Copyright
©The Author(s) 2018.
World J Gastroenterol. Jan 14, 2018; 24(2): 161-169
Published online Jan 14, 2018. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v24.i2.161
Published online Jan 14, 2018. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v24.i2.161
Table 2 Clinical studies comparing drug-eluting beads and conventional transarterial chemombolization
Ref. | Arm | Sample size | Study design | Region | CP(A/B/C) | BCLC(A/B/C) | 1-yr survival |
Lammer et al[40] 2010 | DEB-TACE | 93 | RCT | Europe | 77/16/0 | 24/69/0 | NA |
cTACE | 108 | 89/19/0 | 29/79/0 | ||||
Song et al[43] 2012 | DEB-TACE | 60 | R | South Korea | 56/4/0 | 27/33/0 | 88% |
cTACE | 69 | 62/6/0 | 28/41/0 | 67% | |||
Sacco et al[41] 2011 | DEB-TACE | 33 | RCT | Italy | 29/4/0 | 22/11/0 | 94.10% |
cTACE | 34 | 25/9/0 | 22/12/0 | 90% | |||
Van Malenstein et al[44] 2011 | DEB-TACE | 16 | RCT | Belgium | 14/2/0 | 9/5/2002 | NA |
cTACE | 14 | 14/0/0 | 10/3/2001 | ||||
Golfieri et al[42] 2014 | DEB-TACE | 89 | RCT | Italy | 75/14/0 | 41/26/22 | 86.20% |
cTACE | 88 | 77/11/0 | 41/23/24 | 83.50% | |||
Ferrer et al[45] 2011 | DEB-TACE | 47 | P | Spain | NA | NA | 88% |
cTACE | 25 | NA | NA | 90% | |||
Dhanasekaran et al[46] 2010 | DEB-TACE | 45 | R | United States | 11/12/2022 | NA | 58% |
cTACE | 26 | 11/4/2011 | NA | 31% | |||
Wiggermann et al[47] 2011 | DEB-TACE | 22 | R | Germany | 22/0/0 | 1/17/3 | 70% |
cTACE | 22 | 22/0/0 | 4/15/2 | 55% | |||
Recchia et al[48] 2012 | DEB-TACE | 35 | P | Italy | NA | NA | 63.40% |
cTACE | 70 | NA | NA | 49.30% | |||
Facciorusso et al[49] 2015 | DEB-TACE | 145 | R | Italy | 129/16/0 | 58/81/6 | 85% |
cTACE | 104 | 93/11/0 | 41/63/0 | 92% | |||
Arabi et al[50] 2015 | DEB-TACE | 35 | R | Saudi Arabia | 24/11/0 | NA | 72.70% |
cTACE | 19 | 17/2/0 | NA | 74.50% | |||
Kloeckner et al[51] 2015 | DEB-TACE | 76 | R | Germany | 51/22/3 | 8/34/34 | 45% |
cTACE | 174 | 103/64/7 | 30/59/85 | 52% | |||
Megias et al[52] 2015 | DEB-TACE | 30 | R | Spain | 46.7%a | NA | 68% |
cTACE | 30 | 63.3%a | 58% | ||||
Liu et al[53] 2015 | DEB-TACE | 53 | R | Taiwan | 53/0/0 | 0/53/0 | NA |
cTACE | 64 | 64/0/0 | 6/58/0 | ||||
Scartozzi et al[54] 2010 | DEB-TACE | 64 | R | Italy | 57.1%a | NA | 74% |
cTACE | 87 | 58.6%a | 93% |
- Citation: Facciorusso A. Drug-eluting beads transarterial chemoembolization for hepatocellular carcinoma: Current state of the art. World J Gastroenterol 2018; 24(2): 161-169
- URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1007-9327/full/v24/i2/161.htm
- DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v24.i2.161