Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2017.
World J Gastroenterol. Apr 21, 2017; 23(15): 2731-2742
Published online Apr 21, 2017. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v23.i15.2731
Table 1 Characteristic of interval cancers and screen-detected colorectal cancers n (%)
Interval cancers
Screen-detected (SCs)P value
FITPost-colonoscopy
Total186 (6.8)18 (0.7)2518 (92.5)-
Patient characteristics
Sex
Male125 (67.2)10 (55.6)1651 (65.6)0.601
Female61 (32.8)8 (44.4)867 (34.4)
Age (yr)
Mean (SC)60.2 (4.9)62.0 (3.5)61.7 (3.4)0.042
50-5428 (15.1)0 (0)375 (14.9)
55-5953 (28.5)5 (27.8)539 (21.4)0.001
60-6461 (32.8)10 (55.6)709 (28.2)
65-6944 (23.7)3 (16.7)895 (35.5)
Round of invitation0.001
1143 (76.9)16 (88.9)1615 (64.1)
240 (21.5)2 (11.1)680 (27.0)
33 (1.6)0 (0)223 (8.9)
Type participation0.086
Initial149 (80.1)17 (94.4)1863 (74.0)
Regular35 (18.8)1 (5.6)639 (25.4)
Irregular2 (1.1)0 (0)16 (0.6)
Deprivation Index0.192
1 (least deprived)42 (23.9)3 (16.7)521 (21.4)
243 (24.4)1 (5.5)503 (20.6)
329 (16.5)6 (33.4)539 (22.1)
438 (21.6)2 (11.1)461 (18.9)
5 (most deprived)24 (13.6)5 (27.8)414 (17.0)
Unknown0 (0)1 (5.5)0 (0)
Time to diagnosis (months)-< 0.0001
Median (IQR)13.5 (8.5-18.9)28.1 (16.5-40.1)
Range1.5-39.45.6-61.2
Cancer characteristics
Location< 0.0001
Proximal168 (36.6)7 (38.9)478 (19.0)
Distal258 (31.2)9 (50.0)1529 (60.7)
Rectum58 (31.2)2 (11.1)404 (16.0)
Unknown2 (1.1)0 (0)107 (4.2)
Stage< 0.0001
I43 (23.1)4 (22.2)1376 (54.6)
II36 (19.4)2 (11.1)408 (16.2)
III57 (30.6)7 (38.9)566 (22.5)
IV50 (26.9)5 (27.8)152 (6.0)
Unknown0 (0)0 (0)16 (0.6)
Morphology0.002
ADC, NOS139 (74.7)15 (83.3)1823 (72.4)
ADC in adenomatous polyp4 (2.2)0 (0)121 (4.8)
Carcinoid tumor0 (0)0 (0)7 (0.3)
ADC in villous adenoma6 (3.2)0 (0)154 (6.1)
ADC in tubulovillous adenoma10 (5.4)0 (0)174 (6.9)
Mucinous ADC5 (2.7)2 (11.1)42 (1.7)
Mucin-producing ADC3 (1.6)0 (0)23 (0.9)
Signet ring cell carcinoma0 (0)0 (0)4 (0.2)
Other15 (8.1)0 (0)64 (2.5)
Unknown4 (2.2)1 (5.6)106 (4.2)
Degree of differentiation< 0.0001
Well differentiated76 (41.1)7 (38.9)988 (39.2)
Moderately differentiated59 (31.9)7 (38.9)1061 (42.2)
Poorly differentiated14 (7.6)1 (5.5)86 (3.4)
Undifferentiated/anaplastic33 (17.8)2 (11.1)320 (12.7)
Unknown3 (1.6)1 (5.5)63 (2.5)
Size (mm)0.022
Median (IQR)20 (8.0-40.0)38.0 (30.0-60.0)26.0 (19.7-40.0)
Range2.0-90.09.0-80.02.0-95.0
Treatment< 0.0001
Endoscopic resection5 (2.7)0 (0)733 (29.1)
Surgery56 (30.1)9 (50.0)182 (7.2)
Surgery and neoadjuvant therapy106 (57.0)7 (38.9)1332 (52.9)
Palliative procedure18 (9.7)2 (11.1)164 (6.6)
Unknown1 (0.5)0 (0)107 (4.2)
Table 2 f-Hb values of previous negative screening test in interval cancer cases
Median f-Hb (μg Hb/g faeces)IQRP value
All2.80.4-9.9-
Sex
Male3.40.2-10.00.409
Female1.90.4-9.8
Age (yr)0.380
50-541.90.2-6.9
55-593.00.6-13.0
60-642.80.2-8.6
65-694.00.4-12.5
Deprivation Index0.887
1 (least deprived)3.00.6-11.9
22.60.0-10.2
34.21.1-12.4
44.00.4-11.2
5 (most deprived)2.60.0-8.7
Time to diagnosis (mo)0.795
Within 1 yr3.40.2-10.6
1-2 yr2.50.5-9.6
Location0.171
Proximal11.90.0-9.3
Distal23.80.3-13.7
Rectum3.90.7-9.1
Unknown1.00.0-…
Stage0.927
I2.00.0-9.7
II2.60.2-10.6
III3.20.7-9.8
IV4.00.2-9.9
Unknown
Morphology0.550
ADC, NOS3.00.6-10.0
ADC in adenomatous polyp10.02.0-17.2
ADC in villous adenoma0.50.0-9.8
ADC in tubulovillous adenoma2.40.0-9.3
Mucinous ADC0.40.0-12.5
Mucin-producing ADC14.00.0-…
Other1.70.0-6.0
Unknown1.00.0-6.9
Degree of differentiation0.600
Well differentiated2.81.0-9.0
Moderately differentiated4.40.6-13.0
Poorly differentiated0.60.0-5.6
Undifferentiated/anaplastic4.00.0-9.4
Unknown2.00.0-…
Size (mm)
< 101.40.4-12.40.586
10-19.991.00.0-7.9
≥ 202.9
Table 3 Characteristics of post colonoscopy colorectal cancers at the time of diagnosis
n (%)
Interval CRC tumor site
Appendix and caecum5 (27.8)
Ascending0 (0)
Hepatic flexure1 (5.6)
Transverse1 (5.6)
Splenic flexure0 (0)
Descending2 (11.1)
Sigmoid7 (38.8)
Rectum2 (11.1)
Unknown0 (0)
Polyp found on the Screening colonoscopy
Yes10 (61.1)
No8 (38.9)
Polyp frequency
Median (IQR)2.0 (1.0-3.5)
Range1-6
Previous resection in the same location
Yes2 (11.0)
No16 (89.0)
Report of incomplete Screening colonoscopy
Yes23 (16.7)
No15 (83.3)
Polyp size on the Screening colonoscopy
≥ 10 mm
Yes2 (11.1)
No16 (88.9)
Polyp histology (n = 10)
Hyperplastic polyp0 (0)
LRA6 (60.0)
AA4 (40.0)
Bowel preparation
Inadequate2 (11.1)
Adequate112 (66.7)
Unknown4 (22.2)
Diverticulosis
Yes5 (27.8)
No13 (72.2)
Table 4 Multivariate analysis of patients and tumors predictors of interval cancers compared with screen-detected cancers
% with CIOR (95%CI)P value
Sex
Female69 (33.8)1 (ref.)
Male135 (66.2)1.03 (0.76-1.39)0.860
Age (yr)
50-5428 (13.7)1 (ref.)
55-5958 (28.4)1.44 (0.90-2.31)0.127
60-6471 (34.8)1.34 (0.84-2.11)0.206
65-6947 (23.0)0.70 (0.43-1.14)0.153
Deprivation
1 (least deprived)45 (23.3)1 (ref.)
244 (22.8)1.01 (0.66-1.56)0.954
335 (18.1)0.75 (0.48-1.19)0.222
440 (20.7)1.00 (0.64-1.57)0.984
5 (most deprived)29 (15.0)0.81 (0.50-1.32)0.396
Location
Proximal174 (36.8)1 (ref.)
Distal267 (33.3)0.28 (0.20-0.40)< 0.0001
Rectum60 (29.9)0.96 (0.67-1.38)0.824
Stage
I47 (23.0)1 (ref.)
II38 (18.6)2.73 (1.75-4.24)< 0.0001
III64 (31.4)3.31 (2.24-4.88)< 0.0001
IV55 (27.0)10.59 (6.93-16.18)< 0.0001
Table 5 Hazard ratios and 95%CI for interval cancer vs screen-detected cancers
Hazard ratio95% CIP value
Sex
Female (ref)
Male1.391.01-1.930.049
Age (yr)
50-54 (ref)0.451
55-591.370.79-2.360.258
60-641.220.72-2.070.463
65-691.470.89-2.440.137
Deprivation Index
1 (least deprived) (ref)0.839
20.890.54-1.460.639
31.010.63-1.620.956
40.900.54-1.510.696
5 (most deprived)1.160.72-1.880.537
Location
Rectum (ref)< 0.001
Proximal11.170.78-1.770.456
Distal20.560.39-0.820.003
Stage
I (ref)< 0.001
II1.991.11-3.540.020
III3.672.31-5.83< 0.001
IV26.5417.37-40.56< 0.001
CRC type
Screen detected CRC (ref)< 0.0001
IC FIT3.312.25-4.85< 0.0001
IC colonoscopy3.491.11-10.970.032