Copyright
©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Psychiatr. Dec 19, 2021; 11(12): 1407-1424
Published online Dec 19, 2021. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v11.i12.1407
Published online Dec 19, 2021. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v11.i12.1407
Ref. | BD | Sample size, N (P × C) | Age in years (P × C) | Female frequency (%) (P × C) | Intervention | Applied scales/parameters | Results |
Zhang et al[14], 2019 | I e II | 35 × 39 | 34.2 × 34.6 | 57.1 × 46.2 | SCIT | YMRS | P = 0.21 |
HDRS | P = 0.11 | ||||||
FAST | P < 0.001 | ||||||
TMTA | P = 0.77 | ||||||
SDMT | P = 0.09 | ||||||
HVLT-R | P = 0.09 | ||||||
SCWT | P = 0.054 | ||||||
Wiener et al[15], 2017 | ND | 32 × 29 | 24 × 23.81 | 83.3 × 76.2 | PMBD | HDRS | P = 0.028 |
YMRS | P = 0.879 | ||||||
Cardoso et al[16], 2015 | ND | 32 × 29 | 24.09 × 24.03 | 65.6 × 72.4 | PMBD | BRIAN | P = 0.88 |
HARS | P = 0.175 | ||||||
YMRS | P = 0.576 | ||||||
HDRS | P = 0.074 | ||||||
Cardodo et al[17], 2014 | ND | 32 × 29 | 24.09 × 24.03 | 65.6 × 72.4 | PMBD | HDRS | P = 0.001 |
YMRS | P = 0.102 | ||||||
Faria et al[18], 2014 | II | 32 × 29 | 24.09 × 24.03 | 72.4 × 65.6 | PMBD | BRIAN | P = 0.01 |
Depressive symptoms | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Kurdal et al[19], 2014 | ND | 40 × 40 | 37.17 × 33.9 | 35 × 40 | PMBD | BDFQ | P > 0.005 |
Javadpour et al[20], 2013 | I e II | 45 × 41 | 24.4/23.2 | 23 × 21 | PMBD | WHOQOL-BREF | P < 0.001 |
MARS | P = 0.008 | ||||||
Hospitalizations | P < 0.001 | ||||||
de Barros Pellegrinelli et al[21], 2013 | I e II | 32 × 23 | 43.43 × 43.74 | 23 × 15 | PMBD | HDRS | P = 0.820 |
YMRS | P = 0.716 | ||||||
SAS | P = 0.114 | ||||||
GAF | P = 0.586 | ||||||
CGI | P = 0.026 | ||||||
Candini et al[22], 2013 | I e II | 57 × 45 | 41.5 × 44.8 | 52.6 × 48.9 | PMBD | Hospitalizations | P = 0.001 |
Number of days of hospitalization | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Colom et al[11], 2009 | I e II | 60 × 60 | 34.03 × 34.26 | 63.3 × 63.3 | PMBD | New mood episode | P = 0.002 |
Hospitalizations | P = 0.023 | ||||||
Number of days of hospitalization | P = 0.047 | ||||||
Colom et al[23], 2003 | I | 25 × 25 | 35.36 × 34.48 | 64 × 60 | PMBD | Mood episodes in the treatment phase | P = 0.003 |
Mood episodes after 2 yr | P = 0.008 | ||||||
Depressive episodes | P = 0.004 | ||||||
Hospitalizations | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Colom et al[24], 2003 | I e II | 60 × 60 | 23.25 × 22.26 | 63.3 × 63.3 | PMBD | New mood episode | P = 0.001 |
Hospitalizations | P = 0.05 | ||||||
Number of days of hospitalization | P = 0.05 | ||||||
Dalum et al[25], 2018 | ND | 23 × 24 | 41 × 45 | 46 × 44 | IMR | IMRS-P | P = 0.14 |
IMRS-S | P = 0.76 | ||||||
Depp et al[26], 2015 | I e II | 51 × 63 | 46.9 × 48.1 | 53.7 × 63.4 | PRISM | YMRS | P = 0.004 |
MADRS | P = 0.036 | ||||||
IIS | P = 0.636 | ||||||
Lauder et al[27], 2015 | I e II | 71 × 59 | 39.87 × 41.35 | 73 × 76 | MS–PLUS | ASRMS | P = 0.02 |
MADRS | P = 0.003 | ||||||
MOS-SSS | P = 0.003 | ||||||
MARS | P = 0.001 | ||||||
GPF | P = 0.003 | ||||||
Torrent et al[28], 2013 | I e II | 159 × 80 | 40.59 × 40.47 | 57.1 × 57.5 | FR | FAST | P = 0.002 |
HDRS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
YMRS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
Hospitalizations | P > 0.05 | ||||||
Smith et al[29], 2011 | I e II | 24 × 26 | 42.7 × 44.7 | 54.2 × 69.2 | BBO | FAST | P = 0.15 |
GAF | P = 0.21 | ||||||
SAI | P = 0.44 | ||||||
WHOQOL-BREF | P = 0.25 | ||||||
Sylvia et al[30], 2011 | I e II | 4 × 6 | 60 × 50.2 | 75 × 33 | NEW TX | MADRS | P = 0.10 |
LIFE-RIFT | P = 0.014 | ||||||
D'Souza et al[31], 2010 | I | 27 × 31 | 40.7 × 39.5 | 51.85 × 51.61 | SIMSEP-BD | ARS | P = 0.001 |
New mood episode | P = 0.015 | ||||||
Time between mood episodes | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Castle et al[32], 2010 | I e II | 42 × 42 | 41.6 × 42.6 | 79 × 26 | MAPS | Mood episode | P = 0.003 |
Depressive symptoms | P = 0.003 | ||||||
Knowledge about illness | P > 0.05 | ||||||
ESM-PA | P = 0.024 | ||||||
ESM-NA | P = 0.001 | ||||||
So et et al[46], 2021 | I e II | 38 × 26 | 35.8 × 43.1 | 78.9 × 73.1 | LGP | Medication adherence | P > 0.05 |
Sajatovic et al[33], 2009 | I e II | 80 × 80 | 41.13 × 40 | 73.75 × 87.5 | LGP | DAI | P = 0.366 |
SRTAB | P = 0.577 | ||||||
GAS | P = 0.382 | ||||||
Miklowitz et al[34], 2007 | I e II | 163 × 130 | 40.1 × 40 | ND | IPI | Remission of symptoms 1 yr | P = 0.001 |
Miklowitz et al[35], 2007 | I e II | 84 × 68 | ND | 59 × 59 | IPI | LIFE-RIFT | P = 0.006 |
González Isasi et al[36], 2014 | I | 20 × 20 | 43.35 × 39.25 | 45 × 50 | CBT | STAI-S | P = 0.062 |
YMRS | P = 0.009 | ||||||
BDI | P = 0.131 | ||||||
IS | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Parikh et al[37], 2012 | I e II | 109 × 95 | 40.9 × 40.9 | 53.2 × 63.2 | CBT | LIFE | P > 0.05 |
CARS-M | P = 0.089 | ||||||
HDRS | P = 0.089 | ||||||
Zaretsky et al[38], 2008 | I e II | 40 × 39 | ND | ND | CBT | CARS-M | P = 0.001 |
HDRS | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Proudfoot et al[39], 2012 | ND | 139 × 134 | 35.3 × 40.9 | 66.9 × 69.4 | BEP | GADS | P > 0.05 |
WSAS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
SWLS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
BRIEF IPQ | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Aubry et al[40], 2012 | I e II | 50 × 35 | 46 × 52 | 66 × 62.9 | LGP | Hospitalizations | P = 0.001 |
Number of hospitalizations | P = 0.009 | ||||||
Gonzalez et al[41], 2007 | I e II | 11 × 11 | 40.5 × 41.0 | 45.45 × 45.45 | IOM | GAF | P = 0.65 |
CGI-BD | P = 0.06 | ||||||
Depressive symptoms | P = 0.005 | ||||||
Miklowitz et al[42], 2003 | I | 31 × 70 | 35.6 × 36.6 | 58 × 66 | FFT | SADS-C | P = 0.001 |
New mood episode | P = 0.001 | ||||||
MTS | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Pakpour et al[43], 2017 | I e II | 134 × 136 | 41.8 × 41.2 | 55.2 × 50.7 | GP | MARS | P = 0.001 |
YMRS | P = 0.001 | ||||||
CGI | P = 0.001 | ||||||
QoL.BD | P = 0.001 | ||||||
Petzold et al[45], 2019 | I e II | 39 × 34 | 44.32 × 42.69 | 43.6 × 47.1 | GP | New mood episode | P = 0.175 |
YMRS | P = 0.241 | ||||||
HDRS | P = 0.58 | ||||||
SF-36 | P = 0.359 | ||||||
Morriss et al[7], 2016 | I e II | 153 × 151 | 44.2 × 46·5 | 60 × 56 | GP | Time between mood episodes | P = 0.012 |
SOFAS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
SAS | P > 0.05 | ||||||
Kessing et al[44], 2014 | I | 72 × 86 | 64.1 × 63 | 61.1 × 48.8 | GP | Time between mood episodes | P = 0.014 |
Hospitalizations | P = 0.064 | ||||||
Gumus et al[47], 2015 | I e II | 41 × 41 | 38.7 × 40.05 | 40.5 × 56.1 | GP | Number of mood episodes | P = 0.208 |
Eker et al[48], 2012 | ND | 35 × 36 | 34.57 × 36.54 | 54.3 × 52.8 | GP | ANT | P < 0.005 |
MARS | P < 0.005 | ||||||
Perry et al[49], 1999 | I | 34 × 35 | 44.1 × 45 | 68 × 69 | GP | Time between manic episodes | P = 0.008 |
Time between depressive episodes | P = 0.19 |
- Citation: Rabelo JL, Cruz BF, Ferreira JDR, Viana BM, Barbosa IG. Psychoeducation in bipolar disorder: A systematic review. World J Psychiatr 2021; 11(12): 1407-1424
- URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/2220-3206/full/v11/i12/1407.htm
- DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.5498/wjp.v11.i12.1407