Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Gastroenterol. Dec 28, 2014; 20(48): 18466-18476
Published online Dec 28, 2014. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i48.18466
Table 1 Characteristics of included studies on screening flexible sigmoidoscopy and colorectal cancer incidence and mortality
Ref.LocationStudy period (median follow-up time)Age range (yr)No. of patients per groupStudy designTotal number of CRC casesIncidence rate1(95%CI)Number of deaths due to CRCCRC Mortality rate1Study quality
Atkin et al[18], 2010United Kingdom11.2 yr55-64(C): 113195FS(C): 1818(C): 149 (143 -156)(C): 538(C): 52 (48-56)7
(S): 57237Colonoscopy on detection of high risk polyps(S): 706(S): 114 (106-123)(S): 189(S): 36 (31-41)
Hoff et al[20], 2009Norway7 yr55-64(C): 41913FS/FS + FIT(C): 362(C): 134(C): 997
Colonoscopy on detection of high risk polyps(262 advanced CRC)
(S): 13823(S): 123(S): 132(S): 24
(78 advanced CRC)
Schoen et al[17], 2012United States11.9 yr55-74(C): 77455FS(C): 1287(C): 152 (144-160)(C): 341(C): 39 (35-43)8
Follow-up FS at 3-5 yr(537 advanced CRC)
(S): 77445Colonoscopy on detection of any polyp(S): 1012(S): 119 (112-127)(S): 252(S): 29 (25-32)
(381 advanced CRC)
Segnan et al[19], 2011Italy10.5 yr55-64(C): 17144FS(C): 306(C): 176 (158-197)(C): 83(C): 44 (36-65)7
Colonoscopy for high risk Polyps(152 advanced CRC)
(S): 17148(S): 251(S): 144 (127-163)(S): 65(S): 35 (37 -55)
(112 advanced CRC)