Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2024.
World J Hepatol. Dec 27, 2024; 16(12): 1429-1440
Published online Dec 27, 2024. doi: 10.4254/wjh.v16.i12.1429
Table 1 Clinical characteristics between resolved hepatitis B virus patients and healthy controls before and after propensity score matching for age and sex
CharacteristicBefore PSM
After PSM
Resolved HBV,
n = 11186
Healthy controls,
n = 5666
P value
Resolved HBV,
n = 5015
Healthy controls,
n = 5015
P value
Age, year57.41 ± 9.3151.29 ± 11.25< 0.00153.39 ± 10.2353.32 ± 10.320.729
Male3445 (30.80)1553 (27.41)< 0.0011252 (24.97)1331 (26.54)0.071
BMI, kg/m224.20 ± 3.6024.13 ± 3.880.266 24.12 ± 3.8324.16 ± 3.820.619
Body fat %29.41 ± 7.4629.52 ± 7.440.37529.87 ± 7.4529.71 ± 7.420.309
WC, cm83.48 ± 9.7882.82 ± 10.32< 0.00182.66 ± 10.1083.02 ± 10.150.076
Metabolic parameters
MASLD4670 (41.75)2229 (39.34)0.003 2007 (40.02)2033 (40.54)0.597
Diabetes1383 (12.36)474 (8.37)< 0.001503 (10.03)463 (9.23)0.176
Hypertension2072 (18.52)724 (12.78)< 0.001731 (14.58)711 (14.18)0.569
Hyperlipidemia1431 (12.79)548 (9.67)< 0.001499 (9.95)539 (10.75)0.190
Glucose, mg/dL98 (21.71)95 (19.00)< 0.00197 (21.48)96 (19.25)0.166
HbA1c, %5.93 ± 0.845.80 ± 0.75< 0.0015.86 ± 0.845.83 ± 0.770.106
TG, mg/dL120.91 ± 99.13115.42 ± 77.93< 0.001118.04 ± 116.37117.85 ± 78.990.924
CHO, mg/dL199.78 ± 36.71197.94 ± 36.280.002 198.72 ± 36.05199.22 ± 36.070.482
HDL, mg/dL55.26 ± 13.6255.89 ± 13.740.005 55.80 ± 13.5755.96 ± 13.740.568
LDL, mg/dL122.75 ± 32.30121.78 ± 32.150.065 122.19 ± 31.92122.44 ± 31.910.695
Liver parameters
AST, U/L25.11 ± 11.2824.35 ± 12.12< 0.00124.31 ± 12.7124.56 ± 12.290.325
ALT, U/L23.05 ± 20.8223.10 ± 22.660.885 22.48 ± 24.7623.24 ± 23.110.113
GGT, U/L22.74 ± 25.6222.21 ± 20.170.138 21.79 ± 25.4722.47 ± 20.530.143
Fatty liver index25.73 ± 23.0324.85 ± 24.050.023 24.48 ± 23.6325.25 ± 23.870.103
FIB-41.46 ± 0.741.23 ± 0.61< 0.0011.30 ± 0.611.30 ± 0.620.550
FIB-4 > 21739 (15.55)578(10.20)< 0.0001558 (11.13)576 (11.49)0.5703
Other parameters
Carotid plaque 3684 (32.93)1266 (22.34)< 0.0011253 (24.99)1250 (24.93)0.945
Table 2 Clinical characteristics between hepatitis B virus carrier and healthy controls before and after propensity score matching for age and sex
CharacteristicBefore PSM
After PSM
HBV carrier,
n = 2128
Healthy controls,
n = 5666
P value
HBV carrier,
n = 2128
Healthy controls, n = 2128
P value
Age, year53.85 ± 9.6851.29 ± 11.25< 0.00153.85 ± 9.6853.88 ± 9.710.926
Male775 (36.42)1553 (27.41)< 0.001775 (36.42)772 (36.28)0.924
BMI, kg/m224.16 ± 3.6524.13 ± 3.880.778 24.16 ± 3.6524.32 ± 3.800.151
Body fat %28.66 ± 7.6729.52 ± 7.44< 0.00128.66 ± 7.6728.76 ± 7.620.670
WC, cm83.27 ± 10.2982.82 ± 10.320.08683.27 ± 10.2983.83 ± 10.140.072
Metabolic parameters
MASLD755 (35.48)2229 (39.34)0.002 755 (35.48)925 (43.47)< 0.001
Diabetes204 (9.59)474 (8.37)0.088 204 (9.59)206 (9.68)0.917
Hypertension293 (13.77)724 (12.78)0.247 293 (13.77)330 (15.51)0.109
Hyperlipidemia182 (8.55)548 (9.67)0.131 182 (8.55)244 (11.47)0.002
Glucose, mg/dL96 (21.23)95 (19.00)0.036 96 (21.23)97 (21.66)0.325
HbA1c, %5.83 ± 0.835.80 ± 0.750.110 5.83 ± 0.835.86 ± 0.840.205
TG, mg/dL107.73 ± 73.91115.42 ± 77.93< 0.001107.73 ± 73.91121.34 ± 80.35< 0.001
CHO, mg/dL194.28 ± 35.76197.94 ± 36.28< 0.001194.28 ± 35.76198.76 ± 35.46< 0.001
HDL, mg/dL55.23 ± 13.6255.89 ± 13.740.059 55.23 ± 13.6254.74 ± 13.700.242
LDL, mg/dL118.93 ± 31.26121.78 ± 32.15< 0.001118.93 ± 31.26122.86 ± 31.63< 0.001
Liver parameters
AST, U/L27.97 ± 15.5724.35 ± 12.12< 0.00127.97 ± 15.5724.71 ± 10.15< 0.001
ALT, U/L28.57 ± 29.6823.10 ± 22.66< 0.00128.57 ± 29.6823.63 ± 17.79< 0.001
GGT, U/L20.03 ± 19.4722.21 ± 20.17< 0.00120.03 ± 19.4723.47 ± 22.09< 0.001
Fatty liver index23.12 ± 21.7624.85 ± 24.050.004 23.12 ± 21.7626.89 ± 24.28< 0.001
FIB-41.49 ± 0.751.23 ± 0.61< 0.0011.49 ± 0.751.31 ± 0.59< 0.001
FIB-4 > 2407 (19.13)578 (10.20)< 0.0001407 (19.13)260 (12.22)< 0.0001
Other parameter
Carotid plaque533 (25.05)1266 (22.34)0.012533 (25.05)566 (26.60)0.248
Table 3 Clinical characteristics between “dual etiology” group and “metabolic associated steatotic liver disease alone” group before and after propensity score matching for age and sex
CharacteristicBefore PSM
After PSM
Dual etiology,
n = 755
MASLD alone,
n = 6899
P value
Dual etiology,
n = 755
MASLD alone,
n = 755
P value
Age, year53.83 ± 9.6256.09 ± 10.08< 0.00153.83 ± 9.6253.83 ± 9.62> 0.999
Male324 (42.91)2536 (36.76)0.001 324 (42.91)324 (42.91)> 0.999
BMI, kg/m226.25 ± 3.6926.13 ± 3.660.387 26.25 ± 3.6926.25 ± 3.690.988
Body fat %31.32 ± 7.6631.87 ± 7.520.058 31.32 ± 7.6631.20 ± 7.880.757
WC, cm88.76 ± 10.4188.44 ± 9.370.369 88.76 ± 10.4189.01 ± 9.620.628
Metabolic parameters
Diabetes135 (17.88)1275 (18.48)0.686 135 (17.88)144 (19.07)0.551
Hypertension153 (20.26)1,591 (23.06)0.082 153 (20.26)154 (20.40)0.949
Hyperlipidemia93 (12.32)1091 (15.81)0.012 93 (12.32)103 (13.64)0.444
Glucose, mg/dL102 (26.32)102 (25.71)0.961 102 (26.32)104 (31.15)0.197
HbA1c, %6.11 ± 1.066.12 ± 0.980.716 6.11 ± 1.066.17 ± 1.200.261
TG, mg/dL139.82 ± 96.00154.43 ± 120.06< 0.001 139.82 ± 96.00165.52 ± 230.030.005
CHO, mg/dL196.49 ± 38.11200.82 ± 37.260.003196.49 ± 38.11203.09 ± 36.600.001
HDL, mg/dL49.71 ± 11.5549.75 ± 11.440.931 49.71 ± 11.5548.94 ± 11.410.191
LDL, mg/dL123.25 ± 33.16125.89 ± 33.290.038 123.25 ± 33.16128.21 ± 33.230.004
Liver parameters
AST, U/L28.70 ± 13.2726.72 ± 14.20< 0.001 28.70 ± 13.2726.03 ± 9.82< 0.001
ALT, U/L33.40 ± 26.1629.62 ± 26.51< 0.00133.40 ± 26.1629.10 ± 18.42< 0.001
GGT, U/L24.21 ± 16.7427.96 ± 28.63< 0.00124.21 ± 16.7428.91 ± 24.95< 0.001
Fatty liver index37.72 ± 23.6639.99 ± 24.690.01637.72 ± 23.6641.90 ± 25.450.001
FIB-41.35 ± 0.641.30 ± 0.660.064 1.35 ± 0.641.22 ± 0.57< 0.001
FIB-4 > 2100 (13.25)699 (10.13)0.0079100 (13.25)59 (7.81)0.0006
Other parameters
Carotid plaque198 (26.23)2307 (33.44)< 0.001198 (26.23)208 (27.55)0.562
Table 4 Clinical characteristics between “dual etiology” group and “hepatitis B virus alone” group before and after propensity score matching for age and sex
CharacteristicBefore PSM
After PSM
Dual etiology,
n = 755
HBV alone, n = 1373
P value
Dual etiology,
n = 755
HBV alone, n = 755
P value
Age, year53.83 ± 9.6253.87 ± 9.720.932 53.83 ± 9.6253.80 ± 9.580.957
Male324 (42.91)451 (32.85)< 0.001324 (42.91)324 (42.91)> 0.999
BMI, kg/m226.25 ± 3.6923.00 ± 3.07< 0.00126.25 ± 3.6923.05 ± 3.09< 0.001
Body fat %31.32 ± 7.6627.20 ± 7.27< 0.00131.32 ± 7.6626.04 ± 7.60< 0.001
WC, cm88.76 ± 10.4180.24 ± 8.88< 0.00188.76 ± 10.4180.45 ± 8.87< 0.001
Metabolic parameters
Diabetes135 (17.88)69 (5.03)< 0.001135 (17.88)41 (5.43)< 0.001
Hypertension153 (20.26)140 (10.20)< 0.001153 (20.26)81 (10.73)< 0.001
Hyperlipidemia93 (12.32)89 (6.48)< 0.00193 (12.32)58 (7.68)0.003
Glucose, mg/dL102 (26.32)93 (16.97)< 0.001102 (26.32)94 (20.10)< 0.001
HbA1c, %6.11 ± 1.065.68 ± 0.62< 0.0016.11 ± 1.065.69 ± 0.70< 0.001
TG, mg/dL139.82 ± 96.0090.08 ± 50.25< 0.001139.82 ± 96.0091.52 ± 51.42< 0.001
CHO, mg/dL196.49 ± 38.11193.06 ± 34.350.040 196.49 ± 38.11193.44 ± 34.530.104
HDL, mg/dL49.71 ± 11.5558.27 ± 13.73< 0.00149.71 ± 11.5557.96 ± 13.89< 0.001
LDL, mg/dL123.25 ± 33.16116.55 ± 29.91< 0.001123.25 ± 33.16117.00 ± 30.02< 0.001
Liver parameters
AST, U/L28.70 ± 13.2727.56 ± 16.690.084 28.70 ± 13.2728.10 ± 15.930.426
ALT, U/L33.40 ± 26.1625.91 ± 31.13< 0.00133.40 ± 26.1627.29 ± 34.92< 0.001
GGT, U/L24.21 ± 16.7417.73 ± 20.46< 0.00124.21 ± 16.7418.88 ± 23.99< 0.001
Fatty liver index37.72 ± 23.6615.09 ± 15.64< 0.00137.72 ± 23.6615.85 ± 16.07< 0.001
FIB-41.35 ± 0.641.57 ± 0.80< 0.0011.35 ± 0.641.61 ± 0.78< 0.001
FIB-4 > 2100 (13.25)307 (22.36)< 0.0001100 (13.25)185 (24.50)< 0.001
Other parameters
Carotid plaque198 (26.23)335 (24.40)0.352 198 (26.23)194 (25.70)0.814
Table 5 Factors associated with advanced liver fibrosis (Fibrosis-4 index > 2.67) in metabolic associated steatotic liver disease patients using binary logistic regression for 7654 study participants
Factor
Univariate
Multivariate
OR
95%CI
P value
AOR
95%CI
P value
Age, year1.147(1.123-1.172)< 0.0011.151(1.126-1.177)< 0.001
Male0.986(0.749-1.299)0.922
BMI, kg/m20.975(0.939-1.013)0.189
Body fat, %0.989(0.971-1.007)0.217
WC, cm1.006(0.992-1.020)0.406
Diabetes mellitus1.767(1.313-2.379)< 0.0010.919(0.593-1.424)0.706
Hypertension1.563(1.172-2.084)0.0020.734(0.536-1.005)0.054
Dyslipidemia1.511(1.091-2.092)0.0131.009(0.715-1.422)0.961
Glucose, mg/dL1.006(1.002-1.009)0.0040.999(0.991-1.007)0.791
HbA1c, %1.191(1.077-1.316)0.0011.149(0.903-1.462)0.259
Triglyceride, mg/dL1.000(0.999-1.001)0.869
Cholesterol, mg/dL0.993(0.989-0.997)< 0.0011.000(0.992-1.008)0.998
HDL, mg/dL1.007(0.996-1.018)0.219
LDL, mg/dL0.990(0.985-0.994)< 0.0010.993(0.984-1.001)0.089
AST, U/L1.050(1.043-1.056)< 0.001
ALT, U/L1.013(1.009-1.017)< 0.001
GGT, U/L1.004(1.001-1.006)0.0061.004(1.001-1.007)0.011
FLI1.001(0.996-1.007)0.615
HBV1.546(1.055-2.265)0.0252.154(1.446-3.209)< 0.001