Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2024.
World J Psychiatry. Jun 19, 2024; 14(6): 884-893
Published online Jun 19, 2024. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v14.i6.884
Table 1 Comparison of general data between the two groups, n (%)
Item
Intervention group (n = 60)
Control group (n = 60)
t
P value
Sex ratio1.671.96
        Male38 (63.3)31 (51.67)
        Female22 (36.7)29 (48.33)
Age (yr)45.11 ± 10.3746.14 ± 9.97-0.580.57
Nation01
        Han nationality55 (91.67)55 (91.67)
        Other5 (8.33)5 (8.33)
Duration of disease (yr)9.26 ± 3.029.36 ± 3.74-0.160.87
Number of hospitalizations (times)3.97 ± 1.634.13 ± 1.42-0.580.56
Years of schooling (yr)9.97 ± 1.7110.03 ± 1.36-0.230.82
Smoking history0.130.72
        Exist32 (53.33)30 (50.00)
        None28 (46.67)30 (50.00)
Drinking history0.330.56
        Exist22 (36.67)19 (31.67)
        None38 (66.3)41 (68.33)0.56
Marital status0.330.67
        Married41 (68.33)38 (63.33)
        Unmarried19 (31.67)22 (36.67)
Fertility0.190.66
        Infertile13 (21.67)16 (26.67)
        Rear47 (78.33)44 (73.33)
SBP (mmHg)128.06 ± 15.03129.81 ± 18.28-0.570.56
DBP (mmHg)80.53 ± 12.4183.15 ± 11.40-1.20.23
HR75.09 ± 15.9877.51 ± 14.78-0.870.39
Educational level0.390.53
        Less than high school27 (45.00)24 (40.00)
        High school and above33 (55.00)36 (60.00)
BMI (kg/m2)21.16 ± 1.2321.31 ± 1.41-0.640.53
Family history of mental illness0.870.35
        Exist26 (43.33)21 (35.00)
        None34 (56.67)39 (65.00)
Professional status0.30.58
        Incumbency28 (46.67)25 (41.67)
        Non-working32 (53.33)35 (58.33)
Residence0.030.85
        Towns33 (55.00)34 (56.67)
        Countryside27 (45.00)26 (43.33)
Forms of onset0.550.46
        Acute onset23 (38.33)27 (45.00)
        Chronic onset37 (61.67)33 (55.00)
Table 2 Comparison of positive and negative syndrome scale scores before and after treatment between the two groups of patients (mean ± SD)
Times
Groups
General pathology
Positive symptom
Negative symptom
Totals
Pre-treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)35.63 ± 2.0317.77 ± 1.5022.58 ± 1.9568.65 ± 7.63
Control groups (n = 60)36.02 ± 1.3117.63 ± 1.5822.28 ± 1.3366.25 ± 6.94
2 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)26.22 ± 2.49a11.85 ± 2.29 a15.63 ± 1.59a53.70 ± 3.46a
Control groups (n = 60)33.42 ± 3.3415.12 ± 1.8418.18 ± 3.6564.72 ± 5.53
4 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)20.39 ± 2.08a10.35 ± 2.91a10.13 ± 1.55a48.65 ± 2.67a
Control groups (n = 60)30.28 ± 1.4412.45 ± 3.0817.31 ± 3.2661.50 ± 2.17
6 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)12.21 ± 5.72a7.18 ± 6.48a9.12 ± 1.79a43.02 ± 7.62a
Control groups (n = 60)23.85 ± 5.6710.90 ± 2.3611.91 ± 2.0956.95 ± 6.94
Table 3 Comparison of Wisconsin Card Sorting Test scores before and after treatment between the two groups of patients (mean ± SD, n = 60)
Times
Groups
RE
RPE
RA
CC
Pre-treatmentIntervention group62.38 ± 1.7637.28 ± 1.26103.60 ± 1.763.33 ± 0.89
Control groups62.85 ± 3.6337.48 ± 1.20103.35 ± 1.883.28 ± 0.80
2 wk of treatmentIntervention group53.23 ± 2.06a25.07 ± 2.39a90.20 ± 4.28a4.03 ± 0.84a
Control groups56.73 ± 3.6832.62 ± 4.3997.65 ± 5.433.97 ± 0.89
4 wk of treatmentIntervention group47.04 ± 1.66a18.21 ± 3.19a82.46 ± 3.53a5.86 ± 2.07a
Control groups54.35 ± 1.2029.47 ± 2.8295.88 ± 2.344.78 ± 2.76
6 wk of treatmentIntervention group39.92 ± 2.29a10.50 ± 3.68a75.89 ± 1.58a7.42 ± 2.24a
Control groups52.24 ± 3.7125.41 ± 1.3691.92 ± 4.396.23 ± 1.72
Table 4 Comparison of therapeutic efficacy between the two groups of patients, n (%)
Groups
Precedent
Heal
Significant progress
Progress
Null
Intervention group6024 (40.00)18 (30.00)13 (21.67)5 (8.33)
Control groups6010 (16.67)22 (36.67)17 (28.33)11 (18.33)
t8.95
P value0.03
Table 5 Comparison of Social Functioning Scale for Psychiatric Inpatients scores before and after treatment between the two groups of patients
Times
Groups
Daily living skills
Motivation and socialization
Social mobility skills
SSPI total score
Pre-treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)6.15 ± 2.229.15 ± 2.317.04 ± 1.149.15 ± 2.31
Control groups (n = 60)6.52 ± 1.998.81 ± 2.446.62 ± 3.598.81 ± 2.44
2 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)11.06 ± 4.56a15.96 ± 3.80a11.99 ± 4.47a15.96 ± 3.80a
Control groups (n = 60)8.00 ± 3.2912.19 ± 3.788.03 ± 2.2112.19 ± 3.78
4 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)14.97 ± 3.29a18.85 ± 2.68a13.01 ± 2.95a18.85 ± 2.68a
Control groups (n = 60)11.32 ± 2.7915.72 ± 2.6310.79 ± 2.7815.72 ± 2.63
6 wk of treatmentIntervention group (n = 60)21.32 ± 1.29a27.92 ± 5.80a19.13 ± 4.68a25.66 ± 5.45a
Control groups (n = 60)14.78 ± 3.7717.69 ± 3.5114.13 ± 4.2918.84 ± 3.98