Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Clin Cases. Nov 6, 2021; 9(31): 9520-9534
Published online Nov 6, 2021. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v9.i31.9520
Table 1 Basic characteristics of included studies
Ref.
Year
Nation
Men, n (%)
Age (yr)
BMI (kg/m2)/BMI z-score
Detection methods
Cut-off
n
TP (a)
FP (b)
FN (c)
TN (d)
Chume et al[42]2019Brazil40.553.4128.91GlycoGap, Poway, CA14.8%242505727108
Furusyo et al[52]2011Japan29.849.922.2Lucica GA-L, Japan15.5%157560251121252
He et al[47]2017China55.255.024.9Lucica GA-L, Japan17.1%128762912363283
Ikezaki et al[48]2015Japan32.059.023.1Lucica GA-L, Japan15.2%90836562291
Lang et al[37]2018China020-30 wk2Not givenEnzymatic method,Japan13.5%276104423595
Liu et al[38]2020China024-28 wk25.1LST 00814.2%26166762099
Ma et al[53]2010China45.453.124.2Lucica GA-L, Japan17.1%1971580281175935
Pimentel et al[40]2020Brazil53.046.1 26.0 GlycoGap, Diazyme Laboratories16.5%13417161685
Shima et al[54]1989Japan83.347.7Not givenHPLC21.6%30240219232
Su et al[46]2018China46.750.524.7Lucica GA-L, Japan16.3%69122659109297
Su et al[45]2019China46.250.4 24.7Lucica GA-L, Japan17.1%70119040160311
Tommerdah et al[44]2019United States41.014.2−0.023Lucica GA-L, Japan14.0%5825744
Wang et al[41]2020China69.536.0 20.6Not given14.6%21012249165
Wu et al[33]2016Taiwan40.050.424.3Lucica GA-L, Japan15.0%155998208341219
Zemlin et al[43]2019South Africa25.847.828.7Werfen, Italy14.9%12946277321123
Zhang et al[50]2014China49.550.225.0Lucica GA-L, Japan16.6%392943337228
Zheng[51]2012China52.751.9Not givenEnzymatic method, Japan17.5%5092231695175
Zhuang et al[39]2019China024-28 wk20.6Colorimetric method11.5%357145944177
Hwang et al[49]2014South Korea58.552.524.8Lucica GA-L, Japan14.3%85221063106473