Evidence-Based Medicine
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Gastroenterol. Dec 14, 2014; 20(46): 17448-17455
Published online Dec 14, 2014. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i46.17448
Table 1 Preoperative clinical parameters
VariablesGroup 1Group 2P value
(n = 46)(n = 32)
Age (yr)67 (37-82)63 (35-86)0.452
Male:female, n25:2120:120.473
Presence of comorbid illness25 (54.3)16 (50.0)0.705
Cardiovascular disease15 (32.6)9 (28.1)0.673
Pulmonary disease5 (10.9)1 (3.1)0.406
Renal disease2 (4.3)1 (3.1)1.000
Diabetes Mellitus9 (19.6)11 (34.4)0.141
Hemoglobin (g/dL)12.5 (9.0-15.6)12.7 (9.5-15.6)0.614
White blood cell count (× 109/L)6.9 (3.6-21.2)6.7 (3.9-13.1)0.763
Prothrombin time (s)11.4 (9.8-40.8)11.3 (9.0-14.4)0.421
International normalized ratio1.0 (0.8-3.6)1.0 (0.8-1.2)0.938
Serum creatinine (mmol/L)75 (52-212)84 (47-143)0.607
Serum bilirubin ( mmol/L)102 (5-533)38 (5-342)0.020
Albumin (g/L)39 (27-46)40.5 (8-47)0.041
Table 2 Operation details n (%)
VariablesGroup 1Group 2P value
(n = 46)(n = 32)
Portal vein resection-18 (56.3)-
Reconstruction method--
Primary anastomosis14 (77.8)
Cadaveric vein graft3 (16.7)
Gortex graft1 (5.6)
Superior mesenteric vein resection-22 (68.8)-
Reconstruction method--
Primary anastomosis18 (81.8)
Cadaveric vein graft3 (13.6)
Gortex graft1 (4.5)
Superior mesenteric artery resection-3 (9.4)-
Reconstruction method--
Primary anastomosis3 (100)
Pancreaticojejunostomy construction method0.358
Dunking1 (2.2)3 (9.4)
Duct to mucosa43 (93.5)28 (87.5)
Double loop2 (4.3)1 (3.1)
Size of pancreatic duct0.239
< 2 mm1 (2.4)3 (13.0)
2-4 mm15 (36.6)8 (34.8)
< 4 mm25 (61.0)12 (52.2)
Pancreatic stent0.882
No32 (69.6)21 (65.6)
Internal3 (6.5)3 (9.4)
External11 (23.9)8 (25.0)
Table 3 Short-term outcomes
VariablesGroup 1Group 2P value
(n= 46)(n = 32)
Blood loss (mL)800 (250-1600)1200 (100-5000)0.007
Operation time (min)580 (378-855)715 (487-992)< 0.0001
Hospital stay (d)17 (9-120)17 (11-89)0.316
Intensive care unit stay (d)2 (1-10)2 (0-24)0.847
Hospital death2 (4.3)1 (3.1)1.000
Patients with complication20 (43.5)10 (31.3)0.275
Chest infection3 (6.5)2 (6.3)1.000
Pleural effusion1 (2.2)1 (3.1)1.000
Wound infection7 (15.2)1 (3.1)0.176
Subphrenic abscess or collection5 (10.9)1 (3.1)0.406
Intra-abdominal bleeding1 (2.2)0 (0.0)1.000
Gastrointestinal bleeding1 (2.2)1 (3.1)1.000
Cardiac arrhythmia4 (8.7)2 (6.3)1.000
Acute coronary syndrome2 (4.3)1 (3.1)1.000
Deep vein thrombosis2 (4.3)0 (0.0)0.641
Delayed gastric emptying (> 7 d)3 (6.5)5 (15.6)0.355
Types of pancreatic fistula according to ISGPF0.662
All types10 (21.7)5 (15.6)
Type A6 (13.0)4 (12.5)
Type B3 (6.5)1 (3.13)
Type C1 (2.2)0 (0.0)
Table 4 Pathologic examination results
VariablesGroup 1Group 2P value
(n = 46)(n = 32)
Tumor size (cm)3 (1.0-8.0)3 (1.6-6.0)0.315
Lymph node metastases0.299
No21 (45.7)12 (37.5)
< 522 (47.8)15 (46.9)
5-102 (4.3)5 (15.6)
> 101 (2.2)0 (0.0)
Pancreaticojejunostomy construction method0.613
Dunking or other4 (12.5)3 (6.5)
Duct to mucosa28 (87.5)43 (93.5)
R0 resection35 (75.6)25 (78.1)0.793
R1 resection11 (24.4)7 (21.9)
AJCC staging (7th edition)0.981
Stage IA2 (4.3)2 (6.3)
Stage IB4 (8.7)3 (9.4)
Stage IIA14 (30.4)8 (25.0)
Stage IIB25 (54.3)18 (56.3)
Stage III1 (2.2)1 (3.1)
Stage IA/IB/IIA (no lymph node involvement)20 (43.5)13 (40.6)0.802
Stage IIB/III (advanced)26 (56.5)19 (59.4)
Table 5 Univariate analyses of factors affecting survival outcomes
FactorMedian survival (mo)P value
Median age (yr)0.634
≤ 64 (n = 40)22.35 ± 3.73
> 64 (n = 38)15.84 ± 4.40
Sex0.445
Male (n = 45)22.35 ± 6.32
Female (n = 33)19.26 ± 3.74
Comorbidity0.890
No (n = 37)20.05 ± 4.08
Yes (n = 41)21.36 ± 4.34
Preoperative cholangitis0.487
No (n = 76)19.26 ± 3.54
Yes (n = 2)21.36
Postoperative complication0.204
No (n = 48)23.79 ± 5.26
Yes (n = 30)16.76 ± 4.18
International normalized ratio0.924
≤ 1 (n = 55)21.36 ± 2.79
> 1 (n = 15)27.51 ± 14.53
Creatinine level (mmol/L)0.652
≤ 79 (n = 37)23.79 ± 4.42
> 79 (n = 36)13.90 ± 2.98
Total bilirubin level ( mmol/L)0.581
≤ 72 (n = 39)22.35 ± 3.16
> 72 (n = 38)16.66 ± 5.01
Serum albumin level (g/L)0.419
≤ 40 (n = 44)28.79 ± 8.12
> 40 (n = 29)19.09 ± 3.77
Blood loss (mL)0.284
≤ 850 (n = 36)28.79 ± 5.84
> 850 (n = 33)21.36 ± 4.89
Tumor Size (cm)0.630
≤ 3 (n = 43)16.76 ± 3.22
> 3 (n = 28)19.09 ± 7.97
R1 resection0.055
No (n = 59)25.34 ± 5.32
Yes (n = 18)13.44 ± 3.87
Lymph node metastases0.113
No (n = 33)28.79 ± 3.82
< 5 (n = 37)17.12 ± 3.05
5-10 (n = 7)11.40 ± 5.68
> 10 (n = 1)22.18
Disease stage (AJCC staging, 7th edition)0.036
Early (IA + IB + IC) (n = 33)28.79 ± 5.00
Advanced (IIB + III + IV) (n = 45)17.12 ± 3.41
Simultaneous vascular resection0.815
Yes (n = 32)21.36 ± 5.93
No (n = 46)19.26 ± 3.58
Pancreatic fistula type (according to ISGPF)0.488
No fistula + type A (n = 73)20.05 ± 3.43
Type B + type C (n = 5)13.90 ± 6.61