Systematic review on the use of autologous matrix-induced chondrogenesis for the repair of articular cartilage defects in patients

Table 4 Summary of detailed magnetic resonance imaging evaluation results if provided from studies that reported Magnetic resonance Observation of Cartilage Repair Tissue scores

Number and percentage of patients that achieved a particular result for each category of the MOCART scoring system
Scoring measure	Outcome	Buda et al[15]		Dhollander et al[16]		Dhollander et al[13]		Kusano et al[22]		Leunig et al[23]		Valderrabano et al[17]		Wiewiorski et al[25]		Dhollander et al[29]
		No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	No. of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.	No. of Pts.	% of Pts.
Degree of defect repair	Complete	14	70%	0	0%	1	20%	3	19%	4	100%	9	35%	8	35%	2	20%
	Hypertrophy	4	20%	2	40%	2	40%	3	19%	0	0%	13	50%	12	52%	2	20%
	Incomplete	2	10%	3	60%	2	40%	10	63%	0	0%	4	15%	3	13%	6	60%
Integration to the Surrounding Cartilage	Complete	16	80%	4	80%	1	20%	8	50%	4	100%	9	35%	8	35%	4	40%
	Incomplete	2	10%	0	0%	4	80%	4	25%	0	0%	9	35%	0	0%	2	20%
	Defect visible	2	10%	1	20%	0	0%	4	25%	0	0%	8	31%	15	65%	4	40%
Surface of the Repaired tissue	Intact	14	70%	0	0%	1	20%	2	13%	3	75%	17	65%	15	65%	3	30%
	Damaged	6	30%	5	100%	4	80%	14	88%	1	25%	9	35%	8	35%	7	70%
Structure of the Repaired tissue	Homogeneous	6	30%	0	0%	0	0%	0	0%	1	25%	7	27%	6	26%	4	40%
	Inhomogeneous	14	70%	5	100%	5	100%	16	100%	3	75%	19	73%	17	74%	6	60%
Signal Intensity DPFSE	Isointense	13	65%	0	0%	2	40%	1	6%	2	50%	4	15%	3	13%	1	10%
	Hyperintense	7	35%	5	100%	2	40%	15	94%	1	25%	18	69%	17	74%	6	60%
	Hypointense	0	0%	0	0%	1	20%	0	0%	1	25%	4	15%	3	13%	3	30%
Subchondral lamina	Intact	6	30%	0	0%	0	0%	3	19%	1	25%	9	35%	8	35%	0	0%
	Not intact	14	70%	5	100%	5	100%	13	81%	3	75%	17	65%	15	65%	10	100%
Subchondral bone	Intact	6	30%	0	0%	1	20%	4	25%	2	50%	3	12%	3	13%	6	60%
	Not intact	14	70%	5	100%	4	80%	12	75%	2	50%	23	88%	20	87%	4	40%
Adhesions	No	20	100%	5	100%	5	100%	15	94%	3	75%	26	100%	23	100%	10	100%
	Yes	0	0%	0	0%	0	0%	1	6%	1	25%	0	0%	0	0%	0	0%
Effusion	No	17	85%	5	100%	3	60%	6	38%	4	100%	25	96%	22	96%	7	70%
	Yes	3	15%	0	0%	2	40%	10	63%	0	0%	1	4%	1	4%	3	30%