Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2022.
World J Clin Cases. Dec 6, 2022; 10(34): 12594-12604
Published online Dec 6, 2022. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v10.i34.12594
Table 1 Basic characteristics of the studies included
Ref.
Country
Sample size
Age (range, yr)
Diagnosis
Research type
Methods
TP
FP
FN
TN
Singhal and Danks[16], 2022Australia6862 (21-87)TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D CISS50378
Jia et al[17], 2016China9549.2HFSProspective3D TOF MRA + 3D CISS94001
Xie et al[9], 2014China9056.8 (31-76)TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D CISS81063
Shi et al[18], 2022China4049.6 (24-66)HFSRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA35041
Jiang et al[10], 2022China4953.1 (30-77)TNProspective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA48001
Wei et al[11], 2020China14656 (32-83)TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA1290143
Guo et al[19], 2018China3655.8 (31-80)TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA33012
3151.5 (39-64)HFS3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA28111
Liu et al[12], 2016China5253.7 (35-72)TNProspective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA44053
Zeng et al[13], 2013China3756.3 (22-81)TNProspective3D TOF MRA + 3D FIESTA35011
Xia et al[20], 2015China10651.9 (26-81)TN/HFSRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D SPACE97027
Müller et al[14], 2020Germany3859.63 ± 13.56TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + bSSFP/FSE31007
Vergani et al[15], 2011United Kingdom6759.8 (32-84)TNRetrospective3D TOF MRA + 3D TSE DRIVE60133