Systematic review of bone marrow stimulation for osteochondral lesion of talus - evaluation for level and quality of clinical studies

Table 3 Outcome of modified Coleman methodology scores

Ref.	Part A							Part B			Total
	1 Study size - number of patients	2 Mean follow-up (mo)	3 No. of different surgical procedures included in each reported outcome	4 Type of study	5 Diagnostic certainty (MRI)	6 Description of surgical procedure given	7 Description of postoperative rehabilitation	1 Outcome criteria	2 Procedure for assessing outcomes	3 Description of subject selection process
[23]	7	5	10	0	5	3	10	8	5	5	58
[29]	0	5	10	0	0	5	10	10	5	5	50
[5]	10	5	10	0	5	5	10	8	5	0	58
[3]	10	5	10	0	5	5	10	8	8	0	61
[32]	10	5	10	0	5	5	5	6	3	8	57
[24]	10	5	10	0	5	5	10	10	9	3	67
[18]	10	5	10	0	5	5	10	8	3	0	56
[4]	10	5	10	0	5	3	10	6	8	0	57
[16]	4	5	10	0	0	3	0	8	5	3	38
[13]	4	5	0	10	5	5	10	10	9	3	61
[18]	4	5	10	0	5	5	5	6	5	0	45
[30]	7	5	10	0	5	5	10	10	9	8	69
[20]	4	2	10	0	5	3	5	10	9	8	56
[21]	10	5	10	15	5	5	10	10	9	10	89
[17]	4	5	10	0	5	5	5	8	5	3	50
[31]	7	5	10	0	5	5	10	10	5	8	65
[25]	7	5	10	0	0	3	5	10	12	5	57
[26]	4	5	10	0	5	3	10	10	5	0	52
[27]	7	5	10	0	5	3	10	8	8	10	66
[28]	7	5	10	0	5	3	10	8	5	3	56
[22]	4	2	10	0	5	5	5	8	9	0	48
[7]	10	5	0	0	5	0	10	10	5	5	50
mean	6.8	4.7	9.1	1.1	4.3	4	8.2	8.6	6.6	4	57.5
SD	3	0.9	2.9	3.8	1.8	1.3	2.9	1.4	2.4	3.5	10.2

MRI: Magnetic resonance imaging.