Review
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Gastroenterol. Jun 21, 2021; 27(23): 3158-3181
Published online Jun 21, 2021. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v27.i23.3158
Table 3 The outcomes of various latest studies comparing laparoscopic pancreaticoduodenectomy with open procedure
Ref.
Study
Comparison
Outcome
Nickel et al[112], 2020 Meta-analysis of 3 RCTsLPD and OPD90-d mortality, post-operative complications and oncological outcomes were similar in both groups
Blood loss was less for LPD
Operating time was more for LPD
Yoo et al[113], 2020Retrospective cohort study 359 patientsLPD and OPDPost-operative complications and hospital stay were shorter for LPD
Operative time was longer for LPD
Recurrence free outcomes andoverall survival rates were similar
Chen et al[114], 2020 Meta-analysis of 6 cohort studiesLPD and OPD for PDANumber of lymph nodes harvested, number of positive lymph nodes, rate of adjuvant therapy, time to adjuvant therapy, 1 yr survival and 2 yr survival are same for both the groups
Zhou et al[115], 2019 Retrospective cohort studyLPD and OPDOverall complications and survival were similar between the two groups
Chen et al[116], 2018 Retrospective cohort study of 102 patientsLPD and OPDIntra-operative blood loss, post-operative recovery and hospital stay were shorter for LPD
Operative time was longer for LPD
Post operative complications were similar in both the groups
Dang et al[117], 2020 Retrospective cohort studyLPD and OPDIntra-operative blood loss, operating time and hospital stay for shorter for LPD
30 d and 90 d mortality rates were better for LPD
Long term survival rates were similar
Palanivelu et al[118], 2017 RCT of 68 patients with periampullary carcinomaLPD and OPDIntra-operative blood loss and hospital stay for shorter for LPD
Operative time was longer for LPD
Post-operative complications were similar in both the groups