Observational Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Psychiatr. May 19, 2020; 10(5): 101-124
Published online May 19, 2020. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v10.i5.101
Table 1 Clinical high risk for psychosis criteria
Ultra-high risk (UHR) criteria as per the Structured Interview for Psychosis-Risk Syndromes (SIPS) and basic symptom (BS) criteria as per the Schizophrenia Proneness Instruments (SPI-A/SPI-CY)[15,16]
UHR: Brief Intermittent Psychotic Symptoms Syndrome (BIPSS)
≥ 1 of the following SIPS positive (P) items scored 6 = “severe and psychotic” with first appearance in the past 3 months and a presence of at least several minutes per day at a frequency of at least once per month but less than 7 d:
P1 Unusual Thought Content/Delusional Ideas
P2 Suspiciousness/Persecutory Ideas
P3 Grandiose Ideas
P4 Perceptual Abnormalities/Hallucinations
P5 Disorganized Communication
UHR: Attenuated Psychotic Symptoms Syndrome (APSS)
≥ 1 of the above P-items scored 3 = “moderate” to 5 = “severe but not psychotic” with a first appearance within the past year or current rating one or more scale points higher compared to 12 mo ago, and with an occurrence of an average frequency of at least once per week in the past month.
UHR: Genetic Risk and Deterioration Syndrome (GRDS)
Patient meets SIPS-criteria for Schizotypal Personality Disorder or has 1st-degree relative with a psychotic disorder, and has experienced > 30% drop in the global assessment of functioning score over the last month compared to 12 mo ago
BS: Cognitive-Perceptive Basic Symptoms (COPER)
≥ 1 of the following BS with a score of ≥ 3 = “frequency of at least several times in a month or weekly” within the last 3 mo and with first occurrence ≥ 12 mo ago:
Thought interference
Thought perseveration
Thought pressure
Thought blockages
Disturbance of receptive speech
Decreased ability to discriminate between ideas/perception, fantasy/memories
Unstable ideas of reference
Derealization
Visual perception disturbances (excl. hypersensitivity to light or blurred vision)
Acoustic perception disturbances (excl. hypersensitivity to sounds)
BS: Cognitive Disturbances (COGDIS)
≥ 2 of the following BS with a score of ≥ 3 within the last 3 mo:
Inability to divide attention
Thought interference
Thought pressure
Thought blockages
Disturbance of receptive speech
Disturbance of expressive speech
Unstable ideas of reference
Disturbances of abstract thinking
Captivation of attention by details of the visual field
Table 2 Sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of the sample
Total sample (n = 2916)Males (n = 1550)Females (n = 1366)χ²(df)/U; P value (Cramer’s V/Rosenthal’s r)
Study participation: n (%) in BEAR2683 (92.0)1447 (93.4)1236 (90.5)8.14 (1); 0.004 (0.053)
Age in years: mean ± SD, Mdn28.8 ± 8.7, 3128.6 ± 8.6, 3129.0 ± 8.9; 321031227.0; 0.226 (0.022)
Nationality: n (%) Swiss2708 (92.9)1433 (92.5)1275 (93.3)0.86 (1); 0.353 (0.017)
Marital status: n (%) single1730 (59.3)977 (63.0)753 (55.1)18.82 (1); < 0.001 (0.080)
Concluded school education: n (%) yes2538 (87.0)1372 (88.5)1166 (85.4)6.42 (1); 0.011 (0.047)
Highest school education: n (%)5.14 (3); 0.162 (0.042)
ISCED 1148 (5.1)78 (5.0)70 (5.1)
ISCED 21689 (57.9)921 (59.4)768 (56.2)
ISCED 3 (34+35)1079 (37.0)551 (35.6)528 (38.7)
Current occupation: n (%)27.96 (4); < 0.001 (0.098)
Unemployed61 (2.1)37 (2.4)24 (1.8)
Sheltered work place7 (0.2)7 (0.5)0
Self-employed or temporary job, or other34 (1.2)6 (0.4)28 (2.1)
Normal occupation incl. education2814 (96.5)1500 (96.8)1314 (96.2)
1st- or 2nd-degree relative with mental disorder: n (%)11133 (39.0)479 (31.0)654 (48.1)87.93 (1); < 0.001 (0.174)
With psychosis89 (3.1)34 (2.2)55 (4.0)8.22 (1); 0.004 (0.053)
With affective disorder691 (23.8)274 (17.8)417 (30.6)66.18 (1); < 0.001 (0.151)
Current SOFAS score: mean ± SD, Mdn85.2 ± 7.1, 8785.4 ± 7.3, 8885.0 ± 6.9, 87998335.5; 0.007 (0.050)
Highest-past-year SOFAS score: mean ± SD, Mdn85.4 ± 6.9, 8785.6 ± 7.0, 8885.2 ± 6.8, 871002860.0; 0.013 (0.079)
Psychosocial impairment (SOFAS ≤ 70): n (%)161 (5.5)79 (5.1)82 (6.0)1.13 (1); 0.285 (0.020)
Current mental disorder: n (%)386 (13.4)158 (10.2)228 (16.7)26.69 (1); < 0.001 (0.096)
Table 3 Frequency of clinical high risk symptoms in age groups and sexes, n (% of group)
Any BSAny cognitive BSAny perceptual BSAny APS or BIPSAny delusional APS or BIPSAny hallucinatory APS or BIPSAny speech disorganization APS
8-12 yr21 (17.9)14 (12.0)11 (9.4)36 (30.8)6 (5.1)32 (27.4)1 (0.9)
13-15 yr18 (26.1)15 (21.7)5 (7.2)15 (21.7)4 (5.8)14 (20.3)0
16-17 yr30 (15.7)17 (8.9)20 (10.5)38 (19.9)15 (7.9)32 (16.8)0
18-19 yr27 (16.2)19 (11.4)9 (5.4)27 (16.2)9 (5.4)21 (12.6)0
20-24 yr40 (8.1)20 (4.1)23 (4.7)58 (11.8)23 (4.7)42 (8.5)1 (0.2)
25-29 yr23 (7.2)12 (3.8)11 (3.4)33 (10.3)15 (4.7)22 (6.9)2 (0.6)
30-40 yr102 (6.5)68 (4.4)41 (2.6)174 (11.2)113 (7.2)98 (6.3)16 (1.0)
Male110 (7.1)69 (4.5)51 (3.3)161 (10.4)79 (5.1)107 (6.9)15 (1.0)
Female151 (11.1)96 (7.0)69 (5.1)220 (16.1)106 (7.8)154 (11.3)5 (0.4)
Total261 (9.0)165 (5.7)120 (4.1)381 (13.1)185 (6.3)261 (9.0)20 (0.7)
Table 4 Frequency of clinical high risk criteria in age groups and sexes, n (% of group)
Any CHR criterionAny EPA criterionCOPERCOGDISAPSSBIPSSGRDS, only by family history
8-12 yr7 (6.0)5 (4.3)2 (1.7)1 (0.9)4 (3.4)00
13-15 yr5 (7.2)4 (5.8)3 (4.3)3 (4.3)1 (1.4)00
16-17 yr9 (4.7)1 (0.5)9 (4.7)1 (0.5)000
18-19 yr5 (3.0)3 (1.8)4 (2.4)3 (1.8)1 (0.6)00
20-24 yr19 (3.9)11 (2.2)12 (2.4)3 (0.6)8 (1.8)1 (0.2)0
25-29 yr4 (1.3)1 (0.3)3 (0.9)01 (0.3)00
30-40 yr33 (2.1)13 (0.8)30 (1.9)10 (0.6)5 (0.3)00
Male29 (1.9)13 (0.8)22 (1.4)6 (0.4)9 (0.6)00
Female53 (3.9)25 (1.8)41 (3.0)15 (1.1)11 (0.8)1 (0.1)0
Total82 (2.8)38 (1.3)63 (2.2)21 (0.7)20 (0.7)1 (0.03)0
Table 5 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 of the 11 basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category64.14660.000
8-12 yr0.9070.2929.65510.0022.4771.3984.390
13-15 yr1.3860.32018.75310.0003.9972.1357.483
16-17 yr0.7470.2588.35510.0042.1101.2723.501
18-19 yr0.7810.2678.54910.0032.1841.2943.687
25-29 yr-0.1280.272.22110.6390.8800.5161.500
30-40 yr-0.2330.1941.43810.2300.79201.159
Sex
Male-0.4870.13113.74710.00000.4750.795
Table 6 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 of the 9 cognitive basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category56.27960
8-12 yr1.1680.36510.23310.0013.2151.5726.574
13-15 yr1.8820.37125.80910.0006.5693.17813.581
16-17 yr0.8380.3426.01110.0142.3111.1834.513
18-19 yr1.1110.33411.06210.0013.0361.5785.842
25-29 yr-0.0790.3720.04510.8330.9240.4461.918
30-40 yr0.0750.2600.08310.7731.0780.6481.794
Sex
Male-0.4840.1628.88110.0030.6160.4480.847
Table 7 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 of the 2 perceptual basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category35.62060.000
8-12 yr0.7520.3823.87210.0492.1211.0034.484
13-15 yr0.4680.5110.83810.3601.5960.5864.347
16-17 yr0.8710.3197.48310.0062.3901.2804.462
18-19 yr0.1520.4040.14110.7071.1640.5282.568
25-29 yr-0.3150.3740.71010.4000.7300.3511.519
30-40 yr-0.5950.2665.01110.0250.5520.3280.929
Sex
Male-0.4470.1895.62310.0180.6400.4420.925
Table 8 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 of the 5 attenuated psychotic symptoms or brief intermittent psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category50.07060.000
8-12 yr1.2040.24424.29510.0003.3332.0655.380
13-15 yr0.7340.3245.14410.0232.0831.1053.928
16-17 yr0.6220.2297.38610.0071.8631.1892.917
18-19 yr0.3690.2522.13810.1441.4460.8822.372
25-29 yr-0.1450.2310.39210.5310.8650.5501.361
30-40 yr-0.0600.1610.13910.7090.9420.6861.292
Sex
Male-0.5050.11120.61310.0000.6040.4860.751
Table 9 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 of the 3 delusional attenuated psychotic symptoms or brief intermittent psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category7.12060.310
8-12 yr0.0990.4700.04510.8331.1050.4392.777
13-15 yr0.2290.5580.16910.6811.2580.4223.751
16-17 yr0.5550.3432.61010.1061.7420.8883.414
18-19 yr0.1520.4040.14110.7071.1640.5282.568
25-29 yr0.0080.3400.00110.9811.0080.5181.963
30-40 yr0.4670.2353.96110.0471.5961.0072.529
Sex
Male-0.4490.1548.54810.0030.6380.4730.862
Table 10 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of hallucinatory attenuated psychotic symptoms or brief intermittent psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category80.88660.000
8-12 yr1.3970.26328.26210.0004.0432.4156.766
13-15 yr1.0060.3408.74410.0032.7331.4045.323
16-17 yr0.7710.2529.34310.0022.1611.3183.542
18-19 yr0.4350.2842.34810.1251.5450.8862.693
25-29 yr-0.2290.2740.70010.4030.7950.4651.360
30-40 yr-0.3290.1922.92910.0870.7200.4941.049
Sex
Male-0.5390.13216.71110.0000.5840.4510.756
Table 11 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of speech-disorganization attenuated psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category2.77760.836
8-12 yr1.4451.4181.03810.3084.2410.26368.311
13-15 yr-15.0044838.6650.00010.9980.0000.000.
16-17 yr-15.0042908.2610.00010.9960.0000.000.
18-19 yr-15.0043110.2260.00010.9960.0000.000.
25-29 yr1.1331.2270.85210.3563.1040.28034.375
30-40 yr1.6291.0322.49110.1145.0980.67438.543
Sex
Male0.9780.5183.57010.0592.6600.9647.338
Table 12 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 of the 11 basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0620.00942.50310.0000.9400.9230.958
Sex-1.4500.41612.18110.0000.2350.1040.529
Age and sex0.0360.0155.88710.0151.0361.0071.067
Table 13 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 of the 9 cognitive basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0460.00926.59210.0000.9550.9390.972
Sex-0.4960.1639.25010.0020.6090.4420.838
Table 14 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 of the 2 perceptual basic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0780.01432.11010.0000.9250.9010.950
Sex-1.9710.58011.55610.0010.1390.0450.434
Age and sex0.0600.0217.89310.0051.0621.0181.107
Table 15 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 of the 5 attenuated psychotic symptoms or brief intermittent psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0240.00614.92310.0000.9760.9640.988
Age and sex-0.0190.00421.89110.0000.9820.9740.989
Table 16 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of hallucinatory attenuated psychotic symptoms or brief intermittent psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0470.00740.90410.0000.9540.9400.968
Age and sex-0.0220.00518.54710.0000.9780.9690.988
Table 17 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of speech-disorganization attenuated psychotic symptoms
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and sex0.0470.0168.50510.0041.0481.0161.082
Table 18 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 clinical high risk criterion
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category17.71460.007
8-12 yr0.4620.4551.03410.3091.5880.6513.870
13-15 yr0.6670.5201.64710.1991.9490.7035.400
16-17 yr0.2100.4140.25710.6121.2340.5482.777
18-19 yr-0.2610.5110.26210.6090.7700.2832.095
25-29 yr-1.1500.5554.29110.0380.3170.1070.940
30-40 yr-0.6180.2934.45310.0350.5390.3040.957
Sex
Male-0.7500.23410.27210.0010.4720.2990.747
Table 19 Simple effects of age group and sex on presence of ≥ 1 European Psychiatric Association-recommended clinical high risk criterion
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age category22.23060.001
8-12 yr0.6710.5491.49110.2221.9560.6665.743
13-15 yr0.9920.5992.74610.0982.6970.8348.717
16-17 yr-1.4671.0481.96010.1620.2310.0301.799
18-19 yr-0.2210.6580.11310.7370.8020.2212.908
25-29 yr-1.9821.0473.58410.0580.1380.0181.073
30-40 yr-0.9990.4135.85210.0160.3680.1640.827
Sex
Male-0.7900.3445.27910.0220.4540.2310.890
Table 20 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 clinical high risk criterion
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0430.01212.10110.0010.9580.9350.982
Sex-0.7600.23510.51110.0010.4680.2950.740
Table 21 Combined effects of selected age and sex predictors on presence of ≥ 1 European Psychiatric Association-recommended clinical high risk criterion
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age-0.0550.0189.48010.0020.9460.9140.980
Sex-0.7990.3455.37210.0200.4500.2290.884
Table 22 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 11 basic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and BS0.0510.00662.37410.0001.0521.0391.066
Table 23 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 9 cognitive basic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and BS0.0550.00754.24010.0001.0561.0411.072
Table 24 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 2 perceptual basic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and sex and BS0.0620.01131.58810.0001.0641.0411.087
Table 25 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 5 attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and APS-0.0430.01212.10110.0010.9580.9350.982
Table 26 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 3 delusional attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and APS0.0640.006117.31810.0001.0661.0541.079
Table 27 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (hallucinatory attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and APS0.0480.00751.01410.0001.0491.0351.063
Table 28 Combined effects of selected age, sex and criteria (≥ 1 clinical high risk criterion) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and CHR criterion0.0910.009100.73810.0001.0951.0761.115
Table 29 Combined effects of selected age, sex and criteria (≥ 1 European Psychiatric Association criterion) predictors on presence of psychosocial impairment (Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale ≤ 70)
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Age and EPA criterion0.1070.01457.02110.0001.1131.0831.145
Table 30 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 11 basic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5680.11126.22410.0000.5670.4560.704
Table 31 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 9 cognitive basic symptom) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5470.11223.95310.0000.5790.4650.720
Age and BS0.0390.00635.95610.0001.0391.0261.053
Table 32 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 2 perceptual basic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5470.11223.96310.0000.5790.4650.721
BS1.1350.20630.35510.0003.1122.0784.660
Table 33 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 5 attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.4880.11318.48210.0000.6140.4920.767
APS1.3180.129104.56710.0003.7352.9024.809
Table 34 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (≥ 1 of 3 delusional attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5280.11321.96310.0000.5900.4730.735
APS1.4420.16576.39110.0004.2303.0615.845
Table 35 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (hallucinatory attenuated psychotic symptoms/brief intermittent psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5150.11221.00510.0000.5980.4800.745
APS1.0990.15053.83510.0003.0022.2384.026
Table 36 Combined effects of selected age, sex and symptoms (speech-disorganization attenuated psychotic symptoms) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5990.11228.56110.0000.5500.4410.685
Age and APS0.0610.01321.20110.0001.0631.0361.091
Table 37 Combined effects of selected age, sex and criteria (≥ 1 clinical high risk criterion) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5250.11221.78410.0000.5920.4750.738
CHR criterion1.7460.23157.30010.0005.7343.6489.012
Table 38 Combined effects of selected age, sex and criteria (≥ 1 European Psychiatric Association criterion) predictors on presence of any non-psychotic axis-I disorder
BetaSEWalddfP valueExp (Beta)95%CI; lower95%CI; upper
Sex-0.5430.11223.51610.0000.5810.4660.724
EPA criterion2.0660.33438.30610.0007.8964.10415.192