Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Gastrointest Surg. Dec 27, 2020; 12(12): 534-548
Published online Dec 27, 2020. doi: 10.4240/wjgs.v12.i12.534
Table 1 Summary of the demographic and clinicopathological characteristics of 91 patients published in the literature between 1925 and 2020
Ref.
Year
Country
Language
Age
Sex
History of liver disease
Preliminary diagnosis
Radiologic tools
Kachi et al[1]2020LebanonEnglish44FNoCCUS
62FNoCCNA
Avdaj et al[2]2020KosovoEnglish47FNoCCUS
Baral et al[3]2019United StatesEnglish67FNoCCUS
Yuksel et al[4]2019TurkeyEnglish34FNACCUS
Mannan et al[5]2019S. ArabiaEnglish38FNAACUS
Isa et al[6]2019BahrainEnglish42FNoCCUS
Pandit et al[7]2019NepalEnglish30FNABiliary pancreatitis US + MRCP
Granek et al[8]2019AustraliaEnglish36MNAACUS
Lodha et al[9]2018IndiaEnglish50MNAKidney tumorCT
Topcu et al[10]2018TurkeyEnglish64FNAACUS
70FNAIcterusUS + CT + MR
Burke et al[11]2018IrelandEnglish30FNACCUS
Greenberg et al[12]2018United StatesEnglish52FFLDAPUS + CT
Termos et al[13]2017KuwaitEnglish73FNAGBCUS + CT
Weber-Alvarez et al[14]2017MexicoEnglish37FNAACUS
Galimov et al[15]2017RussiaRussian70MNAACUS
Handra-Luca et al[16]2016FranceEnglish68FNACCUS
56FNACCUS
Mani et al[17]2016United StatesEnglish56MFLDACCT
Ito et al[18]2016JapanEnglish59FNACCMR + CT
Leena et al[19]2016IndiaEnglish25MNACadaverAutopsy
Karaca et al[20]2016TurkeyEnglish43FNACCUS
Jaboury et al[21]2016AustraliaEnglish22FNACCNA
Yahya et al[22]2016LibyaEnglish35FNACCUS
45FNACCUS
45FNACCNA
20FNAPenetrating injuryNA
Aslan et al[23]2016TurkeyEnglish49FNACCUS
Longjam et al[24]2016IndiaEnglish42FNACCUS
Kostov et al[25]2016BulgariaEnglish49MRCLMRCLMNA
Bal et al[26]2015TurkeyEnglish51FNACCUS
Smyth et al[27]2015AustraliaEnglish77FNACCUS
Abhilash et al[28]2015IndiaEnglish45FNAACUS
Hussein et al[29]2015LebanonEnglish49FNAACCT
Yankol et al[30]2015TurkeyEnglish30MNoLiving donorUS + CT + MRCP
Arslan et al[31]2014TurkeyEnglish59FNACCUS
Pulle et al[32]2014IndiaEnglish43FNACCUS
Terakawa et al[33]2014JapanJapanese33FNACCUS + MRCP
Sirasanagandla et al[34]2013IndiaEnglish62MNACadaverNA
Hassan et al[35]2013IndiaEnglish32FNACCUS
Martinez et al[36]2013BrazilEnglish37FNAACUS
Ozturk et al[37]2013TurkeyTurkish35FNoCCUS
Yajima et al[38]2013JapanJapanese73FNACCUS + CT
Khan et al[39]2013IndiaEnglish32FNACCNA
Karaman et al[40]2012TurkeyEnglish63MNACCUS
Patel et al[41]2012United KingdomEnglish21FNACCUS
Sozen et al[42]2012TurkeyTurkish40FNACCUS
Catani et al[43]2011ItalyEnglish72FNAACUS
83FNoCCUS
Dettmer et al[44]2011SwitzerlandEnglish91FNAACCT
Nagar et al[45]2011United StatesEnglish25FNAAP + Cystic massUS + CT + MRCP
Ates et al[46]2010TurkeyTurkish64FNAACNA
49MNACCUS
Triantafyllidis et al[47]2009GreeceEnglish56FNACCUS
Guzman et al[48]2009MexicoSpanish36MNACCUS
Kyeong et al[49]2008S. KoreaEnglish66FNACCCT
Koh et al[50]2007AustraliaEnglish60FNAACNA
Malhas et al[51]2007United KingdomEnglish42MFLDCCUS
39FNACCUS
Soto et al[52]2007United StatesEnglish32FNACCUS
Beltran et al[53]2007ChileEnglish47MNACCUS
33FNACCUS
27MNAGastric cancer US + CT
35MNAPancreatic pseudocyst US + CT
Wang et al[54]2006ChinaChinese38MNAGallbladder polypsUS
Ikeda et al[55]2006JapanEnglish70MNoHCC + CirrUS + CT
Ngowe et al[56]2006CameroonFrench46FNACCUS
Lundy et al[57]2005United StatesEnglish38FFLDLiver tumorUS + CT
Leone et al[58]2004ItalyEnglish54FNOGBCUS + CT
Griniatsos et al[59]2002United KingdomEnglish39FNACCUS
49MNACCUS
Acar et al[60]2002TurkeyEnglish55FNACCUS
Sakarya et al[61]2002TurkeyEnglishNANANANANA
Arakawa et al[62]1999JapanEnglish48MALDALDAutopsy
Hamdani et al[63]1994United StatesEnglish49MCirrPSCUS + CT
Boyle et al[64]1992United StatesEnglish44FNoACUS
Tejada et al[65]1989United StatesEnglish43MNACC + HSUS
Watanabe et al[66]1989JapanEnglish37MCLLCLLCT
54MCirrALDLaparoscopy
64FCirrCirrCT
71FCirrCirrLaparoscopy
Fellbaum et al[67]1987AustriaGerman34FNACCNA
Natori et al[68]1986JapanEnglish56FNACCCT
Ashby et al[69]1969United KingdomEnglish42MNADuodenal ulcerNA
BASSIS et al[70]1956United StatesEnglishNANANACCNA
NANANACCNA
NANANACCNA
5dMNACadaverNo
Thorsness et al[71]1941United StatesEnglish63FNACadaverNo
Cullen et al[72]1925United StatesEnglish33FNoJaundiceNA
Table 2 Summary of the surgical and histopathological characteristics of 91 patients published in the literature between 1925 and 2020
Ref.
Lesion sizes (mm)
Surgical indication
Surgical procedure
Histopathological findings of ELT
Histopathological findings of GB
Kachi et al[1], 202010CCLCELTNA
5CCLCELTNA
Avdaj et al[2], 2020NACCLCELTNA
Baral et al[3], 201930CCLCELTNA
Yuksel et al[4], 201917CCLCELTCC
Mannan et al[5], 20195ACLCELTNA
Isa et al[6], 2019NACCLCELTNA
Pandit et al[7], 201935CCLCELTNA
Granek et al[8], 201919ACLCELTNA
Lodha et al[9], 201820Kidney tumorLap nephrectomyELT (no excised)NA
Topcu et al[10], 201815CCOCELTNA
80Pancreatic tumorWhipple procedureELTNA
Burke et al[11], 2018NACCLCELTNA
Greenberg et al[12], 201830CCLCELTNA
Termos et al[13], 201730Diag lapLCELTNA
Weber-Alvarez et al[14], 201710ACLCELTAC + CC
Galimov et al[15], 20176ACLCELTPhlegmonous cholecystitis
Handra-Luca et al[16], 20165CCLCELTCC
11CCLCELTCC
Mani et al[17], 2016NACCLCELTNA
Ito et al[18], 201615CCLCELTNA
Leena et al[19], 201615AutopsyAutopsyELTNA
Karaca et al[20], 201615CCLCELTNA
Jaboury et al[21], 2016NACCLCELTNA
Yahya et al[22 ], 201660CCLCELTNA
NACCLCELTNA
NACCLCELTNA
NAPenetrating injuryDiag lapELTNA
Aslan et al[23], 20168CCLCELTNA
Longjam et al[24], 201615CCLCELTCC
Kostov et al[25], 201635RCLMOCELTHydatid cyst on gallbladder wall
Bal et al[26], 201520CCLCELTNA
Smyth et al[27], 201520CCLCELTCC
Abhilash et al[28], 201510ACLCELTCC
Hussein et al[29], 2015NAACLCELTNA
Yankol et al[30], 201515Donor hepatectomyLDHELTAccessory gallbladder tissue
Arslan et al[31], 201420CCLCELTNA
Pulle et al[32], 201420CCLCELTCC
Terakawa et al[33], 201412CCLCELTNA
Sirasanagandla et al[34], 201320AutopsyAutopsyELTNA
Hassan et al[35], 201310CCLCELTCC
Martinez et al[36], 201330CCLCELTChronic inflammation
Ozturk et al[37], 201320CCLCELTNA
Yajima et al[38], 20136CCLCELTNA
Khan et al[39], 2013NACCLCELT (Fatty change)CC
Karaman et al[40], 201211CCLCELTNA
Patel et al[41], 201226CCLCELTNA
Sozen et al[42], 20127CCLCELTNA
Catani et al[43], 201115ACLCELTNA
14CCLCELTNA
Dettmer et al[44], 201115ACLCELTAcute cholecystitis
Nagar et al[45], 201145AP + Cystic massLCELTCC
Ates et al[46], 20105ACLCELTNA
6CCLCELTNA
Triantafyllidis et al[47], 200915CCLCELTCC
Guzman et al[48], 200930CCLCELTNA
Kyeong et al[49], 200810CCLCELTCC
Koh et al[50], 200715ACLCELTNA
Malhas et al[51], 2007NACCLCELTNA
NACCLCELTNA
Soto et al[52], 20078CCLCELTNA
Beltran et al[53], 200712CCLCELTCC
17CCLCELTNA
7Gastric cancer OC + GastrectomyELTNA
18Pancreatic pseudocyst OC + GastrectomyELTNA
Wang et al[54], 200611Gallbladder polypsLCELTCC + Polyps
Ikeda et al[55], 2006NAHCCOC + Segment V ResectionNASHNA
Ngowe et al[56], 200630CCLCELTCC
Lundy et al[57], 200530Diag lapLCELTNA
Leone et al[58], 200490GBCOCELT + HCCNA
Griniatsos et al[59], 200210CCLCELTNA
15CCLCELTNA
Acar et al[60], 200214CCOCELTPapillary epithelial hyperplasia
Sakarya et al[61], 2002NANALCNANA
Arakawa et al[62], 199915AutopsyAutopsyELTNA
Hamdani et al[63], 199430PSCLTELTNA
Boyle et al[64], 199220ACOCELTCC
Tejada et al[65], 198911CCOC + SplenectomyELTCC
Watanabe et al[66], 19895Cystic lesion of the liverDiag lapBiliary hamartomaNA
8CirrDiag lapNANA
10CirrDiag lapNANA
6CirrDiag lapNANA
Fellbaum et al[67], 1987NANANANANA
Natori et al[68], 198612CCOC + ExcisionELTChronic inflammation
Ashby et al[69], 196910Duodenal ulcerOC + ExcisionELTNA
BASSIS et al[70], 195615CCOCELTCC
10CCOCELTCC
6CCOCELTCC
8AutopsyAutopsyELTNA
Thorsness et al[71], 19415AutopsyAutopsyELTNA
Cullen et al[72], 192512JaundiceExcisionNANA