Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastroenterol. Dec 14, 2015; 21(46): 13166-13176
Published online Dec 14, 2015. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v21.i46.13166
Table 2 Study design and characteristics of patients and endoscopies
StudyDesignPatient and endoscopic characteristics
Buderus et al[19] (2012)Retrospective 1995-200438 pediatric cancer patients with various GI complaints
40 diagnostic endoscopies, 7 follow-up endoscopies, 10 therapeutic endoscopies
Diagnostic yield 82.5%: Gastritis, esophagitis, duodenitis, colitis, Mallory-Weiss tears, ulcer
Chu et al[17] (1983)Retrospective 1978-1979133 cancer patients with thrombocytopenia and overt GI bleed
187 diagnostic endoscopies, no therapeutic endoscopies
Diagnostic yield 92% for upper, 60% for lower exam: Unifocal and multifocal lesions in majority; rare diffuse bleeding
Gorschlüter et al[20] (2008)Retrospective 1993-2005104 acute leukemia patients after myelosuppressive chemotherapy
131 primary endoscopies, 40 follow-up endoscopies; includes 16 therapeutic interventions and 5 ERCPs (2 for jaundice, 2 for suspicion of cholecystitis, 1 for suspicion of cholangitis)
Diagnostic yield 91% for upper, 70% for lower exam: esophagitis, gastric erosions, hiatal hernia, gastritis
Kaur et al[22] (1996)Retrospective 1986-199343 post-bone marrow transplant patients with overt GI bleed
31 endoscopies total: 26 EGD, 5 colonoscopy; 2 endoscopies required hemostasis
Diagnostic yield 100% for upper, 80% for lower exam: Diffuse esophagitis, gastritis, or duodenitis in upper exam; 2 ulcers, 1 colitis, 1 tumor recurrence in lower exam
Kaur et al[23] (2013)Retrospective 2007-201011 pediatric patient requiring PEG placement in anticipation of BMT (BMT group) compared with 30 patients requiring PEG placement for other indications (comparison group)
Khan et al[24] (2006)Retrospective 1995-2002191 pediatric patients who underwent hematopoietic stem cell transplantation
198 EGDs, 220 lower endoscopies. All diagnostic endoscopies for GI complaints, mostly for nausea, vomiting, and non-bloody diarrhea.
Diagnostic yield 32% for upper, 16% for lower exam:
Mucosal abnormalities most common
Acute GVHD in 14% on histological exam
Non-GVHD histological evidence of inflammation in 24%
Park et al[21] (2010)Retrospective 2002-200732 patients with aplastic anemia and overt GI bleed, each evaluated by endoscopy, 3 of which required therapeutic intervention
Diagnostic yield 66%: bleeding sites in esophagus, stomach, duodenum, small intestine, large intestine
Ross et al[25] (2008)Retrospective 2002-2006112 patients with simultaneous upper and lower endoscopic procedures following hematopoietic stem cell transplant. All diagnostic endoscopies for GI symptoms
Diagnostic yield: GVHD diagnosed in 81% of patients
Schulenburg et al[26] (2004)Prospective cohort 1996-200142 post-allogeneic stem cell transplant patients admitted for GI complaints
22 upper, 12 lower, and 13 upper and lower endoscopies performed, unclear distinction between primary and follow-up endoscopies
Diagnostic yield 100%: Majority GVHD, gastritis, CMV, bacterial enteritis
Schwartz et al[18] (2001)Prospective cohort 1985-1987 and 1996-19971102 patients with hematopoietic cell transplantation followed prospectively, of whom 75 developed severe GI bleed. Endoscopic evaluation included diagnostic and therapeutic procedures, however, number of procedures was unclear
Diagnostic yield: Majority had multiple sites of bleed, caused by GVHD and peptic acid esophageal ulcers
Soylu et al[27] (2005)Prospective cohort 1999-2005451 patients with hematological malignancies, of which 32 developed overt GIB
25 upper GI bleeding episodes, of which 8 EGDs were performed, remainder managed by supportive care. The other 7 patients had lower GI bleed episodes caused by neutropenic enterocolitis excluding the need for endoscopic procedures.
Diagnostic yield 100% (8 endoscopies): Erosive gastritis (5/8), duodenal ulcers (3/8) in upper GI bleed