Greco L, Timpone L, Abkari A, Abu-Zekry M, Attard T, Bouguerrà F, Cullufi P, Kansu A, Micetic-Turk D, Mišak Z, Roma E, Shamir R, Terzic S. Burden of celiac disease in the Mediterranean area. World J Gastroenterol 2011; 17(45): 4971-4978 [PMID: 22174546 DOI: 10.3748/wjg.v17.i45.4971]
Corresponding Author of This Article
Luigi Greco, Professor of Medicine, Chief, European Laboratory for Food Induced Diseases, Federico II University of Naples, 80131 Naples, Italy. ydongre@unina.it
Article-Type of This Article
Brief Article
Open-Access Policy of This Article
This article is an open-access article which was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
World J Gastroenterol. Dec 7, 2011; 17(45): 4971-4978 Published online Dec 7, 2011. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v17.i45.4971
Table 1 Excess need of health resources before the diagnosis of celiac disease
n
Adult cost (€)
n
Child cost (€)
In-patient admission
2
9818
1
2254
Out-patient admission
1
879
1
586
Medical consultations
3
100
3
150
Specialist consultations
2
150
1
50
Lab test
4
446
2
297
Total per patient
11 393
3337
Table 2 Populations now and after 10 years
Population
Children 0-14
Median age (yr)
Population growth rate (%)
Children 0-14 in 10 yr
Total population in 10 yr
Albania
3 619 778
853 883
29.9
0.5
901 667
3 822 345
Algeria
33 769 669
8 878 665
26.6
1.2
9 999 566
38 032 972
Bosnia
4 590 310
673 770
39.8
0.3
696 962
4 748 317
Cyprus
792 604
154 445
35.5
1.7
182 623
937 214
Croatia
4 491 543
708 683
41
-0.1
705 006
4 468 242
Egypt
81 713 517
25 983 672
24.8
2
31 776 575
99 931 053
France
64 057 790
11 894 698
39.4
0.5
12 564 088
67 662 729
Greece
10 722 816
1 531 606
41.8
0.1
1 551 169
10 859 777
Israel
7 112 359
1 989 312
29.1
1.7
2 347 869
8 394 303
Italy
58 126 212
7 870 226
43.3
0
7 833 314
57 853 596
Lebanon
3 971 941
1 032 888
29.3
1.1
1 153 096
4 434 197
Libya
6 173 579
2 048 548
23.9
2.2
2 539 599
7 653 427
Malta
403 532
66 112
39.5
0.4
68 805
419 967
Morocco
34 343 219
10 473 478
25
1.1
11 683 138
8 309 775
Syria
19 747 586
7 146 569
21.7
2
8 716 754
24 086 361
Slovenia
2 007 711
273 464
41.5
0
273 655
2 009 117
Spain
40 525 002
5 864 419
41.1
0.1
5 906 780
40 817 729
Tunisia
10 383 577
2 413 484
29.2
1
2 660 713
11 447 236
Turkey
71 892 807
17 545 890
27.7
1.3
19 965 025
81 805 009
Mediter
458 445 552
107 403 812
33.2
0.9
121 526 405
507 693 365
Table 3 Prevalence of celiac disease in the next 10 years1
Estimated celiacs today
Estimated celiac children today at 1%
Projected prevalence of CD in next 10 yr
Projected celiac children in next 10 yr
Albania
36 198
8539
38 223
9017
Algeria
337 697
88 787
380 330
99 996
Bosnia
45 903
6738
47 483
6970
Cyprus
7926
1544
9372
1826
Croatia
44 915
7087
44 682
7050
Egypt
817 135
259 837
999 311
317 766
France
640 578
118 947
676 627
125 641
Greece
107 228
15 316
108 598
15 512
Israel
71 124
19 893
83 943
23 479
Italy
581 262
78 702
578 536
78 333
Lebanon
39 719
10 329
44 342
11 531
Libya
61 736
20 485
76 534
25 396
Malta
4035
661
4200
688
Morocco
343 432
104 735
383 098
116 831
Syria
197 476
71 466
240 864
87 168
Slovenia
20 077
2735
20 091
2737
Spain
405 250
58 644
408 177
59 068
Tunisia
103 836
24 135
114 472
26 607
Turkey
718 928
175 459
818 050
199 650
Mediter
4 584 456
1 074 038
5 076 934
1 215 264
Table 4 Symptoms and diseases associated with symptomatic cases
Symptomatic adults next 10 yr 1:7
Symptomatic children next 10 yr 1:5
Gastrointestinal symptoms
Anaemia
Osteopenia
Abnormal liver
Children with short stature
Albania
4172
1803
5079
2390
1793
598
361
Algeria
40 048
19 999
51 040
24 019
18 014
6005
4000
Bosnia
5788
1394
6104
2873
2154
718
279
Cyprus
1078
365
1227
577
433
144
73
Croatia
5376
1410
5768
2714
2036
679
282
Egypt
97 364
63 553
136 779
64 367
48 275
16 092
12 711
France
78 712
25 128
88 264
41 536
31 152
10 384
5026
Greece
13 298
3102
13 940
6560
4920
1640
620
Israel
8638
4696
11 333
5333
4000
1333
939
Italy
71 458
15 667
74 056
34 850
26 137
8712
3133
Lebanon
4687
2306
5944
2797
2098
699
461
Libya
7305
5079
10 527
4954
3715
1238
1016
Malta
502
138
543
256
192
64
28
Morocco
38 038
23 366
52 194
24 562
18 421
6140
4673
Syria
21 957
17 434
33 482
15 756
11 817
3939
3487
Slovenia
2479
547
2573
1211
908
303
109
Spain
49 873
11 814
52 433
24 675
18 506
6169
2363
Tunisia
12 552
5321
15 193
7149
5362
1787
1064
Turkey
88 343
39 930
109 032
51 309
38 482
12 827
7986
Mediter
551 667
243 053
675 512
317 888
238 416
79 472
48 611
Table 5 Excess cost of undiagnosed symptomatic celiac patients
Purchasing power parity
Standardized cost for an adult in 6 yr of delay, €
Standardized cost for a child in 2 yr of delay, €
Total cost for adults in the next 10 yr, €
Total cost for children in the next 10 yr, €
Total cost of symptomatic in the next 10 yr, €
Albania
7.164
2804
821
11 698 575
1 481 020
13 179 595
Algeria
6.869
2688
787
107 662 164
15 748 296
123 410 460
Bosnia
7.361
2881
844
16 673 654
1 176 265
17 849 919
Cyprus
17.7
6928
2029
7 468 819
741 246
8 210 065
Croatia
28.54
11 171
3272
60 057 866
4 613 886
64 671 751
Egypt
6.123
2396
702
233 320 214
44 609 799
277 930 013
France
33.68
13 181
3861
1 037 513 563
97 017 277
1 134 530 840
Greece
29.88
11 695
3426
155 520 664
10 627 416
166 148 080
Israel
28.39
11 112
3255
95 985 202
15 284 247
111 269 450
Italy
29.11
11 393
3337
814 080 086
52 279 538
866 359 625
Lebanon
14.23
5568
1631
26 097 336
3 761 033
29 858 369
Libya
14.33
5608
1643
40 966 178
8 342 757
49 308 935
Malta
23.58
9230
2704
4 630 407
372 044
5 002 450
Morocco
4.604
1802
528
68 540 194
12 332 575
80 872 769
Syria
4.7
1839
539
40 388 186
9 393 156
49 781 342
Slovenia
29.69
11 619
3403
28 807 411
1 862 767
30 670 178
Spain
33.7
13 189
3863
657 786 976
45 639 366
703 426 342
Tunisia
8.254
3230
946
40 548 541
5 035 255
45 583 796
Turkey
12.48
4883
1430
431 358 582
57 108 945
488 467 527
Mediter
17.92
7012
2054
3 879 104 619
387 426 887
4 266 531 506
Table 6 Excess mortality in undiagnosed cases2
Projected prevalence of CD in the next 10 yr
Death rate, deaths/1000 individuals
Population expected deaths (next 10 yr)
Celiac deaths in next 10 yr
Excess celiac deaths in next 10 yr
Albania
38 223
5.1
193 793
3488
1550
Algeria
380 330
4.6
1 764 730
31 765
14 118
Bosnia
47 483
8.6
409 780
7376
3278
Cyprus
9372
6.4
59 982
1080
480
Croatia
44 682
11.8
525 018
9450
4200
Egypt
999 311
4.9
4 876 635
87 779
39 013
France
676 627
8.6
5 791 930
104 255
46 335
Greece
108 598
10.5
1 141 363
20 545
9131
Israel
83 943
5.4
455 811
8205
3646
Italy
578 536
10.7
6 201 905
111 634
49 615
Lebanon
44 342
6
267 382
4813
2139
Libya
76 534
3.4
260 982
4698
2088
Malta
4200
8.4
35 193
633
282
Morocco
383 098
4.7
1 815 883
32 686
14 527
Syria
240 864
3.7
896 013
16 128
7168
Slovenia
20 091
9.2
184 839
3327
1479
Spain
408 177
10
4 077 691
73 398
32 622
Tunisia
114 472
5.2
595 256
10 715
4762
Turkey
818 050
6
4 908 301
88 349
39 266
Mediter
5 076 934
7
34 462 486
620 325
275 700
Citation: Greco L, Timpone L, Abkari A, Abu-Zekry M, Attard T, Bouguerrà F, Cullufi P, Kansu A, Micetic-Turk D, Mišak Z, Roma E, Shamir R, Terzic S. Burden of celiac disease in the Mediterranean area. World J Gastroenterol 2011; 17(45): 4971-4978