Review
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastrointest Endosc. Jul 10, 2015; 7(8): 777-789
Published online Jul 10, 2015. doi: 10.4253/wjge.v7.i8.777
Table 1 Advantages and disadvantages of different suturing patterns
SuturingPatternProsCons
Interrupted/ simpleLess tissue drag during tightening of the suture compared to a running suture No risk of suture crossing and entanglement as described for running suture Any failure during suturing would only involve the most recently placed interrupted suture rather than the entire suturing work up to that point as is the case with running sutures Suture failure after termination of the procedure would only involve a small segment of the closure without the risk of dehiscence of the entire closure that exists with running suturesApproximation of the defect edges occurs as soon as the first interrupted suture is tightened and may limit good visualization and grasping of the edges of the nearly closed defect thus making placement of the subsequent interrupted sutures difficult or inaccurate Substantial increase in cost proportionate to the number of sutures used as discussed under running sutures
Figure of 8Specialized suture used to close small circular defect in a circular fashion with equal circumferential anisotropic compression towards the center of the defect. Thus, it may be the optimal suturing pattern for fistula closure or oversewing an ulcer containing large vessel(s) at risk for bleedingTechnically more challenging than interrupted sutures Risk of suture entanglement Any suture failure (e.g., erosion through tissue, breakage) would result in slack along the entire suture and result in dehiscence of the entire closure
RunningAllows clear visibilty of the defect edges until the suturing is completed Less expensive as it uses only one suture and cinch (in the United States, for the OverStitch platform, each additional suture+cinch adds approximately $100)Tissue drag caused by the suture going through multiple bites of tissue requires gentle slow careful technique during tightening of the suture prior to cinching Avoiding entanglement of the long suture leading to the start of the suture line during placement of the transverse sutures across the defect requires careful technique and experience Any error such as accidental drop of the needle, fraying and breakage of the suture or device failure results in loss of the entire work up to that point with the need to start the closure from the beginning Similarly, any suture failure after termination of the procedure (e.g., suture eroding through tissue prematurely or breaking) would result in failure of the entire closure