Cross-sectional evaluation of circulating hepatitis B virus RNA and DNA: Different quasispecies?

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Different forms of pregenomic and other hepatitis B virus (HBV) RNA have been detected in patients’ sera. These circulating HBV-RNAs may be useful for monitoring covalently closed circular DNA activity, and predicting hepatitis B e-antigen seroconversion or viral rebound after nucleos(t)ide analog cessation. Data on serum HBV-RNA quasispecies, however, is scarce. It is therefore important to develop methodologies to thoroughly analyze this quasispecies, ensuring the elimination of any residual HBV-DNA. Studying circulating HBV-RNA quasispecies may facilitate achieving functional cure of HBV infection.

AIM

To establish a next-generation sequencing (NGS) methodology for analyzing serum HBV-RNA and comparing it with DNA quasispecies.

METHODS

Thirteen untreated chronic hepatitis B patients, showing different HBV-genotypes and degrees of severity of liver disease were enrolled in the study and a serum sample with HBV-DNA > 5 Log₁₀ IU/mL and HBV-RNA > 4 Log₁₀ copies/mL was taken from each patient. HBV-RNA was treated with DNAse I to remove any residual DNA, and the region between nucleotides (nt) 1255-1611 was amplified using a 3-nested polymerase chain reaction protocol, and analyzed with NGS. Variability/conservation and complexity was compared between HBV-DNA and RNA quasispecies.

RESULTS

No HBV-DNA contamination was detected in cDNA samples from HBV-RNA quasispecies. HBV quasispecies complexity showed heterogeneous behavior among patients. The Rare Haplotype Load at 1% was greater in DNA than in RNA quasispecies, with no statistically significant differences (P = 0.1641). Regarding conservation, information content was equal in RNA and DNA quasispecies in most nt positions [218/357 (61.06%)]. In 102 of the remaining 139 (73.38%), HBV-RNA showed slightly higher variability. Sliding window analysis identified 4 hyper-conserved sequence fragments in each quasispecies, 3 of them coincided between the 2 quasispecies: nts 1258-1286, 1545-1573 and 1575-1604. The 2 hyper-variable sequence fragments also coincided: nts 1311-1344 and 1461-1485. Sequences between nts 1519-1543 and 1559-1587 were only hyper-conserved in HBV-DNA and RNA, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our methodology allowed analyzing HBV-RNA quasispecies complexity and conservation without interference from HBV-DNA. Thanks to this, we have been able to compare both quasispecies in the present study.

Keywords: Hepatitis B virus RNA; Hepatitis B X gene; Quasispecies; Next-generation sequencing; Quasispecies conservation; Quasispecies complexity

Core Tip: Hepatitis B virus (HBV) quasispecies composition and its evolution are related to liver disease progression. HBV-RNA in serum is potentially useful for analyzing viral quasispecies, even in patients with low levels of or suppressed serum HBV-DNA. Few studies have analyzed circulating HBV-RNA quasispecies, and similarities and differences with DNA quasispecies should be assessed. We used next-generation sequencing to analyze RNA quasispecies variability/conservation and complexity, without interference of HBV-DNA, in untreated chronic hepatitis B patients. Comparison of both quasispecies showed similar results between them. DNA quasispecies tended toward greater complexity, while RNA quasispecies tended toward higher variability.