Frontier
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Gastrointest Surg. Oct 27, 2021; 13(10): 1110-1121
Published online Oct 27, 2021. doi: 10.4240/wjgs.v13.i10.1110
Table 4 Summary of comparative studies: Long-term oncological outcomes
Ref.1-year OS, %
3-year OS, %
5-year OS, %
1-year DFS, %
3-year DFS, %
5-year DFS, %
LLR
OLR
P
LLR
OLR
P
LLR
OLR
P
LLR
OLR
P
LLR
OLR
P
LLR
OLR
P
Belli et al[5]9485NS6753NS7879NS5252NS
Tranchart et al[6]93.181.8NS74.473NS59.547.4NS81.670.2NS60.954.3NS45.637.2NS
Lee et al[7]86.998NS81.880.6NS7676.1NS78.869.2NS5155.9NS45.355.9NS
Ahn et al[8]80.185.7NS67.854.8NS
Memeo et al[9]8863NS5944NS8060NS1923NS
Lee et al[10]95.393.9NS89.789.5NS89.787.3NS60.581.5NS60.366.7NS60.358.6NS
Yoon et al[11]9598NS8684NS8288NS6362NS
Xiao et al[12]95.189.5NS7876.7NS87.882.6NS70.768.6NS
Sposito et al[13]7579NS3846NS4144NS2511NS
Cheung et al[14]10093NS85.684.1NS69.177.6NS9569.2NS72.861.5NS51.861.5NS
Ryu et al[15]89.989.9NS84.768NS70.963.1NS79.572.4NS5856.1NS42.550.4NS
Rhu et al[16]96.896.8NS94.594.5NS94.594.5NS77.877.8NS68.368.3NS62.562.5NS
Guro et al[17]77.360.2NS50.840.1NS
El-Gendi et al[18]8884NS58.754NS
Inoue et al[19]97.887.9NS78.870.6NS83.875NS57.554.8NS
Kim et al[20]93.993.879.691.1NS
Deng et al[21]96.296.8NS72.673.4NS45.346.9NS90.591.7NS53.754.4NS24.619.9NS
Wu et al[22]9381.4NS81.475.5NS69.862.8NS75.669.8NS60.553.5NS44.238.4NS
Tsai et al[23]90.3850.00282.963.60.00278.157.60.00272.960.8NS49.243NS37.931NS
Di Sandro et al[24]68764444NS
Li et al[25]96.395.3NS68.490.5NS8487.2NS3659.7NS
Kim et al[26]94.4100NS94.492.9NS93.876.5NS56.341.3NS
Chen et al[27]69.874NS51.657.8NS
Untereiner et al[28]7879NS7258.6NS
Yoon et al[29]98.193.8NS8790.8NS78.684.3NS8185.3NS6264.7NS49.156.2NS
Peng et al[30]95.892.87777NS71.979.1NS51.446.2NS
Yamamoto et al[31]8278.4NS58.962.3NS52.640.3NS2424.1NS
Lee et al[32]96.692.8NS73.393.1NS88.876.1NS84.464NS60.293.1NS67.463.9NS
Navarro et al[33]9090NS5840NS
Delvecchio et al[34]10095NS10088NS7775NS6779NS4454NS2946NS
Ho et al[35]95.687.50.03684.970.30.03684.961.10.03680.073.3NS40.041.1NS20.022.2NS