Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastroenterol. Jul 7, 2015; 21(25): 7895-7906
Published online Jul 7, 2015. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v21.i25.7895
Table 1 Baseline characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis
Ref.YearCountryCutoff(109/L)TherapyAdjusted HRRecurrence typeMenWomenRecurrenceFollow-up time (mo)LoE
Saito et al[32]2014Japan100PH + RFANoOverall38133939.9-46.64
Kaibori et al[19]2013Japan150PHYesOverall601414151.22a
Shiina et al[24]2012Japan100RFAYesDistant75141974038.22b
Nishikawa et al[25]2012Japan100RFAYesDistant114688636.42b
Kao et al[26]2012TaiWan100RFAYesOverall1629616328.52b
Miyatake et al[33]2012Japan100PH + PTAYesOverall26013527742-462b
Ikeda et al[20]2011Japan150RFANoOverall683955124
Amano et al[21]2011Japan100PHNoOverall1272410749.24
Ishikawa et al[31]2011Japan100TACEYesDistant47314636.61b
Hagihara et al[34]2011Japan100PH + PTANoOverall124588144.44
Nonaka et al[22]2010Japan100PHNoOverall422232124
Kang et al[23]2009Korea100PHNoOverall1254278384
Fuke et al[28]2008Japan100RFAYesDistant80379029.12b
Nouso et al[27]2008Japan100RFANoOverall + distant41520658934.74
Jeong et al[35]2007Japan100PH + medicalYesOverall651950322b
Tateishi et al[29]2006Japan100RFANoOverall276140277NR4
Yamanaka et al[30]2005Japan100RFAYesDistant17914182b
Ikeda et al[36]2000Japan100PH + RFANoOverall1378254