation (12)CVA (6)
EPIC group;EPIC group;EPIC group;EPIC group;
6%19%Reoperation (6)-
Passot et al[47]1203.821.8-Reoperation (13.3)
Fistula (7.5)
Hompes et al[48]48052.11 (0-6)Prolonged ileus (23)Pulmonary (12.5)
Anastomotic leakage (10.4)Cardiac (2.1)
Bleeding (6.3)Urological (12.5)
Bowel perforation (2.1)Haematological (2.5)
Fistula (2.1)
Abscess (2.1)
Reoperation (20.8)
Cashin et al[56]151HIPEC group:HIPEC group:---
4%41%
EPIC group:EPIC group:
3%30%
Klaver et al[49]24062-Prolonged ileus (21)Superficial wound infection (4)
Intra-abdominal collection requiring drainage (21)Cardiorespiratory complications (38)
Fistula (4)Urological (4)
Splenic infarction (4)
Turrini et al[50]26033-Fistula (10)Haematological toxicity (10)
Delayed gastric emptying (10)
Haslinger et al[51]38-Not specifically provided for patients undergoing procedures for CPM
Yonemura et al[52]1420.742.9---