Investigational growth factors utilized in animal models of spinal fusion: Systematic review

doi:10.5312/wjo.v10.i4.176

Advanced Search

BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge

Home / Archive / Volume 10, Issue 4

This Article

Academic Content and Language Evaluation of This Article

CrossCheck and Google Search of This Article

Academic Rules and Norms of This Article

Supplementary Materials of This Article

Citation of this article

Corresponding Author of This Article

Research Domain of This Article

Article-Type of This Article

Open-Access Policy of This Article

Times Cited Counts in Google of This Article

Number of Hits and Downloads for This Article

Total Article Views (9508)

All Articles published online

The chart showing PDF series, WORD series, HTML series, Figures (1-1) series, Tables (1-4) series.

Item

Count

PDF

736

WORD

195

HTML

5617

Figures (1-1)

373

Tables (1-4)

365

Sum=7286

Publishing Process of This Article

The chart showing Browse series, Download series.

Item

Count

Browse

1044

Download

1178

Sum=2222

Apr 18, 2019 (publication date) through Jan 26, 2025

Times Cited of This Article

Times Cited (16)

Journal Information of This Article

Publication Name

World Journal of Orthopedics

ISSN

2218-5836

Publisher of This Article

Baishideng Publishing Group Inc, 7041 Koll Center Parkway, Suite 160, Pleasanton, CA 94566, USA

Systematic Review

World J Orthop. Apr 18, 2019; 10(4): 176-191
Published online Apr 18, 2019. doi: 10.5312/wjo.v10.i4.176

Table 4 Experimental models and rates of bony fusion for each included study

Growth factor	Animal(n)	Levels (a/p)¹	Experimental groups	Fusion rate
AB204
Zheng et al[32], 2017	Dog (n = 56)	L1-L2, L4-L5 (p)	(1) BCP; (2) BCP + rhBMP-2; (3) BCP + AB204	(1) 6.3%; (2) 15%; (3) 90%²
COMP-Ang-1
Park et al[33], 2011	Rat (n = 56)	L3-L5 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) ICBG + bovine serum albumin-impregnated collagen sponge; (3) ICBG + COMP-Ang-1-impregnated collagen sponge	(2) 38.9%; (2) 42.1%; (3) 89.5%²
Calcitonin
Babat et al[34], 2005	Rabbit (n = 56)	L5-L6 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) ICBG + calcitonin; (3) ICBG + pamidronate	(1) 56%; (2) 68%; (3) 37%
Liu et al[35], 2012	Rabbit (n = 32)	L4-L5, L6-L7 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) ICBG + calcitonin; (3) ICBG + interspinous fixation (steel wire); (4) ICBG + interspinous fixation (steel wire) + calcitonin	(1) 75%; (2) 100%; (3) 75% 100%
Liu et al[36], 2015	Rat (n = 50)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) Sham surgery + saline vehicle; (2) Ovariectomy + saline vehicle; (3) Spinal fusion (ICBG) + saline vehicle; (4) Ovariectomy + Spinal fusion (ICBG); (5) Ovariectomy + Spinal fusion (ICBG) + calcitonin	Not reported
EPO
Rolfing et al[37], 2011	Rabbit (n = 28)	L5-L6 (p)	(1) ICBG + Epoetin beta subcutaneous injection; (2) ICBG + Saline subcutaneous injection	(1) 86%; (2) 71%
bFGF
Inoue et al[38], 2017	Rat (n = 20)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) Allograft; (2) Allograft + bFGF	Not reported
GDF-5
Spiro et al[39], 2000	Baboon (n = 36)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) Collagen matrix strips; (3) Collagen matrix strips + rhGDF-5 (500μg/cm³); (4) Collagen matrix strips + rhGDF-5 (1500μg/cm³)	(1) 22%; (2) 0%; (3) 44%; (4) 11%
Spiro et al[40], 2001	Rabbit (n = 31)	L5-L6 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) Hydroxyapatite-mineralized collagen matrix (Matrix); (3) Matrix + bone marrow; (4) Healos strips + rhGDF-5 (0.1 mg/cc); (5) Healos strips + rhGDF-5 (1.0 mg/cc); (6) Non-crosslinked collagen strips + rhGDF-5 (0.1 mg/cc); (7) Non-crosslinked collagen strips + rhGDF-5 (1.0 mg/cc); (8) Collagen fiber slurry + rhGDF-5 (0.1 mg/cc); (9) Collagen fiber slurry + rhGDF-5 (1.0 mg/cc)	(1) 33%; (2) 0%; (3) 0%; (4) 0%; (5) 67%; (6) 75%; (7) 80%; (8) 25%; (9) 0%
Jahng et al[41], 2004	Sheep (n = 8)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) Healos + GDF-5	(1)100%; (2) 100%
Magit et al[42], 2006	Rabbit (n = 65)	L5-L6 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) Healos; (3) Healos + rhGDF-5 (0.5 mg/cc); (4) Healos + rhGDF-5 (1 mg/cc); (5) Healos + rhGDF-5 (1.5 mg/cc)	(1) 38%; (2) 0%; (3) 100%²; (4) 100%²; (5) 100%²
IGF-1/TGF-β
Kandziora et al[43], 2002	Sheep (n = 32)	C3-C4 (a)	(1) Titanium cage (Cage); (2) Cage + ICBG; (3) Cage + PDLLA + BMP-2; (4) Cage + PDLLA + rh-IGF-1/TGF-β	(1) 0%; (2) 13%; (3) 13%; (4) 13%
Kandziora et al[44], 2002	Sheep (n = 32)	C3-C4 (a)	(1) ICBG; (2) Titanium cage (Cage); (3) Cage + PDLLA; (4) Cage + PDLLA + rh-IGF-1/TGF-β	(1) 0%; (2) 0%; (3) 0%; (4) 12.5%
Kandziora et al[45], 2003	Sheep (n = 32)	C3-C4 (a)	(1) Titanium cage + PDLLA (Cage); (2) Cage + rh-IGF-1/TGF-β (2.5/0.5%); (3) Cage + rh-IGF-1/TGF-β (5/1%); (4) Cage + rh-IGF-1/TGF-β (10/2%)	Not reported
Gu et al[46], 2006	Goat (n = 32)	C3-C4 (a)	(1) ICBG; (2) Titanium cage (Cage); (3) Cage + hydroxyapatite; (4) Cage + IGF-1/TGF-β (5/1%)	(1) 0%; (2) 25%; (3) 38%; (4) 63%
Insulin
Koerner et al[47], 2013	Rat (n = 19)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) ICBG + 100% palmitic acid; (2) ICBG + Linplant (95% palmitic acid and 5% bovine insulin)	(1) 11%; (2) 60%²
NELL-1
Lee et al[48], 2009	Rat (n = 10)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) Demineralized bone putty (Putty) + PBS; (2) Putty + rh-NELL-1	(1) 0%; (2) 60%
Li et al[49], 2010	Rat (n = 24)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) DBX + PBS; (2) DBX + NELL-1 (2.5 g); (3) DBX + NELL-1 (5 μg)	(1) 25%; (2) 75%; (3) 88%
Siu et al[50], 2011	Sheep (n = 32)	L3-L4 L5-L6 (a)	(1) Cage + DBM; (2) Cage + inactivated DBM; (3) Cage + DBM + NELL-1 (0.3 mg/mL) Cage + DBM + NELL-1 (0.6 mg/mL); (4) Cage + inactivated; (5) DBM + NELL-1 (0.3 mg/mL); (6) Cage + inactivated DBM + NELL-1 (0.3 mg/mL)	(1) 50%; (2) 50%; (3) 87.5%²; (4) 100%²; (5) 100%²; (6) 100%²
Yuan et al[51], 2013	Rat (n = 26)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) DBX + PBS; (2) DBX + NELL-1 (10μg); (3) DBX + NELL-1 (50μg); (4) Acellular collagen sponge (ACS) + PBS; (5) ACS + BMP-2; (6) ICBG	(1) 20%; (2) 100%; (3) 100%; (4) 0%; (5) 100%; (6) 0%
James et al[20], 2017	Macaque (n = 12)	L3-L4 L5-L6 (a)	(1) Cage + aTCP; (2) Cage + DBX + rh-NELL-1-loaded aTCP (1mg/mL); (3) Cage + DBX + rh-NELL-1-loaded aTCP (1.7mg/mL)	(1) 25%; (2) 25%; (3) 100%
Noggin
Klineberg et al[52], 2014	Rabbit (n = 25)	L5-L6 (p)	(1) ICBG + Noggin scrambled siRNA bilateral; (2) ICBG + scrambled siRNA one side + siRNA other side; (3) ICBG + functional siRNA bilateral	(1) - (2) - (3) 50%
P-15
Sherman et al[53], 2010	Sheep (n = 12)	L3-L5 (a)	(1) PEEK + ICBG; (2) PEEK + anorganic bovine-derived matrix/P-15	(1) 83%; (2)100%
Peptide B2A
Smucker et al[54], 2008	Rabbit (n = 45)	L4-L5 (p)	(1) ICBG; (2) ICBG + TCP (1:1); (3) ICBG + B2A (50 μg); (4) ICBG + B2A (100 μg); (5) ICBG + B2A (300 μg)	(1) 25%; (2) 22%; (3) 56%; (4) 78%² (vs A and B); (5) 40%
Cunningham et al[55], 2009	Sheep (n = 40)	L2-L3 L4-L5 (a)	(1) PEEK + ICBG; (2) PEEK + ICBG + B2A (50 μg); (3) PEEK + ICBG + B2A (100 μg); (4) PEEK + ICBG + B2A (300 μg); (5) PEEK + ICBG + B2A (600 μg)	(1) 63%; (2) 88%; (3) 88%; (4) 88%; (5) 75%
SPP24
Sintuu et al[56], 2011	Rat		(1) Collagen sponge (Sponge); (2) Sponge + rhBMP-2; (3) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP24 (100 μg); (4) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP24 (500 μg); (5) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP24 (1 mg); (6) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP24 (2.5 mg); (7) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP18 (100 μg); (8) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP18 (500 μg); (9) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP18 (1 mg); (10) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (1 μg) + SPP18 (2.5 mg); (11) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP24 (100 μg); (12) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP24 (500 μg); (13) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP24 (1 mg); (14) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP24 (2.5 mg); (15) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP18 (100 μg); (16) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP18 (500 μg); (17) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP18 (1 mg); (18) Sponge + rhBMP-2 (10 μg) + SPP18 (2.5 mg)	(1) 0%; (2) 100%²; (3) 0%; (4) 0%; (5) 0%; (6) 0%; (7) 0%; (8) 0%; (9) 0%; (10) 0%; (11) 0%; (12) 0%; (13) 0%; (14) 0%; (15) 0%; (16) 0%; (17) 0%; (18) 0%

¹(a/p): anterior/posterolateral surgical approach; N²: Statistically significant compared to all other experimental groups. ICBG: Iliac crest bone graft. BCP: Biphasic calcium phosphate; rhBMP-2: Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein 2; bFGF: Basic fibroblast growth factor; GDF-5: Growth differentiation factor 5; PDLLA: Poly-D, L-lactide; TGF: Transforming growth factor; IGF: Insulin-like growth factor.

Citation: Cottrill E, Ahmed AK, Lessing N, Pennington Z, Ishida W, Perdomo-Pantoja A, Lo SF, Howell E, Holmes C, Goodwin CR, Theodore N, Sciubba DM, Witham TF. Investigational growth factors utilized in animal models of spinal fusion: Systematic review. World J Orthop 2019; 10(4): 176-191
URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/2218-5836/full/v10/i4/176.htm
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.5312/wjo.v10.i4.176