Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Gastroenterol. Sep 7, 2014; 20(33): 11886-11893
Published online Sep 7, 2014. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i33.11886
Table 2 Comparison of toxicity between S-1-based chemotherapy and non-S-1-based chemotherapy
ToxicityNumber of TrialsIncidence of toxicity (%)
RR (95%CI)P value
S-1 ArmNon-S-1 Arm
Hematologic
Anemia614.0114.861.150 (0.720-1.837)0.560
Neutropenia617.5424.801.043 (0.451-2.413)0.922
Thrombocytopenia43.915.220.736 (0.499-1.085)0.121
Leukopenia68.879.151.334 (0.524-3.397)0.546
Febrile neutropenia30.863.540.225 (0.126-0.515)0.000
Neutropenic infection30.670.391.450 (0.476-4.424)0.513
Nonhematologic
Fatigue68.678.371.041 (0.788-1.375)0.777
Vomiting54.295.610.769 (0.530-1.114)0.164
Nausea65.917.380.805 (0.583-1.111)0.187
Diarrhea65.243.541.288 (0.590-2.813)0.525
Abdominal pain24.002.761.469 (0.925-2.335)0.103
Anorexia67.446.991.074 (0.790-1.461)0.647
Weight decreased22.003.250.625 (0.369-1.061)0.082
Stomatitis/mucosal inflammation41.5311.810.230 (0.060-0.878)0.032
Liver function30.860.691.221 (0.481-3.103)0.674
Neuropathy, peripheral50.670.890.724 (0.274-1.915)0.515
Alopecia20.380.301.205 (0.300-4.840)0.792
Palmar-plantar erythrodysesthesia40.380.590.719 (0.241-2.150)0.555