Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Gastroenterol. Sep 7, 2020; 26(33): 5008-5021
Published online Sep 7, 2020. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v26.i33.5008
Table 1 Patient and tumor characteristics in the training and validation sets
CharacteristicTraining (n = 103)Validation (n = 45)P value
Age (yr)60 ± 1259 ± 110.513
Gender0.156
Male5719
Female4626
Tumor size (long axis, mm)49.4 ± 11.654.1 ± 14.60.040
Pathological T-stage0.218
T1112
T23413
T35529
T431
Pathological N-stage0.018
N07524
N11812
N2109
M-stage00
Overall Stage (pTNM)0.081
I3914
II3610
III2821
Pathological grade0.222
Well30
Moderate7832
Poor2213
CRM0.788
Negativity9139
Positivity126
Ki-67 (%)52 ± 2047 ± 210.261
Distant metastasis (+/-)36/6715/300.849
Distant metastasis10.394
Lung1613
Liver198
Other (bone, brain, etc.)66
Follow-up time (months)
DFS29 ± 1230 ± 120.638
OS34 ± 534 ± 50.691
Table 2 Comparison of the models between the metastasis group and the non-metastasis group, and between the death group and the survival group
MetastasisNon-metastasisP valueDeathSurvivalP value
3-yr1
n (%)51 (34.5)97 (65.5)26 (17.6)122 (82.4)
Rad-score0.46 ± 0.210.32 ± 0.24< 0.0010.45 ± 0.200.35 ± 0.240.023
Clinical0.52 ± 0.200.30 ± 0.21< 0.0010.55 ± 0.200.34 ± 0.22< 0.001
Combined0.60 ± 0.230.28 ± 0.26< 0.0010.62 ± 0.220.34 ± 0.28< 0.001
2-yr1
n (%)41 (27.7)107 (72.3)15 (10.1)133 (89.9)
Rad-score0.44 ± 0.200.34 ± 0.250.0090.40 ± 0.170.35 ± 0.250.368
Clinical0.51 ± 0.190.32 ± 0.23< 0.0010.63 ± 0.150.35 ± 0.22< 0.001
Combined0.56 ± 0.230.31 ± 0.28< 0.0010.65 ± 0.190.36 ± 0.29< 0.001
1-yr1
n (%)25 (16.9)123 (83.1)2 (1.4)146 (98.6)
Rad-score0.39 ± 0.190.36 ± 0.250.4530.29 ± 0.360.37 ± 0.240.676
Clinical0.55 ± 0.190.34 ± 0.22< 0.0010.75 ± 0.240.37 ± 0.230.258
Combined0.56 ± 0.230.35 ± 0.290.0010.60 ± 0.520.38 ± 0.290.302
Table 3 Diagnostic performance of the three models in both training and validation cohorts
Training setValidation set
1TimeRad-scoreClinicalCombinedRad-scoreClinicalCombined
3-yrAUC0.7090.7820.8420.6870.7660.802
SEN88.89%88.33%91.67%80%100%86.67%
SPE42.67%58.21%70.15%56.67%50%80%
2-yrAUC0.7000.7600.8160.6090.7200.691
1-yrAUC0.6140.7710.7690.5450.7420.632