Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2025.
World J Meta-Anal. Mar 18, 2025; 13(1): 98933
Published online Mar 18, 2025. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v13.i1.98933
Table 2 Characteristics of participants
Ref.Sample sizePsychiatric morbiditiesConcurrent treatment
Past treatment
Outcome scaleResultsSide effectsConclusion
Psychotropics (mg/d)
Psychotherapy
Psychotropics (mg/d)
Psychotherapy
Chaudhary et al[18], 20241Not mentionedFluoxetine 80 mg, Aripiprazole 2 mgNot mentionedYes (details not mentioned)Not mentionedYBOCS, MGH-HPS, and CGI-I56% and 80% reduction in YBOCS and MGH-HPS scores, respectively. CGI-I scores improved from moderately worse to moderately efficacious. After 6 sessions of maintenance acTBS over 6 weeks, improvement was sustainedNRFirst case report for acute and maintenance acTBS which was well tolerated and effects sustained
Di Ponzio et al[19], 2023147 major depressive disorder, 2 ADHD, 4 GAD, 1 bipolar disorderSelective serotonin reuptake inhibitors: Fluoxetine equivalent of 30 mgNoneYes (details not mentioned)Cortical bone trajectory MGH-HPS and SDQMean percentage of improvement was 58.2% in MGH-HPS and 17.1% in SDQ. No significant reduction after 1 month follow-up. Linear regression analysis indicated no age effect between pre- and post-intervention. Worsening of MGH-HPS scores was at follow-up in older age groupNRPositive outcomes suggest implications for reward circuits, which are usually used for addictions. This is consistent with the emerging view that obsessive-compulsive and related disorders are behavioral addictions. Worsening of MGH-HPS scores at follow-up in the older age group indicates reduced plasticity in elderly
Aydin et al[17], 20205Case 1 ADHD; Case 2 none; Case 3 none; Case 4 GAD; Case 5 bipolar type II, obsessive-compulsive disorder, alcohol abuse, specific phobiaCase 1 Methylphenidate 36 mg; Case 2 no psychotropics; Case 3 Fluoxetine 80 mg; Case 4 Fluoxetine 20 mg; Case 5 Sertraline 100 mg, Aripiprazole 5 mg, Quetiapine 150 mgNone in all casesCase 1 Fluoxetine 20 mg; Case 2 Escitalopram 20 mg; Case 3 Fluoxetine 80 mg, N-acetyl cystine 1200 mg; Case 4 no; Case 5 noYes in case 1 and case 3MGH-HPS, Beck’s anxiety inventory, Beck’s depression inventoryThree patients had substantial benefit (100%, 75%, and 70% improvement in MGH-HSP), one patient had 33% improvement. The last patient experienced a mild increase in the severityTransient flashes in eye for 2-3 session in one caseRepetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation was effective in 3 of 5 patients. One was a partial responder, and the other nonresponder might have been due to multiple comorbidities that acted as confounding factors
Kar et al[21], 20202Not mentionedCase 1 Escitalopram 30 mg; Case 2 Sertraline 200 mgHabit reversal therapyNot mentionedNot mentionedMGH-HPSReduction of 66.6% and 73.6% in both cases, respectively. Case 1 sustained benefits for 6 weeks, while case 2 was maintained well for 2 months then experienced worsening which improved with psychotherapy for 6 monthsNRReduction in symptom severity and therapy was well tolerated