Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastroenterol. May 28, 2015; 21(20): 6317-6328
Published online May 28, 2015. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v21.i20.6317
Table 1 CTNNB1 mutation case resources in each article
PubMed IDTotal casesHBV infection casesHCV infection casesHBV and HCV coinfection casesNon-viral infection cases
963557214/75NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
96717678/31NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1048782714/322/52/130/010/13
1059590713/220/013/220/00/0
106656469/38NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1070017613/100NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1098011657/42127/26523/953/444/17
112824856/32NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1137595726/1373/3312/310/911/41
114297830/220/00/00/00/22
114436197/605/480/20/02/10
114775491/140/11/120/00/1
1157058015/34NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1210142614/73NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1237501910/570/010/570/00/0
12439747184/1123NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1284567024/1005/2616/510/03/23
149996983/610/290/70/10/0
1506732810/89NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
151516241/61NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
152884792/160/00/40/02/6
1530537444/781NA/512NA/151NA/52NA/66
1581463537/265NA/161NA/53NA/26NA/25
1718743234/120NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
173931107/29NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1751038413/812/138/441/22/18
175315584/420/74/230/30/9
181713491/360/210/40/01/11
1828227711/52NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
183585014/543/430/10/21/8
1846715947/223NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1870150328/810/028/810/00/0
1910198210/320/03/60/07/26
203475021/10/01/10/00/0
209235737/151/44/100/02/2
209635152/202/200/00/00/0
2145715919/443/1110/231/25/8
2182226428/1395/5013/431/29/44
2256151742/1493/327/241/431/89
2502142153/17613/78NA/NANA/NANA/NA
Table 2 AXIN1 mutation case resources in each article
PubMed IDTotal casesHBV infection casesHCV infection casesHBV and HCV coinfection casesNon-viral infection cases
107001769/100NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
1137595712/1128/320/312/92/40
121014264/560/90/50/24/40
1506732825/89NA/NANA/NANA/NANA/NA
181713499/365/213/40/01/11
214992491/10/01/10/00/0
2256151719/1495/325/241/48/89
2502142125/17613/78NA/NANA/NANA/NA
Table 3 TP53 mutation case resources in each article
PubMed IDTotal casesHBV infection casesHCV infection casesHBV and HCV coinfection casesNon-viral infection cases
13116380/21/360/21/360/0/00/0/00/0/0
13275233/20/613/12/370/4/170/3/40/1/3
16552542/9/43NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
16727320/5/100/5/80/0/NA0/0/NA0/0/NA
18492340/8/16NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
79032052/20/352/15/280/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
80933501/17/530/3/7NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
80939780/3/200/NA/170/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
81004801/3/20NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
81081452/6/152/6/150/0/00/0/00/0/0
82614445/12/161/2/34/8/100/1/20/1/1
82906060/19/800/8/280/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
83025801/6/22NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
83800580/2/150/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
83821110/12/380/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
83840810/4/450/4/280/0/110/0/20/0/4
83892460/11/340/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
83902890/10/150/8/130/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
83904070/1/180/0/30/0/50/0/10/1/9
83931661/1/7NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
84075533/19/632/10/161/4/150/0/00/5/32
85651240/2/120/0/30/0/20/0/10/2/6
86557043/10/38NA/NA/19NA/NA/10NA/NA/5NA/NA/4
86559582/2/201/1/4NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
86729940/1/180/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
88954900/9/120/0/00/1/30/2/30/3/6
90124690/8/160/1/80/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
92700152/26/1052/24/780/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
94635840/2/80/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
96995372/6/97NA/NA/16NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
97819421/2/150/0/01/2/150/0/00/0/0
103897500/17/310/11/170/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
103899780/12/240/10/190/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
105649522/9/11NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
106625910/5/27NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
106998914/11/180/0/00/0/00/0/04/11/18
107430470/35/400/33/380/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
110512492/21/830/14/501/6/160/0/01/1/17
111913530/14/550/NA/450/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
112824862/6/22NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
113759571/36/1371/15/330/10/310/3/90/8/41
117048358/30/71NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
124830053/7/342/5/270/1/30/0/01/1/4
126406820/2/180/1/50/1/80/0/40/0/1
127592402/16/332/16/330/0/00/0/00/0/0
128456700/14/1000/4/260/7/510/0/00/3/23
144996900/18/680/NA/520/NA/20/0/00/NA/14
146757780/5/220/0/00/5/220/0/00/0/0
146877973/9/802/7/NA0/1/NA0/0/NA1/1/NA
150175924/22/50NA/NA/13NA/NA/33NA/NA/3NA/NA/1
151263383/27/48NA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
159430418/8/208/8/200/0/00/0/00/0/0
160786402/7/41NA/NA/1NA/NA/26NA/NA/NANA/NA/NA
165702751/11/401/4/220/2/50/2/50/3/8
166853870/28/550/NA/490/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
166975350/7/230/7/230/0/00/0/00/0/0
170664400/5/510/0/140/4/300/0/00/1/7
172661821/28/501/24/410/NA/NA0/NA/NA0/NA/NA
173508224/16/83NA/2/13NA/13/64NA/0/2NA/1/4
175103840/25/810/5/130/15/440/2/20/3/18
175315582/7/421/1/71/4/240/1/20/1/9
214992490/1/10/0/00/1/10/0/00/0/0
217609960/9/260/6/130/2/40/0/00/0/4
218222644/39/1392/20/501/10/430/2/21/7/44
225615170/26/1490/9/320/7/240/2/40/8/89
226347563/14/273/7/110/7/140/0/00/0/2
229228711/1/101/1/100/0/00/0/00/0/0
Table 4 Mutation case numbers and rates of CTNNB1 in different tissues
Cancer typeMutation cases (n)Total cases (n)Mutation rate (%)P value1
HCC671372018.04
Colon Adenocarcinoma12613189.56< 0.001
Ovary carcinoma10215996.38< 0.001
Stomach Adenocarcinoma5411374.75< 0.001
Lung Adenocarcinoma3812193.12< 0.001
ESCC53471.44< 0.001
Table 5 Mutation case numbers and rates of CTNNB1 in hepatocellular carcinoma etiologies
Viral backgroundMutation cases (n)Total cases (n)Mutation rate (%)P value1
HBV7468610.79
HCV15555427.98< 0.001
HBV and HCV76910.140.999
Non-viral9034825.86< 0.001
Table 6 Mutation case numbers and rates of AXIN1 in different tissues
Cancer typeMutation cases (n)Total cases (n)Mutation rate (%)
Hepatocellular carcinoma758728.60
Colon adenocarcinoma205133.90
Ovary carcinoma37490.40
Stomach adenocarcinoma183774.77
Lung adenocarcinoma66970.86
Esophageal squamous cell carcinoma31302.31
Table 7 Mutation case numbers and rates of AXIN1 in hepatocellular carcinoma etiologies
Viral backgroundMutation cases (n)Total cases (n)Mutation rate (%)P value1
HBV3117218.02
HCV96513.850.964
HBV and HCV31520.000.999
non-viral151808.330.122
Table 8 Mutation case numbers and rates of TP53 in different tissues
Cancer typeGOF mutation cases (n)Mutation cases (n)Total cases (n)GOF mutation rate (%)Non-GOF mutation rate (%)Total mutation rate (%)P value1
HCC9182528133.2326.0929.33
Colon adenocarcinoma331186735969.2042.7151.92< 0.001
Ovary carcinoma3921604332911.7836.4148.18< 0.001
Stomach adenocarcinoma270116034597.8125.7333.54< 0.001
Lung adenocarcinoma421241463946.5831.1737.75< 0.001
ESCC224972185812.0640.2652.31< 0.001
Table 9 Mutation case numbers and rates of TP53 in hepatocellular carcinoma etiologies
Viral backgroundGOF mutation cases (n)Mutation cases (n)Total cases (n)GOF mutation rate (%)Non-GOF mutation rate (%)Total mutation rate (%)
HBV353218194.2734.9239.19
HCV91013982.2623.1225.38
HBV and HCV018410.0043.9043.90
non-viral7603462.0215.3217.34