Donation after cardio-circulatory death liver transplantation

Table 2 Results of donation after cardio-circulatory death-liver transplantations in single-center studies

Authors study period	Transplant center	Publication year	Patient number and Maastricht category	WIT (min)	CIT (min)	Mean follow-up	PNF %	Major biliary complications %	ITBL %	HAT %	HAS %	Rejection %	Retransplan-tation %	Graft survival %				Patient survival %
														1 yr	3 yr	5 yr	10 yr	1 yr	3 yr	5 yr	10 yr
Casavilla et al[85] 1989-1993	Pittsburgh, United States	1995	6 DCD4	37	10.6 h	-	501	-	-	16.6	-	-	83.3	17	-	-	-	67	-	-	-
			6 DCDc	23.8	11 h	-	01	-	-	33.3	-	-	33.3	50	-	-	-	50	-	-	-
Otero et al[87] 1995-2000	Madrid, Spain	2003	20 DCD2	10	647	> 2 yr	251	301	-	0	-	27	25	80	-	-	-	80	-	-	-
			40 DBD	8	405	-	31	81	-	-	-	34	5	55	-	-	-	83	-	-	-
Quintela et al[86] 1995-2004	Spain	2005	9 DCD2 + 1 DCD4	80	561	-	10	-	-	-	-	-	10	100	-	-	-	100	-	-	-
Suárez et al[89] 1994-2005	Spain	2008	27 DCD2	13	635	> 3 mo	181	41.71	25.01	3.6	-	17.4	-	-	-	491	-	-	-	62	-
			471 DBD	7	-	-	31	16.81	2.31	3.1	-	28.6	-	-	-	681	-	-	-	74	-
Fondevila et al[29] 2002-2006	Barcelona, Spain	2007	10 DCD1	-	399	-	10	10	-	10	-	-	20	50	-	-	-	70	-	-	-
			20 DBD	-	-	-	0	0	-	5	-	-	5	75	-	-	-	80	-	-	-
Jiménez-Galanes et al[71] 2006-2008	Madrid, Spain	2009	20 DCD2	12	432	360 d	10	5	50	0	-	-	11	80	-	-	-	85.5	-	-	-
			40 DBD	6	409	-	2.5	-	-	-	-	-	501	87.5	-	-	-	87.5	-	-	-
Pine et al[72] 2002-2008	St. James, London, United Kingdom	2009	39 DCDc	13.4	352	2.5 yr	5.1	33.31	20.51	2.6	12.81	20.5	7.61	79.51	63.61	-	-	801	68.21	-	-
			39 DBD	-	593	6.6 yr	-	10.21	-	5.1	-	23.1	2.51	97.41	97.41	-	-	1001	11	-	-
de Vera et al[34] 1993-2007	Pittsburgh, United States	2009	141 DCDc	19.8	657	-	121	251	16.31	66	-	-	181	691	-	561	441	79	-	70	57
			282 DBD	-	636	-	31	131	< 11	-	-	-	71	821	-	731	631	85	-	76	64
Yamamoto et al[90] 1984-1988	Stockholm, Sweden	2010	24 DCDc	6	7 h	> 20 yr	8.3	37.51	-	33.31	-	70.8	-	54.2	-	37.5	37.5	61.9	-	42.9	42.9
			16 DBD	-	6.8 h	> 20 yr	18.7	6.31	-	-	-	56.2	-	43.8	-	37.5	37.5	63.6	-	-	54.5
Fujita et al[105] 1990-2006	Gainesville, Floria, United States	2007	24 DCDc	12.8	7.6 h	-	2.8	25	12.5	8.3	-	39.1	20.8	69.1	58.6	-	-	86.8	81.7	-	-
			1209 DBD	-	8.1 h	-	-	20.5	-	4.1	-	-	9.4	78.7	70.2	-	-	84	76	-	-
Foley et al[91] 1993-2002	Wisconsin, United States	2005	36 DCDc	17.8	8.2 h	3 yr	5.5	331	13.8	5.5	16.61	61	19.41	671	561	-	-	801	681	-	-
			553 DBD	-	8.3 h	4.6 yr	1.3	101	8	11.8	5.41	56	71	861	801	-	-	911	841	-	-
Manzarbeitia et al[106] 1995-2002	Philadelphia, United States	2004	19 DCDc	19.6	574	1000 d	5.2	10.5	-	-	-	-	10.5	-	-	-	-	89.5	-	-	-
			311 DBD	-	557	-	-	13.8	-	-	-	-	8.7	-	-	-	-	84.2	-	-	-
Abt et al[104] 1996-2001	Pennsylvania, United States	2003	15 DCDc	20.4	366	819 d	6.7	33.31	26.71	3.2	-	20	6.61	71.8	71.8	-	-	79	79	-	-
			221 DBD	-	464	690 d	3.6	9.51	2.31	-	-	21.3	3.61	85.4	73.9	-	-	90.9	77.7	-	-
Nguyen et al[45] 1998-2001	Mayo Clinic, Floria, United States	2009	19 DCDc	16	6.7 h	> 4.5 yr	5.3	26.3	10.5	0	5.3	5.31	15.8	73.7	68.4	63.2	-	89.5	89.5	89.5	-
			234 ECD	-	7.1 h	-	4.7	22.6	-	-	-	33.31	8.51	-	-	-	-	85	78.6	72.3	-
			214 SCD	-	7.5 h	-	1.7	15.9	-	-	-	33.21	19.61	-	-	-	-	84.3	80.7	76.5	-

DCDc: Controlled donors after cardiac death; DCD₁, DCD₂ and DCD₄: Maastricht category-1, category-2 and category-4 DCD donors; DBD: Donors after brain death; SCD: Standard criteria donors; ECD: Extended criteria donors; WIT: Warm ischemia time; CIT: Cold ischemia time; PNF: Primary non-function; ITBL: Ischemic-type biliary lesions; HAT: Early hepatic artery thrombosis; HAS: Early hepatic artery stenosis. Major symptomatic biliary complications include biliary leak, anastomotic and non-anastomotic stenosis.

¹Numbers denote the statistically significant difference between groups.