Copyright
©The Author(s) 2018.
World J Gastrointest Endosc. Dec 16, 2018; 10(12): 422-441
Published online Dec 16, 2018. doi: 10.4253/wjge.v10.i12.422
Published online Dec 16, 2018. doi: 10.4253/wjge.v10.i12.422
# | STUDY | Randomized? (1 pt) | Randomization method | Adequate randomization? (1 pt) | Double blind? (1 pt) | Masking method | Adequate masking? (1 pt) | Loss description? (1 pt) | Jadad (0-5 pts) | GENERAL QUALITY |
1 | Regev et al[34] | Yes | Randomization per patients' ID (odd or even numbers) | No | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 2 | Intermidiate |
2 | Lawrance et al[35] | Yes | Randomized using Generator Pro 1.69 (Segobit software) in ratio 2:1:1 (PEG:NaP:Pico) | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
3 | Kao et al[36] | Yes | Randomization in blocks of 8 and stratified per AM/PM using a computer-generated table | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
4 | Katz et al[15] | Yes | Randomization numbers allocated sequentially by voice system | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
5 | Manes et al[37] | Yes | Randomization by computer-generated sequence | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
6 | Rex et al[15] | Yes | Randomization numbers allocated sequentially by voice system | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
7 | Jeon et al[38] | Yes | Randomization by computer-generated table | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
8 | Kang et al[39] | Yes | Randomization in blocks using website randomization.com | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
9 | Kim et al[40] | Yes | Not described | No | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | No | 1 | Low |
10 | Kim et al[41] | Yes | Randomization by computer-generated sequence | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
11 | Leitao et al[28] | Yes | Randomization 1:1 with blocks of 10 by endoscopy-unit secretary | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | No | 2 | Intermidiate |
12 | Kim et al[29] | Yes | Randomization by computer-generated table | Yes | No | Not described | No | No | 2 | Intermidiate |
13 | Munsterman et al[30] | Yes | Randomization by computer-generated 1:1 stratified by age (18-64) or (65-80) | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | No | 2 | Intermidiate |
14 | Pohl et al[31] | Yes | Randomization 1:1 in blocks of 4 by statistician list-generated | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
15 | Yoo et al[32] | Yes | Randomization 1:1 in blocks of 4 by a a computer-generated list | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regimen | No | Yes | 3 | High |
16 | Kojecky et al[33] | Yes | Randomization 1:1 using a software generated random table | Yes | No | Endoscopist blind for the preparation regiment | No | Yes | 3 | High |
- Citation: Rocha RSP, Ribeiro IB, de Moura DTH, Bernardo WM, Minata MK, Morita FHA, Aquino JCM, Baba ER, Miyajima NT, de Moura EGH. Sodium picosulphate or polyethylene glycol before elective colonoscopy in outpatients? A systematic review and meta-analysis. World J Gastrointest Endosc 2018; 10(12): 422-441
- URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1948-5190/full/v10/i12/422.htm
- DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.4253/wjge.v10.i12.422