Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Crit Care Med. Aug 7, 2020; 9(3): 43-53
Published online Aug 7, 2020. doi: 10.5492/wjccm.v9.i3.43
Table 1 Clinical and demographic characteristics of all patients with mechanical ventilation during the study period (n = 263)
Characteristics, n (%)Total (n = 263)VAP (n = 32)Non-VAP (n = 231)P value
Age (yr)151.9 ± 17.849 ± 19.752.3 ± 17.50.329
Gender- Masculine137 (52.1)16 (50)110 (47.6)0.800
Body mass index126.2 ± 5.624.9 ± 4.526.4 ± 5.70.188
Solid tumor2188 (68.1)25 (67.6)163 (68.2)0.938
Cervical21 (7.6)2 (5.4)19 (7.9)0.749
Head and neck21 (7.6)3 (8.1)18 (7.5)1
Colon-rectum20 (7.2)1 (2.7)19 (7.9)0.492
Breast18 (6.5)2 (5.4)16 (6.7)1
Germinal15 (5.4)2 (5.4)13 (5.4)1
Esophagus-stomach14 (5.1)3 (8.1)11 (4.6)0.399
Sarcoma13 (4.7)2 (5.4)11 (4.6)0.688
Ovarian10 (3.6)1 (2.7)9 (3.8)1
Lung10 (3.6)1 (2.7)9 (3.8)1
Prostate9 (3.3)2 (5.4)7 (2.9)0.348
Liver and bile ducts9 (3.3)1 (2.7)8 (3.3)1
Pancreas7 (2.5)1 (2.7)6 (2.5)1
Kidney and bladder5 (1.8)2 (5.4)3 (1.3)0.136
Other16 (5.8)2 (5.4)14 (5.9)1
Hematological malignancies288 (31.9)12 (32.4)76 (31.8)0.938
Lymphoblastic leukemia26 (9.4)3 (8.1)23 (9.6)1
Myeloid leukemia12 (4.3)3 (8.1)9 (3.8)0.207
Non-Hodgkin lymphoma25 (9.1)2 (5.4)23 (9.6)0.548
Hodgkin lymphoma4 (1.5)1 (2.7)3 (1.2)0.439
Multiple myeloma14 (5.1)2 (5.4)12 (5)1
Other37 (2.5)1 (2.7)6 (2.5)1
Cancer stage
Recent diagnosis117 (44.5)11(34.4)105 (45.4)0.236
Progression93 (35.4)16 (50)78 (33.8)0.07
Relapse30 (11.4)2 (6.2)28 (12.1)0.551
Partial remission21 (8)2 (6.2)19 (8.2)1
Complete remission2 (0.7)1 (3.1)1 (0.4)0.228
Chemotherapy within 3 mo99 (37.6)16 (50)83 (35.9)0.123
Radiotherapy during the previous 6 mo23 (8.7)3 (94)20 (8.7)0.749
Biologic antineoplastic drugs22 (8.4)6 (18.8)16 (6.9)0.155
Charlson index3 (2, 5)3 (2, 5)3 (2, 5)1
Hospital admission within 3-mo period75 (28.5)5 (15.6)70 (30.3)0.09
Days of recent hospitalization47 (4,12)5 (4,9)7 (4,12)0.544
Recent broad antimicrobials36 (13.7)1 (3.1)35 (15.1)0.09
Table 2 Clinical data related with current hospitalization and mechanical ventilation (n = 263)
Characteristic – n (%)Total (n = 263)VAP (n = 32)Non-VAP (n = 231)P value
Length of hospitalization (d)122 (14, 34)32 (22, 57)21 (14, 32)0.0001
Length of ICU stay (d)18 (5, 13)18 (9, 27)8 (5, 12)< 0.0001
Causes for MV
Septic shock91 (34.6)10 (31.3)81 (35)0.843
Post-surgical procedure42 (16)8 (25)34 (14.7)0.193
Respiratory failure secondary to pneumonia37 (14)3 (9.4)34 (14.7)0.589
Hypovolemic shock37 (14)8 (25)29 (12.5)0.09
Neurologic cause13 (4.9)013 (5.6)N/A
Lung tumor activity7 (2.7)1 (3.1)6 (2.6)0.601
Post-CPR7 (2.7)1 (3.1)6 (2.6)0.601
Acute pulmonary edema6 (2.3)06 (2.6)N/A
Malignant central airway obstruction5 (1.9)05 (2.2)N/A
Cardiac failure3 (1.1)1 (3.1)2 (0.8)0.323
Bronchospasm2 (0.8)02 (0.8)N/A
Pulmonary embolism2 (0.8)02 (0.8)N/A
TRALI1 (0.4)01 (0.4)N/A
Other causes10 (3.8)010 (4.3)N/A
SOFA at ICU admission28.3 ± 3.48.7 ± 2.88.3 ± 3.40.477
Days of mechanical ventilation18 (4, 12)16 (9, 27)7 (4, 11)< 0.0001
Tracheostomy68 (25.9)19 (59.4)49 (21.2)< 0.0001
Re-intubation27 (10.3)7 (21.9)20 (8.7)0.03
Mortality at 60 d116 (44.1)9 (28.1)72 (31.7)0.839
Table 3 Univariate and multivariate analysis for ventilator-associated pneumonia in patients with mechanical ventilation (n = 263)
CharacteristicsUnivariate
Multivariate
NAV (n = 32)No-NAV (n = 231)P valueORP value
Female16 (50)121 (52.4)0.8-
Male16 (50)110 (47.6)
Age < 60 yr21 (65.6)134 (58)0.411-
Age ≥ 60 yr11 (34.4)97 (42)
Solid tumor12 (37.5)76 (32.9)0.605-
Hematologic malignancy20 (62.5)155 (67.1)
Recent diagnosis, complete or partial remission14 (43.8)125 (54.1)0.27110.541
Progression or relapse18 (56.2)106 (45.9)1.3 (0.55 - 3.03)
Non-recent chemotherapy16 (50)148 (64.1)0.12310.727
Recent chemotherapy16 (50)83 (35.9)1.16 (0.49-2.76)
SOFA at ICU admission8.71 ± 2.798.26 ± 3.420.477-
Days of hospitalization length132 (22, 57)21 (14, 32)0.000110.301
1 (0.99- 1.01)
Days of ICU length118 (9, 27)8 (5, 12)< 0.00011< 0.0001
1.11 (1.06-1.17)
Alive10 (31.2)122 (52.8)0.0210.125
Death22 (68.8)109 (47.2)2.04 (0.82-5.12)
Table 4 Use of antimicrobials in patients with ventilator-associated pneumonia vs those who did not develop the latter
Antimicrobial treatmentTotal (n = 263)Non-VAP (n = 233)VAP (n = 30)P value
Antibacterial treatment
Cephalosporins58 (22)47 (20.2)11 (36.7)0.03
Days of cephalosporins126 (4, 9)6 (4, 9)4 (4, 10)0.856
TZP86 (32.6)69 (29.6)17 (56.7)0.002
Days of TZP26 (4, 9)7 (4, 9)6 (5, 7)0.895
Aminoglycosides18 (6.8)14 (6)4 (13.3)0.134
Days of aminoglycosides24 (3, 6)3 (3, 5)5 (4, 7)0.469
Carbapenem228 (86.7)198 (85)30 (100)0.02
Days of Carbapenem211 (7, 17)10 (6, 16)13 (10, 22)0.003
Fluoroquinolones31 (11.8)23 (9.9)8 (26.7)0.006
Days of fluoroquinolones210 (7, 14)11 (7, 14)9 (5, 15)0.586
Vancomycin153 (58.2)130 (55.8)24 (80)0.01
Days of vancomycin27 (4, 10)7 (4, 10)7 (4, 10)0.684
Linezolid47 (17.8)39 (16.7)8 (26.7)0.205
Days of linezolid29 (5, 12)8 (4, 11)14 (8, 21)0.05
Clarithromycin68 (25.8)59 (25.3)9 (30)0.657
Days of clarithromycin28 (7, 10)8 (6, 10)8 (8,10)0.505
SMX/TMP68 (25.8)56 (24)12 (40)0.06
Days of SMX/TMP28 (5, 13)12 (7, 21)12 (8, 14)0.577
Colistin11 (4.2)7 (3)4 (13.3)0.02
Days of colistin210 (4, 11)8 (3, 11)11 (8, 12)0.341
Table 5 Univariate and multivariate analysis for 60-d mortality in patients with mechanical ventilation (n = 263)
CharacteristicsUnivariate
Multivariate
Alive (n = 147)Death (n = 116)P valueORP value
Female79 (53.7)58 (50)0.546-
Male68 (46.3)58 (50)
Age < 60 yr83 (56.5)72 (62.1)0.358-
Age ≥ 60 yr64 (43.5)44 (37.9)
Solid tumor101 (68.7)74 (63.8)0.401-
Hematologic malignancy46 (31.3)42 (36.2)
Recent diagnosis, complete or partial remission85 (57.8)54 (46.6)0.06910.237
Progression or relapse62 (42.2)62 (53.4)1.38 (0.81-2.37)
Non-recent chemotherapy103 (70.1)61 (52.6)0.00310.006
Recent chemotherapy44 (29.9)55 (47.4)2.16 (1.24-3.76)
SOFA at ICU admission8.45 ± 3.458.15 ± 3.20.471-
Non-tracheostomy115 (78.2)80 (69)0.08810.01
Required tracheostomy32 (21.8)36 (31)2.52 (1.24-5.13)
Days of ICU length8 (6, 13)8 (5, 15)0.457-
Days of mechanical ventilation7 (4, 11)9 (5, 14)0.02910.15
1.04 (1.008-1.07)
Non-VAP132 (89.8)99 (85.3)0.342-
VAP15 (10.2)17 (14.7)