Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2022.
World J Clin Cases. Jun 16, 2022; 10(17): 5690-5701
Published online Jun 16, 2022. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v10.i17.5690
Table 3 Methodological quality evaluation of included literature
Ref.
Randomization method
Blind method
Concealment
Integrity of result data
Selective reporting of results
Other bias
Zhang et al[15], 2008Just mentioned randomNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Li et al[16], 2012Random number tableNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Zhang et al[17], 2015Not mentionedNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Li et al[18], 2016Just mentioned randomNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Wang et al[19], 2016Just mentioned randomNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Jiang et al[20], 2017Random number tableDouble blindUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Liu et al[21], 2017Not mentionedNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataLow riskUnclear
Chen et al[22], 2018Not mentionedDouble blindUnclearComplete dataUnclearUnclear
Shi et al[23], 2018Random number tableNot mentionedUnclearComplete dataUnclearUnclear