Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2022.
World J Psychiatry. Sep 19, 2022; 12(9): 1204-1232
Published online Sep 19, 2022. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v12.i9.1204
Table 5 Types of first rank symptoms in bipolar disorder
Study groups
Passivity/control
Delusional perception
Somatic passivity
Thought broadcast
Thought insertion
Thought withdrawal
Running commentary
Two or more voices conversing
Thought echo
Lifetime BD and BP I (n = 9)Mean (n = 4) 10%; Median 11%; Range: 4%-16% Mean (n = 1) 20%; Median 20%; Range: 20% -Mean (n = 3) 11%; Median 14%; Range: 3%-17% Mean (n = 1) 20%; Median 20%; Range: 20% Mean (n = 1) 4%; Median 4%; Range: 4% Mean (n = 4) 17%; Median 17%; Range: 10%-27% Mean (n = 4) 16%; Median 17%; Range: 5%-27% Mean (n = 1) 13%; Median 13%; Range: 13%
Current BD (n = 4)Mean (n = 2) 36%; Median 36%; Range: 18%-49%Mean (n = 2) 6%; Median 6%; Range: 2%-10% Mean (n = 1) 7%; Median 7%; Range: 7% Mean (n = 3) 14%; Median 5%; Range: 5%-18% Mean (n = 1) 5%; Median 5%; Range: 5% Mean (n = 1) 2%; Median 2%; Range: 2% Mean (n = 2) 20%; Median 20%; Range: 4%-37% Mean (n = 2)12%; Median 12%; Range: 4%-20% Mean (n = 1) 4%; Median 4%; Range: 4%
Lifetime mania (n = 2)Mean (n = 2) 27%; Median 27%; Range: 3%-52%--Mean (n = 1) 6%; Median 6%; Range: 6%Mean (n = 1) 4%; Median 4%; Range: 4% Mean (n = 1) 3%; Median 3%; Range: 3% Mean (n = 1) 1%; Median 1%; Range: 1% Mean (n = 1) 1%; Median 1%; Range: 1% Mean (n = 2) 14%; Median 14%; Range: 14%-15%
Current mania (n = 8)Mean (n = 8) 23%; Median 20%; Range: 5%-48% --Mean (n = 5) 12%; Median 14%; Range: 2%-21% Mean (n = 3) 9%; Median 7%; Range: 1%-18%Mean (n = 3) 9%; Median 3%; Range: 3%-13%Mean (n = 3) 9%; Median 3%; Range: 2%-14%Mean (n = 3) 5%; Median 3%; Range: 2%-6%Mean (n = 3) 5%; Median 2%; Range: 1%-12%
Lifetime depression (n = 1)Mean (n = 1) 1%; Median 1%; Range: 1% --Mean (n = 1) 1%; Median 1%; Range: 1%Mean (n = 1) 1%; Median 1%; Range: 1%Mean (n = 1) 4%; Median 4%; Range: 4%--Mean (n = 1) 10%; Median 10%; Range: 10%
Current depression (n = 1)-------Mean (n = 1) 17%; Median 17%-
Current mixed (n = 1)Mean (n = 1) 49%; Median 49%; Range: 49%-------
Overall ratesMean (n = 18) 24%; Median 24%; Range: 1%-49%Mean (n = 3) 13%; Median 13%; Range: 2%-20%Mean (n = 1) 7%; Median 7%; Range: 7%Mean (n = 17) 9%; Median 8%; Range: 1%-18%Mean (n = 7) 8%; Median 7%; Range: 1%-20%Mean (n = 7) 4%; Median 3%; Range: 2%-13%Mean (n = 10) 12%; Median 10%; Range: 1%-20%Mean (n = 11) 10%; Median 10%; Range: 1%-27%Mean (n = 8) 9%; Median 9%; Range: 4%-15%